!"#$%&%'%&"#()*)(+,-."/0*1"$2&#"3*$-.&#4*5667*
*
!89:;<;=;<89>?*$;@=A;=@BC*(@;<A?B:*D*(EB9FEB9;:*
! "#!$%&'()*+',%!-./%0(!
! ""#!12%34+',%!-./%0(!
! """#!546'3'*)!-./%0(!
! "7#!8%)*+'.9(:';(!*<. 9& !+:%!=+* +%( !
! 7#!><%96<%9+!-0.3%640%(!
! 7"#!?*+'.9*)!@%A+B=4;0%<*3C!D3*+3:E*))F!
! 7""#!8*+'G'3*+'.9!-0.3%640%(!
! H'))!.G!8'&:+(#!!
9.+!%2:*4(+',%!)'(+!!
G%*0!.G!%2;0%('. !49 '4 (!% 2 )4( '.!* )+% 0'4 (#!(% %!> <%96I!"J!
! ><%96<%9+(!
* KC;%(#!! LF!.,%004)'9&!=MNKO=!6%3'('.9(!D%I&IP!LL>!*96!Chisholm(v.(GeorgiaF!
! ! QF!3.00%3+!.0'&'9*)!M.9(+'+4+'.9!D%I&IP!LQ>!*96!;0%G%0%93%!G.0!7-!*96!-0%(!+.!A%!(*<%!;*0+CF!
! ! RF!3:*9&'9&!(.3'*)!*++'+46%(!D%I&IP!LR>!;0.:'A'+'.9!.9!()*,%0CF!
8%3.9(+043+'.9!><%96<%9+(#!LS>!T!-U"P!@-P!1-!
! -0.&0%((',%!10*!
! -.(+!VV""!
M.9(+'+4+'.9*)!W493+'.9(#!(%;*0*+'.9!.G!;./%0(P!G%6%0*)'(<P!'96','64*)!0'&:+( !Dbut(see!(+* + %!* 3 +' . 9 !6 . 3+ 0' 9 %F !
>9+'E<*X.0'+*0'*9!G493+'.9#!;0.+%3+(!<'9.0'+C!0'&:+(!D%(;I!'9!30'('(FP!(:'%)6!).9&!+%0<!,*)4%(!G0.<!(:.0+E+%0<!;*(('.9(!
!
*
!89:;<;=;<89>?*&9;B@G@B;>;<89*
V:%9!'(!'9+%0;0%+*+'.9!9%3%((*0CY!
• /:%9!3.9(+'+4+'.9!6.%(!9.+!%2;0%(()C!3.9('6%0!*9!'((4%!
• /:%0%!+%2+!'(!.;%9E%96%6!
• 6%+%0<'9%!/:%9!&.,%09<%9+!3.93%09(!*0%!(4GG'3'%9+!+.!;%0<'+!'9+%0G%0%93%!/'+:!0'&:+(!
• YF!/:%0%!0'&:+(!*0%!9.9E+%2+4*)!
N0'&'9*)'(<#!!
• W0*<%0Z(!(;%3'G'3!3.93%;+'.9(!N8!D<.6%0*+%F!&%9%0*)!3.93%;+(!
• @0*G+%0(!(;%3'G'3*))CP!N8!D=3*)'*F!.0'&'9*)!<%*9'9&!DG0.<!:'(+.0'3!;0*3+'3%(!*96!496%0(+*96'9&(F!
• 1)C#!9.9.0'&'9*)'(<!'(!.[*C!/:%0%!3.40+!'(!%2%03'('9&!;0.3%640*)!%2;%0+'(%!+.!%9(40%!;.)'+'3*)!;*0+'3';*+'.9P!
*96!(4;;.0+'9&!6%<.30*+'3!'6%*)(!
• =%%9!*(!*!3.9(+0*'9+!.9!+:%!;./%0!.G!X46&%(!
?.9.0'&'9*)'(<!
• M.9(+'+4+'.9!%,.),%(!AC!both!*<%96<% 9 +!* 9 6 !'9 + % 0; 0 % +* +' . 9 P!9 % 3% ( (* 0 C !+. !<%%+!9%%6(!. G!3 : * 9 & '9 & !( . 3'% + C !
• W0*<%0Z(!'9+%9+!'(!%)4(',%!*96!(:*6%6!AC!3.9+%<;.0*0C!,*)4%(P!(.!%,%9!.0'&'9*)'(<!'(!0%*))C!9.9.0'&'9*)'(<!
• K:'(!"=!/:*+!W0*<%0Z(!'9+%96%6P!G.0!%,. ),'9 &!'9+% 0;0 %+*+'. 9(!
V:'3:!A0*93:!(:.4)6!%9&*&%!'9!'9+%0;0%+*+'.9Y!
• >?\#!see!5*3[(.9Z(!,%+. !. G!? * + '. 9 * )!H * 9 [ !3 : * 0 +% 0!0 % 9 % /*)P!see!>++C]%9 !^%%(%Z(!30'+'_ 4 %!. G !X4 6 '3 '* )!( 4 ; 0% <*3C!
• @"7"@1@#!*)).3*+%6!*<.9&!+:%!A0*93:%(P!'9!;0*3+'3%!9./P!see!;.)'+'3*)!_4%( + '. 9 !6 . 3 +0 '9 %!
• 5O@"M">8\ !N ? $ \#!4 <;'0%!0.)%P!MarburyI!!DH4+P!3.4)6!9* 0 0. /!0%*6'9&!. G!Marbury!<%*9!+:* + !X4 6 '3 '* 0C !'( !
(4;0%<%!'9+%0;0%+%0!.G!>0+'3)%!"""!.9)CP!.0!+:*+!'+!3*9!'9+%0;0%+!A4+!(4AX%3+!+.!.+:%0!A0*93:%(YF!
*
*
H8F>?<;<B:*8I*!89:;<;=;<89 > ? *&9 ; B @ G @ B ;> ; <8 9 *
12*<;)%!.G!&..6!)*/C%0'9&#!3C3)%!+:0.4&:!<.6*)'+'%(!*96!G'96!+:%!.9%!+:*+!A%(+!G'+(!C.40!3*(%!
!"#$%&'(&)%"*+,#$&-./0123&atheist(legislator(sues(b/c(of(legislative(chaplain(on(st a te (p a y ro ll(
! `N$@#!9.!,'.)*+'.9!.G!1(+I!M)*4(%P!W0*<%0(!;*'6!G.0!)%&'(!;0*C%0!D'&9.0%(!$%<.9!+%(+F!!
*
.8JB@;*-8:;C*@.3+0'9*)P!`'(+.0'3*)P!8%(;.9(',%!D9.9%2:*4(+',%FI!!&
• 2<:;8@<A>?*H8F>?<;KC**
o Marsh(<*X.0'+CZ(!()*<!649[!DV:*+!V.4)6!+:%!W0*<%0Z(!@.YF*
o N+:%0!;0%((40%(!.9!M.9&0%((!*('6%!G0.<!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)'+C*
o H043%!>3[%0<*9 #!*4*,56&47&%89%,#&:";*"<8593*9.+!_4.+'6'*9!D<.0%!G496*<%9+*)F*
o "9+%9+!.G!0*+'G'%0(!'(!6'GG%0%9+!G0.<!'9+%9 +!.G!)*/ < * [%0( !D%,% 9!'G!(*< %!'9 6','6 4* )!;%. ;)%F *
W0*<%0(Z!'9+%9+!<*9'G%(+%6!'9!W%6%0*)'(+!;*;%0(P!A4+!9.!%,'6%93%!.G!0*+'G'%0(Z!'9+%9+*
o (=;L8@<;K*8I*A89:B9;C*(.3'*)!3.9+0*3+!+:%.0CP!3.9(%9+!+:0.4&:!0*+'G'3*+'.9P!'9:%0'+%6!AC!;0%(%9+!
&%9%0*+'.9I!!*
• M8A;@<9>?*H8F>?<;KC*
o Marsh!6'((%9+#!`%0%P!M.4 0+ !. , % 0). . [(!Lemon!+%(+!D;40;. ( % P!'9 +% 9 + P!%9 + * 9 & )% <%9+F*
o W0.<!(')%93%!*(!+.!;0%3%6%9+P!*((4<%!+:*+!3.40+!'(!3*0,'9&!.4+!*9!%23%;+'. 9 *
o (=;L8@<;K*8I*?>NC*(+*A')'+C!*96!0%)'*A')'+C!+.!.0&*9'a%!'9(+'+4+'.9(!*96!)',%(I!!*
o 8%)'*93%!*96!;*+:!6%;%96%93CP!stare(decisis*
o `.)<%(#!+:%!&0.496(!,*9'(:P!*96!+:%!04)%!;%0('(+(!G0.<!bA)'96!'<'+*+'.9!.G!+:%!;*(+cdX4(+'G'3*+'.9!G.0!
(4(;%96'9&!A*6!;0%3%6%9+(Y*
• .B:G89:<OBPQ;L<A>?*H8F>?<;KC*
o @',%0(%!;.)'+CP!(.3'.).&'3*)!G*3+(!+*[%9!'9+.!*33.49+!/:%9!*9*)Ca'9&!/:*+!+:%!W0*<%0Z(!*3+'.9(!<%*9+*
o -40;.(%!.G!3)*4(%!/*(!9.+!+.!6%&0*6%!0%)'&'.9#!/:*+!'(!0%_4'0%6!+.!*33.<;)'(:!+:'(P!&',%9!+.6*CZ(!;.)'+CY*
o Marsh(6'((%9+!0%(+(!.9!+:'(#!6C9*< '3 !M . 9 (+ '+4 + '. 9 *
o #8*(=;L8@<;KC*G0.<!+:%!9*+'.9*)!%+: . (P!*( (4 < '9 & !. 9% !%2 '(+ (!DCfI!8.A%0+!H.0[P!+: '( !'( !* !3 . ) )% 3 + '. 9 !. G !
'96','64*)!'9+% 0% (+ (*
M.49+%0<*X.0'+*0'*9!;0.A)%<#!3.40+(!6.9Z+!:*,%!*33%((!+.!9*+'.9*)!%+:.(P!)%&'()*+',%!'(!3).(%0*
*
-L<?<G*R8JJ<;;C*@.3+0'9*)P!`'(+.0'3*)P!8%(;.9(',%B1+:'3*)P!K%2+4*)P!=+043+40*)P!-046%9+'*)!D%2:*4(+',%P!*33I!H.AA'++F!
• %BS;=>?*H8F>?<;KC*)..[(!;0'<*0')C!+.!M.9(+'+4+'. 9* )!+%2 +!'+(% )GP!04)% (!)'[% !%2 ;0 %('. !49 '4(*
o "<;0.;%0!/: % 9 !3 . 9 G)'3 +( !/'+:!6%%;)C!:%)6!;0'93';)%(*
o 8*0%)C!*,*')*A)%*
• 2<:;8@<A>?*H8F>?<;KC*<%*9'9&!6%0',%6!G0.<!.0'&'9*)!'9+%9+!DW0*<%0(P!8*+'G'%0(P!-%.;)%F*
o =%%!>3[%0<*9Z(!<.<%9+(!.G!:'&:%0!)*/!<*['9&#!W.496'9&P!8%3.9(+043+'.9P!?%/!@%*)*
o M.9(%9+B(.3'*)!3.9+0*3+!+:%.0C*
• M8A;@<9>?*H8F>?<;KC*(+*0%!6%3'('(!3.9+0.)(P!).&'3*)!3.9('(+%93C*
o H4+P!&4'(%!.G!G'6%)'+C!3*4(%(!).((!.G!+0*9(;*0%93C*
• $;@=A;=@>?*H8F>?<;KC*8%)*+',%!;.('+'.9(!.G!,*0'.4(!A.6'%(!.G!&.,%09<%9+3*'9+%0;0%+!+.!*,.'6!3.9G)'3+ (*
o =+*A)%P!3.9('(+%9+!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)!A)4%;0'9+*
• Q;L<A>?*H8F>?<;KC*3.49+%0<*X.0'+*0'*9!3:*))%9&%!A%(+!<%+!/:%9!0%<%6C'9&!;.)'+'3*)!%9+0%93:<%9+*
• -@=FB9;<>?*H8F>?<;KC*3.(+BA%9%G'+!*9*)C('(*
o %I&IP!Home(Building(&(Loan(v.(BlaisdellP!6'69Z+!4;:. ) 6 !3 . 9 + 0 * 3 + (!'G !'+ !/'))!3*4(%!/ '6 % !% 3 . 9.<'3!(+0'G% *
o 6%('0*A')'+C!.G!0%(4)+(P!A4+!(:.4)69Z+!+:'(!A%!;0.,'93%!.G!6%<.30*+'3!A0*93:%(*
!
*
*
T=F<A<>?*.BO<BN *
(@;<A?B*&&&*
• W%6%0*)!(C(+%<P!=MNKO=!*96!)./%0!G%6!3.40+(!*(!M.9&0%((!%(+*A)'(:%(*
• $'G%!+%940%!G.0!X46&%(P!&..6!;)*3%!+.!(%340%!'96','64*)!0'&:+(*
• K/.!3*+%&.0'%(!.G!X40'(6'3+'.9#!3*(%(!U!3.9+0.,%0('%(P!*96!A%+/%%9!(+*+%(B3'+'a%9(*
• N0'&'9*)!X40'(6'3+'.9!'9!M.9(+'+4+'.9P!*96!*;;%))*+%!X40'(6'3+'.9!G0.<!M.9&0%((*
• 540C!+0'*)!&4*0* 9 +%% 6 !G.0 !M0'<%(P!@%G'9'+'.9!.G!K 0% * (. 9*
• $'<'+%6!AC!(4AX%3+!<*++%0!X40'(6'3+'.9P!0%(+0'3+%6!*33%((P!*96!M.9&0%((!)'<'+(!.9!*;;I!X40'(*
2<:;8@KC*Q@@8@3*"OB@A8@@BA;<893*QU=<?<J@<=E*
• M.).9'*)!`'(+.0C#!+C0*99CP!3%9+0*)!*4+:.0'+C!
• >0+'3)%(!.G!M.9G%6%0*+'.9#!6'GG4(%!(.,%0%'&9+C!.G!(+*+%(!
• W%6%0*)'(+B8%;4A)'3*9!+%9('.9(!A%+/%%9!(+0.9&!*96!/%*[!3%9+0*)!&.,%09<%9+!
• W%6%0*)'(+(!).(%!%)%3+'.9!.G!LeffP!0%*3+'.9!'(!0%%9+0%93:<% 9+!D+0C!+.!&%+!3. 9+0.)!.G!X46'3'*0CF!
o 5.:9!^*0(:* ))!* ; ; .'9 +% 6 !+.!= M N KO=!M5!
o W%6I!M.9&0%((!;*((%(!M'034'+!M.40+!>3+P!g!9%/!M'034'+!M.40+(BLg!X46&%(!
o N0&*9'3!>3+P!>6*<(!*;;.'9+(!SQ!54(+'3%(!.G!+:%!-%*3%!G.0!h!C%*0!+%0<(!D<'69'&:+!X46&%(F!
• 8%;4A)'3*9!H*3[)*(:!
o 8%;%*)!M'034'+!M.40+!>3+P!M*93%)!=MNKO=!LefQ!+%0<P!@%9C!3.<<'(('.9(!+.!54(+'3%(!D'93)I!^*0A40CF!
• Marbury:!M.40+!%(+*A )'( : % (!5 4 6 '3' * )!8 % , '% /!*(!power(to(strike(down(an(act(of(a(coordinate(branch(of(gov’t(as(
unconstitutional&
*
!"#+=#>&'(&!"?8$45&VWX6YZ*
^*0(:*))!3.4)6!:*,%!*,.'6%6!+:%!X46'3'*)!0%,'%/!'((4%#!
LI 8%34(*)#!:*6!A%%9!'((4'9&!=%30%+*0C!.G!=+*+%I!!H4+!*+!+:%!+'<%P!0%34(*)!(+*+4+%!/*(!)*2I!
QI @%)',%0C!%((%9+'*)!+.!+:%!,*)'6'+C!.G!+:%!6%%6!D9.+!3.<<'(('.9%6!49+')!0%3%';+FP!A4+!^*0(:*))!'9(+%*6!04 )% 6 !+: * + !
*;;.'9+<%9+!'(!,*)'6P!6%)',%0C!'(!X4(+!+0*9(<'(('.9!D)'[%!*!<*')A.2!04)%FP!,%(+(!4;.9!('&9!*96!(%*)P!9.+!6%)',%0C!
RI -.)'+'3*)!i4%(+'[email protected]+0'9%#!;0%('6%9+Z(!6'(30%+'.9!+.!4(%!;.)'+'3*)!;./%0(P!*33.49+*A)%!+.!%)%3+.0*+%!9.+!3.40+I!!
>;;.'9+<%9+!;./%0!'9!+:%!%2%34+',%P!9.+!X46'3'*0C!D+%2+4*)!3.<<'+<%9+P!3.<'+CP!'9(+'+4+'.9*)!3.<;%+%93%F!
SI =+*+4+.0CBM.9(+'+4+'.9*)!'9+%0;0%+*+'.9#!'9+%0;0%+!546'3'*0C!>3+!*(!3.9('(+%9+!/'+:!M.9(+'+4+'.9!
^*0A40C!(%%[(!3.<<'(('.9P!/0'+!.G!<*96*<4(I!jLR!.G!546'3'*0C!>3+#!!
• &*,%!3.40+!.0'&'9*)!X40'(!.,%0!/0'+(!.G!<*96*<4(!
• @.%(9Z+!9%3%((*0')C!3.9G)'3+!/'+:!M.9(+#!M.40+!3*9!&',%!/0'+!496%0!*;;%))*+%!X40'(P!%,%9!'G!=MNKO=!3*9Z+!:*,%!
.0'&'9*)!X40'(!+.!'((4%!/0'+I!
• 1,%9!'G!'+!@N1=!&',%!.0'&'9*)!X40'(P!>0+I!"""!:*(!%23%;+'.9(!3)*4(%!b/'+:!(43:!%23%;+'.9(!*(!M.9&0%((!(:*))!<*[%c!
• `%)6#!546I!>3+!,'.)*+%(!M.9(+'+4+'.9P!*(!>0+I!"""!jQ!6%G'9%(!=MNKO=Z(!.0'&'9*)!X40'(6'3+'.9!*(!*!3).(%6!(%+I!
^*0(:*))!<*94G*3+40'9&!3.9G)'3+Y!546'3'*)!8%,'%/!0%_4'0%(!3.9G)'3+!A%+/%%9!(+*+4+%!*96!M.9(+'+4+'.9I!
• M*;'+4)*+'9&!+.!5%GG%0(.9'*9!3.93%09(P!3.40+!'(!G0*&')%!*96!3*9Z+!%9G.03%!'+(!;0.9.493%<%9+(!
• K*[%(!.;;.0+49'+C!+.!%(+*A)'(:!X46'3'*)!0%,'%/!*96!(*30'G'3%!^*0A40C!
• ]',%(!4;!;./%0!+.!&%+!;./%0#!!
o M.9&0%((!3*9!4(%!%23%;+'.9(!3)*4(%!+.!+*[%!G0.<!*;;%))*+%!X4 0' (6 '3 + '. 9 !* 9 6 !* 6 6 !+. !. 0 '& '9 * )!!
o M.9&0%((Z(!;./%0!+.!0%<.,%!*;;%))*+%!X40'(6'3+'.9!*96!(+0';!3.40+!.G!*))!A4+!.0'&'9*)!
• 8%,'%/!.9!%2%34+',%!*3+'.9(P!A4+!9.+!/:%9!;.)'+'3*)!D'I%IP!,%+.0F!
• jLR!.G!546'3'*0C!>3+!M>?!A%!0%*6!+.!.9)C!&',%!=MNKO=!;./%0!+.!&0*9+!/0'+%!/:%9!3*(%!'(!*)0%*6C!/B'9!'+(!
D*;;%))*+%F!X40'(6'3+'.9I!!194<%0*+'.9!.G!.0'&'9* )!X40'(6'3+'.9P!(*C(!^ *0(: *))P!:./ %,% 0P!/.4 )6!0%96 %0!>0+I!"""Z(!
%94<%0*+'.9!(4;%0G)4.4(!DA4+!<*CA%!9.+P!'G!C.4!3.9('6%0!>0+I!"""!*!G)..0!+:*+!M.9&0%((!3*9!*66!+.FI!
!
H>@:L>??[:*\=:;<I<A>;<89:C*
• M.9(+'+4+'.9*)!=4;0%<*3C!
o "9+%9+!.G!W0*<%0(!+.!A'96 !G4+4 0%!&% 9% 0*+'.9 (!/ '+:!; 0'93 ';)%( !
o V0'++%9P!Cf.!H0'+'(:!:%0'+*&% !. G!4 9 /0'++%9!3.9(+ '+4+'.9*)'(<!
o =4;0%<*3C!M)*4(%P!>0+I!"7#!)*/(!<*6%!'9!;40(4*93%!.G!M.9(+'+4+'.9I!!O93:*9&%*A')'+C!.G!M.9(+'+4+'.9!
3.<;*0%6!+.!.+:%0!)*/(I!D(+043+40*)!*0&4<%9+F!
HOK!(.<%!:*,%!*0&4%6!+:'(!'(!procedural!9.+!substantive!0%&4)*0'+C#!)*/(!'9!;40(4* 9 3% !
+:%0%.G!<%*9(!%9*3+%6!'9!*33 .06* 93% !/'+:!+: %!;0.3% 64 0%(!(%+!G.0+:!'9!+:% !M.9 (+'+4+'.9 !
• 546'3'*)!8%,'%/#!546'3'*0C!*(!>&% 9 +!.G!M . 9 (+'+4 +'. 9 * )!"9 +%0 ;0 %+ *+'. 9!
o 546'3'*)!3.<; % +%9 3 %!+. !'9 +%0 ; 0% +!)*/(!
o M.<;%+%93%!+.!:%*0!3*(%(P!'I%IP!+0%*(.9!D+:.4&:P!%2;0%('.!49'4(!/.0[(!*&*'9(+!+:'(F!
o N*+:!+.!4;:.)6!3.9(+'+4+'.9!D+:.4&:P!*))!.GG'3%0(!(/%*0!+:'(!.*+:F!
o -0.,'93%!.G!X46'3'*)!6%;*0+< % 9 +!+. !(* C !/ : * +!+: % !)* / !'(!D 'G!+: %C !:* , % !+.!* ; ; )C !'+P!+: %C !(: . 4 )6 !*)( . !A% !+: %!
A0*93:!+.!'9+%0;0%+!'+F!
";LB@*\=:;<I<A>;<89:*
• K'%!C.40(%)G!+.!+:%!<*(+#!3.<<'+<%9+!+.!G496*<%9+*)!;0'93';)%(!/B.!G.))./'9&!;.)'+'3(!
• M.49+%0<*X.0'+*0'*9#!M.9(+'+4+'.9!'(!(4;%0<*X.0'+*0'*9 P!3) %* , %!+. !+: % !+%2 + !D; 0. A )% < !/:%9!+:%C!6.9 Z+!3 )%* , %F!
• M:%3[(!*96!A*)*93%(!<4(+!A%!<%*9'9&G4)P!.+:%0!A0*93:%(!*)0%*6C!/%'&:%6!'9!.9!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)'+CP!,'*!
%9*3+<%9+!*96!('&9'9&!
• =4;%0,'(.0C!0.)%!.,%0!)./%0!3.40+(!
• k%%;!;.)'+'3*)!;0.3%((!;40%!D1)C#!;0.3%((4*)!+:%.0CF!
o >9'<4(!;0%,%9+(!'96','64*)(!G0.<!%2;0%(('9&!(%),%(!*(!3'+'a%9(P!(.!)%&'()*+40%!:*(!*!)%&'+'<*3C!6%G'3'+!
+:*+!3.40+(!3*9!.,%03.<% !
o -0.+%3+!<'9.0'+C!G0.<!<*X.0'+C!+C0*99C!
• ?NK!6'(+'93+)C!3.49+%0<*X.0'+*0'*9P!*(!3.<;*0%6!+.!+:%!.+:%0!A0*93:%(!B!(.<%/:*+!; . ) '+'3 * )!, '* !9 . <'9*+'.9!
*96!3.9G'0<*+'.9!;0.3%((!
*
*
T=F<A<>?*.BO<BN*8 I*$;> ;B*( A;<8 9: C*
Martin(v.(Hunter’s(Lessee(DLeLgF#!G%6%0*)!+0%*+C!l!(+*+%!*3+ '.9 m!M .9 & 0% ((!& * ,% !=M N K O = !*; ; %))* +% !X4 0'(!U !<*6%!?N!
9%3%((*0C!)./%0!G%6%0*)!3.40+(P!+:%0%G.0%!=MNKO=!:*(!+. !:* ,% !0% ,'% / !. G!(+* +%!3 .4 0 +(!'9 !.0 6% 0!+. !:* , %!> ? \ !* ;; I!0% ,'% /!
Cohens(v.(Virginia!DLeQLF#!/:%9!3.9, '3 +' . 9 !, '. )* +% ( !M . 9 ( +'+ 4 +'. 9 P!( +* + %!3 . 9 , '3 +( !3* 9 !* ; ; % * )!+ . !=M NKO=!
!
Amanda Bakale 4/25/09 11:55 AM
Comment: =%%!:*96.4+!.9!HH!
>0&4<%9+(!G.0!546'3'*)!8%,'%/#!!
! >)+%09*+',%!'(!(%)GE0%&!AC!.+:%0!A0*93:%(!D;.)'+'3*)!;0%((40%(F!
! $%*(+!6*9&%0.4(!A0*93:!D9.!;40(%P!9.!(/.06F!
! M*9Z+!%9G.03%!(.!0%)'%(!.9!(+0%9&+:!.G!0%*(.9'9&!
>0&4<%9+(!*&*'9(+#!
! M.49+%0<*X.0'+*0'*9P!*96!9.+!'9!+:%!M.9(+'+4+'.9!DX46'3'*0C!%2%03'('9&!*9!49%94<%0*+%6!;./%0F!
*
)<E<;>;<89:*89*T=F<A<>?*.BO<BN*
• -.)'+'3*)!i4%(+'[email protected]+0'9%!
o >,.'6'9&!+:%!_4%(+'.9P!6.9Z+!.;'9%!'9!+:%!3*(%I!!?.+!A%3*4(%!;.)'+'3*))C!3: * 0 & % 6 P!A4+!6%G%0%9 3 % !+. !
;.)'+'3*)!A0*93:%(!
o @'(X493+',%!+%(+!
K%2+4*)!M.<<'+<%9+#!;./%0(!+.!.+:%0!A0*93:%(P!(43:!+:*+!3.40+!(:.4)6!9.+!&%+!'9,.),%6!
• 1I&IP!'<;%*3:<%9+!;0.3%((%(P!Nixon(v.(US:!X46&%!'<;%*3: % 6 P!`1$@#!;0.3% 6 4 0 % (!* 0 %!
(.)%!;0.,'93%!.G!=%9*+%!
M.<'+C#!9.!'9+%0,%9+'.9!/:%0%!'+!/.4)6!496%0<'9%!;0%0.&*+',%(!.G!*9.+:%0!A0*93:!
• 1I&IP!Luther(v.(BordenP!M.9&0%((P!9. +!3 . 40+P!&4*0*9 +% % ( !0% ;4A)'3*9!G. 0<!.G!(+*+%!&.,Z+!
"9(+'+4+'.9*)!3.<;% +%9 3%#!/ :'3 :!A0* 9 3:!:* (!*3 3%((!+. !0%)%,* 9+!'9 G.0< * +'.9 !
• 1I&IP!,.+'9&!0'&:+(!3*(%(#!3.40+(!/.9Z+!'9+%0,%9%!*(!(+*+'(+'3'*9(!+.!60*/!6'(+0'3+(!
>)(.#!Baker(v.(Carr!DLngQF!
• $*3[!.G!X46'3'*))C!6'(3.,%0*A)%!(+*96*06!!
• ?%%6!G.0!'9'+'*)!;.)'3C!6%+%0< '9 * +'. 9 !
• ?%%6!G.0!*6:%0%93%!+.!;.)'+'3*)!6%3'('.9!*)0%*6C!<*6%!
• -.+%9+'*)!%<A*00*((<%9+!G0.<!;0.9.493%<%9+!AC!,*0'.4(!6%;+(I!.9!.9%!_4%(+'.9!
o -0%(%0,%!;.)'+'3*)!)%&'+'<*3CP!%2;%0+'(%P!;0%,%9+!.,%0('&:+!.G!.+:%0!A0*93:%(!3:%3[(!.9!X46'3'*0C!D%I&IP!
6.9Z+!'9+%0G%0%!'9!M.9&0%(('.9*)!(%)GE&.,%09*93%F!
• =+*96'9&!
o @'(+'9&4'(:!A%+/%%9!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)!*96!;046%9+'*)!0%_4'0%<%9+(!G.0!X4(+'3'*A')'+CI!
o -046%9+'*)#!3.9(%0,%!0%(.403%(P!(%;*0*+'.9!.G!;./%0(P!A%++%0!6%3'('.9(P!G*'09%((!.G!)'<'+'9&!+.!;*0+'%(!
o M.9(+'+4+'.9*)!&0.496!G.0!(+*96'9 &!6 .3+ 0'9%#!>0+I!"""!b3*(%( !*9 6 !3 . 9 +0 ., % 0( '% (c !D9 . !* 6 , '(. 0 C!. ; '9 '. 9 ( F!
=%;*0*+'.9!.G!;./%0(!3.93%09P!/*(+%!.G!0%(.403%(!'G!3.4)69Z+!;*((!)%&'()*+40%!*9C/*CP!)'<'+!+.!
(;%3'G'3!6'(;4+%(!
o M.9X493+',%!+%(+!!
"9X40C!'9!G*3+!D3.930%+%P!'< <'9%9+F!
• "9X40C!0%_4'0%<%9 +!< *9 ';4 )*A )%!AC !3.4 0+P!:./ !+. !3:* 0*3+% 0'a%!+: %!:*0 < !!
• Baker(v.(CarrP!%I&IP!:*0<!/*(!9.+!b&%+ + '9 & !'9Pc!A4+!+:%!3:*93%!.G!&%+ +' 9 & !'9!
K0*3%*A)%!+.!+:%!oZ(!3.9643+!D3*4(*)!3.99%3+'.9F!
$'[%)CP!9.+!(;%34)*+',%P!+:*+!'9X40C!/'))!A%!0%60%((%6!AC!G*,.0*A)%!6%3'('.9!
o Lujan(v.(Defenders(of(Wildlife:(9.!(+*96'9&!AB3!*<A'&4.4(!*(!+.!/:*+!+:%!:*0<!/.4)6!A%!G0.<!*!).((!.G!
%9,'0.9<%9+*)!;0.+%3+'.9!.G!)*96(F#!<*[%(!:*0<!*!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)P!9.+!;046%9+'*)P!0%_4'0%<%9+!G.0!
(+*96'9&!
o Lyon:((+*96'9&!G.0!'9X493+',%!0%)'%G#!<4 ( +!A %!)'[ % )': . .6 !. G!G4+ 4 0% !:* 0<!
o -046%9+'*)!G*3+.0(!
-0.:'A'+'.9!.9!*((%0+'.9!.G!R
06
!;*0+'%(Z!0'&: +( !!
• 123%;+!/:%0%!R
06
!;*0+C!3*9Z+!( 4 % P!'I% IP!0% ( +0 '3 +', % !3 . , %9 * 9 + (P!Baird(v.(Eisenstadt!/:%0%!
49<*00'%6!3.4;)%(!(%%['9&!3.9+0*3%;+'.9!/.4)6!9%,%0!A%!)'+'&*9+(P!A4+!*0%!:*0<%6!
• >)(.P!%23%;+!/:%0%!+:%0%!'(!*!3).(%!0%)*+'.9(:';!DPierce(v.(Soc’y(of(SistersP!A%+/%%9!
(3:..)!*96!;*0%9+(F!
-0.:'A'+'.9!.9!&%9%0*)'a%6!&0'%,*93%(!D'I%IP!9.!+*2;*C%0!(+*96'9&d%23%;+!G.0!%(+*A)'(:<%9+!
3)*4(%!%23%;+'.9P!see(Marsh(v.(ChambersF!
-0.:'A'+'.9!.9!*((%0+'9&!3)*'<(!.4+('6%!+:%!a.9%!.G!'9+%0%(+(!+:*+!M.9&0%((!(.4&:+!+.!;0.+%3+!
• 8';%9%((!
o K'<'9&#!+..!%*0)C!+.!A0'9&!*!3*(%!
-0%%9G.03%<%9+!*))./%6!"W!:*06(:';!+.!6%9'*)!.G!0%,'%/P!%I&IP!'G!G.03%6!+.!3:..(%!A%+/%%9!
G.0%&.'9&!)*/G4)!*3+','+C!.0!0'(['9&!(*93+'.9(P!.0!/:%0%!+:%0%!'(!<%0%)C!*!6%)*C!'9!
%9G.03%<%9+!
o `*06(:';!*96!G'+9%((!G.0!X46'3'*)!0%,'%/!D<'&:+!9%%6!A%++%0!0%3.06!.G!+:%!G*3+(P!+:%0%G.0%!9.+!0';%F!
o See(Ohio(Forestry(v.(Sierra(Club:!1->!,'.)*+%6!AC!6 % , % ). ; <%9+P!A4+!9. !6 %,%).;< %9+!;)*9(!C%+!
o M*9!A0'9&!+:%!3*(%!)*+%0!/:%9!+:%!G*3+(!&%)!
• ^..+9%((!
o ^*++%0(!:*,%!;0.3%% 6 % 6 !'9 !( 4 3: !* !/*C!+:*+!0%96%0(!6%3'('.9 !4 (% ) %( ( !
o See(City(Novelty(v.(City:!3:*))%9&'9&!.06 '9 * 9 3% !+ . !(: 4 + !6 . /9!*64)+!A.. [ ( : . 0 %P!A4+!(+.0%!3).( % (!G . 0!
%3.9.<'3!0%*(.9(!
o 123%;+'.9#!<*++%0(!%,*6'9&!0%,'%/!A4+!capable(of(repetitionP!'I%IP!*A.0+'.9!3*(%(!D )'+ '&*+'.9!+*[% (!
).9&%0!+:*9!&%(+* +'.9 P!(. !*A .0+'. 9!3 *(% !/ . 4)6 !> $V>\=!A%!<.. +F!D9 .+!X4 (+!3* ; *A )%!. G!0%; %+ '+'.9 !0%* ))CP!
A4+!/'))!*)/*C(!A%!<..+!'9!0%;%*+%6!3'034<(+*93%(dF!
o ?.+!<..+!'GP!%,%9!/:%9!;0'<*0C!'9X40C!0%(.),%6P!+:%0%!*0%!(%3.96*0C!%GG%3+(!D(43:!*(!30'<'9*)!:'(+.0C!
'<;*3+(!.0!3. 9 +'9 4 '9 & !'9 X4 0C P!'I%IP!9% %6 !A * 3[ ; * C F!
• M%0+'.0*0'!-0*3+'3%!
o 8'&:+!+.!G')%!'9!G%6%0*)!3.40+P!0'&:+!+.!G%6%0*)!*;;%*)P!A4+!9.!0'&:+!+.!*;;%*)!'9!=MNKO=!
o pfffEefff!3*(%(!G')%6P!.9)C!:%*06!pfEef!
!
M.9&0%(('.9*)!*A')'+C!+.!0%;%*)!G%6%0*)!3.40+!*;;%))*+%!X40'(6'3+'.9!
Ex(parte(McCardleP!<*X.0'+*0' * 9 !3 : % 3 [ !. 9!X46'3'*0CP!D+ : . 4&:!Marbury!/.4)6!A%!<%*9 '9 & )% ( (!'G !M . 9 & 0% ( (!3 . 4 )6 !0 % <.,%!
>$$!*;;%))*+%!0%,'%/F!
!
=.,%0%'&9!"<<49'+C!
O9)%((#!!LF!(+*+%!.GG'3%0(!D(+*+%!9.+!9*<%6P!Ex(parte(Young#!(+*+%!.GG'3%0(!3*9Z+!,'.)*+% !G% 6 % 0* )!)* /F!
! QF!/*',%0!D0*0%F!
RF!/:%9!M.9&0%((!*3+(!'9!;40(4*93%!.G!jh!.G!LS>!DSeminole(Tribe(v.(Florida,(A4+()'<'+%6!AC!BoerneP!(%%!A%)./F!!
LL>P!'9+%9(%!0%*3+'.9!+.!Chisholm(v.(Georgia!DLpnRFP!/:%0 %!= M !3 '+ 'a% 9 !( 4 % 6 !] > !( 4 3 3% ( (G 4 ))C I!
• 8%(+0'3+(!=^5!.G!G%6!3.40+(!'9!*))!3*(%(P!.0!'9!3*(%(!G.496%6!.9!6',%0('+C!X40'(!D*(!Chisholm!/*(!.9)C!6',!X4 0 '( F!
• =%3.96!,'%/!'93.9('(+%9+!/'+:!Hans(v.(Louisiana!D(+*+%!3*9Z+!A%!(4%6!AC!%'+:%0!3'+'a%9!.0!9.93'+'a%9F !
*
/BFB@>?<:E*>9F*!89]@B::<89>?*-8NB@:*
M.9&0%((!:*(!)'<'+%6!D*96!%94<%0*+%6F!;./%0(!*(!*!3:%3[!.9!'+(!3*;*3'+C!+.!+04<;!(+*+%!)%&'()*+'.9!
>0+'3)%!"P!=%3+'.9!eP!M)*4(%(!LELf!
LI -./%0!.G!+*2*+'.9!D(%%!;0.A)%<(!/'+:!>0+'3)%(!.G!M.9G%6%0*+'.9P!9%%6 !qF !
QI -./%0!+.!A.00./!<.9%C!.9!30%6'+!.G!O=!
RI -./%0!+.!b0%&4)*+%!M.<<%03%!/'+:!G.0%'&9!?*+'.9(P!*96!*<.9&!+:%!(%,%0*)!(+*+%(P!*96!/'+:!+:%!"96'*9!
K0'A%(Ic!
SI -./%0!.,%0!?*+40*)'a*+'.9!*96!H*9[04;+3C!
hI -./%0!+.!3.'9!<.9%C!*96!(%+!/%'&:+(!*96!<%*(40%(!
gI -./%0!+.!;49'(:!3.49+%0G%'+'9&!
pI -./%0!+.!%(+*A)'(:!;.(+!0.*6(!
eI -./%0!+.!30%*+%!'93%9+',%(!G.0!'9+%))%3+4*)!;0.;%0+C!
nI -./%0!+.!30%*+%!3.40+(!496%0!=4;0%<%!M.40+!
LfI -./%0!+.!;49'(:!G%).9'%(!.9!+:%!:'&:!(%*(!*96!.GG%9(%(!*&*'9(+!)*/!.G!9*+'.9(!
>0+'3)%!"P!=%3+'.9!eP!M)*4 ( % (!L L ELg#!/*0!;./%0(!
LLI -./%0!+.!6%3)*0%!/*0!
LQI -./%0!+.!0*'(%!*96!(4;;.0+!>0<C!
LRI -./%0!+.!0*'(%!*96!(4;;.0+!?*,C!
LSI -./%0!+.!0%&4)*+%!>0<C!*96!?*,C!
LhI -./%0!+.!3*))!G.0+:!<')'+'*(!
LgI -./%0!+.!0%&4)*+%!+:%!<')'+'*(!
>0+'3)%!"P!=%3+'.9!eP!M)*4(%(!LpELe!
LpI -./%0!.,%0!@'(+0'3 +!. G !M . )4 <A'*!
LeI -./%0!b+.!<*[%!*))!$*/(!/:'3:!(:*))!A%!9%3%((*0C!*96!;0.;%0!+.!3*00C'9&!'9 +. !12%34+'.9!+: % !G. 0 % &. ' 9 &!
-./%0(Ic!
M)*4(%!Le!'(!*!0'6%0!3)*4(%#!(.!).9&!*(!C.4!:*,%!+:%!;./%0P!C.4!3*9!%9&*&%!'9!9%3%((*0C!*96!;0.;%0!<%*9(!+.!
%GG%3+4*+%!+:*+!;./%0I!!K:%!<%*9'9&!.G!+:'(!3)*4(%!'(!*+!'((4%!'9!McCulloch(v.(Maryland:!%2;*9(',%!'9 + % 0; 0 % +* +' . 9 !. G!
?U-!3)*4(%P!&0*9+!.G!A0.*6%0!;./%0(!+.!M.9&0%((I!
!
>0+'3)%!"!jn#!-./%0(!@%9'%6!+.!M.9&0%((!
><%96<%9+!J#!*))!;./%0(!6%9'%6!+.!M.9&0%((!0%('64*))C!G*))!A*3[!+.!(+*+%(!
*
/BFB@>?<:EC*$;>;BP/BFB@>?*F<O<FB*>9F*W6(*
-0%,%9+'.9!.G!+C0*99C!
6.4A)%!(%340'+CP!3.9+0.)!%*3:!.+:%0!DA4+!=4;0%<*3C!M)*4(%FP!(+*+%(!3*9!&0*9+!<.0%!0'&:+(!+:*9!G%6!
19:*93'9&!6%<.30*+'3!04)%!/'+:!&.,%09%<+9!3).(%0!+.!+:%!;%.;)%!
! 1GG'3'%93C#!9*+'.9*)!,%0(4(!(+*+%!'((4%(!A%++%0!(.),%6!.9!+:*+!)%,%)!
"96','64*)!3:.'3%#!'930%*( %!(*+'(G* 3+'.9 P!,.+%!/ '+: !C.4 0!G%%+P!*4 +.9 .< C !D< .0 %!'9G)4% 93 %!*+!).3* )!)%,%)F!
?*+Z)!&.,Z+!3..06'9*+%(P!<*2'<'a%!3.))%3+',%!&..6(!
M'+'a%9!;*0+'3';*+'.9P!('<')*0!+.!*0&4<%9+(!G.0!).3*)'(<#!A4+!(.3'*))C!9.9E .; +'<*)!;.)'3'%(!AB3!(+*+%(!3.<;%+%!
-.+%9+'*)!;0.A)%<#!^*6'(.9'*9!G*3+'.9(!
=+*+%(!*0%!)*A.0*+.0'%(!G.0!9%/!'6%*(!D%I&IP!9.!G*4)+!6',.03%P!/%)G*0%P!(%*+A%)+(F!
!
*
!8EEB@AB*!?>=:B*
8%*3:!.G!W%6%0*)!)%&'()*+40%!*&*'9(+!=+*+%(#!W*0!0%*3:'9&P!496%0!?U-!*96!M.<<%03%!
=4A(+*9+',%!@-!0..+(#!49%94<%0*+%6!b3.9+0*3+c!0'&:+(!'9!@-!D0%(3'96!*G+%0!?%/!@%*)P!;)%9*0C!;./%0!+.!M.9&0%((!49+')!
+:%!8%:9_4'(+!0%,.)4+'.9F!
!
!@)=::4@%&'(&!"#>:"5?*VWXW7ZC!4(%(!b?%3%((*0C!*9 6 !- 0 . ; % 0!M )* 4 ( % c!+ . !'9 3 0% * ( % !M . 9 &0 % (('.9 *)!;./ %0!
• V*(:'9&+.9!('&9(!)%&'()*+'.9!30%*+'9&!H*9[P!6%(;'+%!3.9+0.,%0(CI!!M.9&0%((!0%G4(%(!+.!0%9%/!3:*0+%0!
• >G+%0!V*0!.G!LeLQP!^*6'(.9!('&9(!=%3.96!H*9[Z(!3:*0+%0!
• ^*0C)*96!'<;.(%(!+*2!.9!*))!9.9E(+*+%!A*9[(!D=%3.96!H*9[!'(!+:%!.9)C!.9%Fd^3M4)).3:!'(!A*9[!3*(:'%0!*96!
0%G4(%(!+.!;*C!+:%!+*2I!
• 54(+'3%!^*0(: *))!* & *'9 !; 4 0( 4% 6 !> 6* <(Z!W%6%0*)'(+!,'('.9 !'9(McCullochI!
• >G+%0!+:%!3*(%P!5*3[(.9!,%+.%(!+:%!0%9%/*)!.G!+:%!A*9[Z(!3:*0+%0P!*0&4%(!+:*+!McCulloch!(:.4)69Z+!A '9 6 !
i4%(+'.9(#!LF!6.%(!M.9&0%((!:*,%!+:%!;./%0!+.!30%*+%!*!H*9[!D49%94<%0*+%6!;./ %0Fm!QF!'G!(.P!3*9!+:%!(+*+%!+*2 !'+Y!
!
^.6*)'+'%(!.G!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)!'9+%0;0%+*+'.9!*;;)'%6!+.!McCulloch(_4%(+'.9!LFP!6.%(!M.9&0%((!:*,%!A*9[!;./%0Y!
!
^4(+!3.<A'9%!;./%0(!+.!'9G%0!A*9['9&!;./%0!D^*0(:*))!
6.%(!9.+!(;%3'GCFI!
&9;B@;BS;=>?<:EC!.9%!/.06 !<%*9(!+:%!(*<%!+:0.4&: . 4 +!
+:%!6.34<%9+!
@.%(!9.+!(*CP!b*A(.)4+%)C!9%3%((*0Cc!D*9.+:%0!(%3+'.9!.G!+:%!
M.9(+'+4+'.9!4(%(!b*A(.)4+%)CcF(
?.+!.9!je!)*4960C!)'(+I!!(
!
!
!
?.+!AC!.06'9*0C!<%*9'9&!.G!b9%3%((*0C!
*96!;0.;%0Ic!(
V*(:'9&+.9!('&9%6!+:%!G'0(+!A*9[I!!
W0*<%0(!6'69Z+!G.496!*!A*9[P!<43:!
.;;.('+'.9I!
?.!;0%3%6%9+P!A4+!;0*3+'3%!*(!;0%3%6%9+!D3.9&%*)(!.,%0!
+'<%!/B.!3:*))%9&%F!
!
$*3[!.G!A*9[!/*(!3.9(+0'3+',%P!%<A*00*((<%9+!640'9&!V*0!
.G!LeLQ!
12;0%(('.9!.G!(+0.9&!;./%0!)%*6(!+.!
+C0*99C!
W%6%0*)!&.,%09<%9+!(4;0%<%!A4+!)'<'+%6P!*96!?U-!&',%(!*!
).9&!)%*(:!
>&*'9P!+C0*99C!
=.,%0%'&9+C!'9!;%.;)%P!,%(+%6!'9!&.,Z+!
=.,%0%'&9+C!'9!(+*+%(P!)'<'+%6!G%6%0*)!
!
iLF!M.9&0%((!M>?!%(+*A)'(:!*!A*9[#!
• `'(+.0CB;0*3+'3%!&.%(!+.!;0%(4<;+'.9!.G!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)'+C!
o (%%!*)(.!Youngstown(Sheet(&(Tube:((C(+%<*+'3P!49A0.[%9!%2%34+',%!;0*3+'3%!).9&!;40(4%6d &).((!
.9!%2%34+',%!;./%0!
• M.<;*3+!G%6%0*)'(<#!;%.;)%P!9.+!(+*+%(P!*0%!(.,%0%'&9r9.!(+*+%!,%+.!.G!G%6%0*)!)%&'()*+'.9P!)'<'+%6!*A ')' +C !
.G!(+*+%(!+.!'9+%0G%0%!
• ?.+!'9!+%2+P!A4+!M.9(+'+4+'.9!'(!9.+!*!)%&*)!3.6%!b'+!'(!*!constitution!/%!*0%!%2;.49 6 '9 & c !
o M.9#!O9%94<%0*+%6!;./%0!.G!M.9&0%((!
• ?U-!3)*4(%#!)%&'+'<*+%!*96!*;;0.;0'*+%!*96!9.+!;0.:'A'+%6!T!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)P!?U-!+.!499*<%6!;./%0!.G!
M.9&0%((!D'9!GibbonsP!^*0(:*)!0 % )*+%(!'+!+.!+:%!M . <<%03%!M) * 4 ( % !; . /%0F!
o M.9#!?U-!'(!*!)'<'+'9&!;0'93';)%P!.0!%)(%!(40;)4(*&%!
!
iQF!=+*+%!3*9!?NK!+*2!+:%!A*9[#!
• @.<'9*9+!<.6*)'+C!'(!structural:!*)).3*+'.9!.G!(+*+%BG %6!;./%0I!!!
• M.93400%9+!;./%0!+.!+*2P!A4+!;./%0!+.!+*2!T!;./%0!+.!6%(+0.C!!
o V:%0%!+:%0%!'(!:.(+')'+C!A%+/%%9!;./%0(P!+:%!G%6%0*)!;./%0!+04<;(!
o $%+!*<A'+'.9!3.49+%0*3+!*<A'+'.9P!3*9Z+!:*,%!3.9G'6%93%!'9!(+*+%(Z!0%(+0*'9+!
• =+*+%!)%&'(!.,%0+409'9&!G%6!+*2!/B.!0%;0%(%9+*+'.9!.G!.+:%0!Sn!(+*+%(I!
• K:'(!'(!+*2*+'.9!/ B. !0% ; 0% (% 9 +* +'. 9 !
!
A8++45$&'(&B9?,5*VWX5^ZC!( %+ +)% ( !. 9 !M . <<%03%!M)* 4 (% !* ( !/*00*9+!G.0!&. , % 0 9 <%9+!'9+%0,%9+'.9!
• N!:*(!G%00C!A%+/%%9!?\B?5P!%23)4(',%!)'3%9(%!G0.<!?\!(+*+%I!!]!3.<;%+%(P!3'+%(!G%6!(+*+4+%!&0*9+'9&!:'<!)'3%9(%I!!
• Lf>#!M.9&0%((!<4(+!:*,%!*4+:.0'+C!+.!)%&'()*+%P!Lf>!6.%(!9.+!)'<'+!)%&'()*+',%!;./%0P!6','6%!police(;./%0!*96!
3.<<%03%!
o Lf>!6.%(!9.+!'9,*)'6*+%!)*/(!/B'9!(3.;%!.G!M.9&0%((Z(!;./%0!
• M.9&0%((!(+*+4+%!&',%(!]!0'&:+P!N!3*9Z+!<.9.;.)'a%!'9+%0(+*+%!+0*9(;.0+*+'.9!
o W%6!;0%%<;+(!(+*+%!'G!,*)'6!
o W%6!)'3%9(%!,*)'6!AB3!M.9&0%((!:*(!;./%0!+.!0%&4)*+%!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%P!'93)46'9&!'9+%0(+*+%!9*,'&*+'.9!
• 54(+'GC!;./%0!% 2 ;* 9 ('. 9 !* (!3. 9 (. 9 * 9+ !/ '+: !M. 9 (+'+ 4 +'.9!
o M.<<%03%#!'93)46%(!9*,'&*+'.9!
o 8%&4)*+%#!)'<'+%6!.9)C!AC!M.9(+'+4+'.9!*96!;.)'+'3*)!;0.3%((%(!
o "9+%0(+*+%#!*9C+:'9&!+:*+Z(!9. +!'9+0* (+*+% !
• ?%3%((*0C!*96!;0.;%0!'9!;40(4*93%!.G!+:%!M.<<%03%!;./%0!
• 5.:9(.9Z(!3.9 3 40 0% 9 3% #!< . 0% !0*6 '3 *)P!6 %9 C !(+* +% (!+: %!; . / % 0!+. !0%& 4 )* +%!3 . < <%03%!D%,%9!'G!M.9 & 0% ((!: * 69 Z+F!
o W.49+*'9:%*6!.G!dormant(commerce(clause(jurisprudence!
!
$=J:;>9;<OB*M-*<9*;LB*C4@%5,#*Q@>*
K0%96!+./*06!9*+'.9*)!%3.9.<C!'930%*('9&)C!A0'9&(!+:%!3.<<%03%!3)*4(%!'9+.!;)*C!
M.<<%03%#!M.9&0%((!3*9!0%&4)*+%!'9+0*(+*+%!*3+','+C!'G!'+!*GG%3+(!'9+%0(+*+%!*3+','+C!
! $*+%!Leff(!s!LnRf(#!%0*!. G!'9 3 0 %* ( '9 & !% 3. 9.< '3!*96!0%&4)*+.0C!)%&'()*+'.9!t!*3+','(+!X46'3'*)!0%,'%/!
! ! "964(+0'*)!0%,.)4+'.9P!&0./+:!.G!3'+'%(!*96!/.0['9&!3)* ((P!*A4 (',% !3.9 +0*3 +(!
! ! 8'(%!.G!)*'((%a!G*'0%!%3.9.<'3(!*96!(.3'*)!@*0/'9'(<!
! M.<<%03%!T!(+*+%!.G!A4('9%((!separate!G0.<!;0. 6 4 3 +' . 9 !!
! Lf>!*))./(!(+*+%(!+.!0%&4)* +% !;0. 6 43 +'.9 P!G%6% 0* )!)%&'( )*+'. 9!3* 9 Z+!'9, *6 %!a. 9 %!.G!( +*+%!
-0%ELnRp!M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!6'(+'93+'.9(
• 7*)'6#!!
o "9+%0(+*+%!D(+0%*<!.G!3.< < % 03% F!
o M.<<%03%!'9!&..6(!+:*+!*)0%*6C!%2'(+!
o @'0%3+!%GG%3+!.9!3.<<%03%!
o "+%<(!'9!+:%!G)./!.G!3.<<%03%!
!
!
!
!
• "9,*)'6!
o "9+0*(+*+%!3.<<% 03% !
o >&0'34)+40%P!<*94G*3+40%P!<'9'9&!
o "96'0%3+!%GG%3+(!.9!3.<< % 03%!
o "9:%0%9+)C!6*9&%0. 4( !&.. 6(!
D3.<;*0%!Champion(*96!HammerF!
o "+%<(!+:*+!:*,%!9.+!C%+!%9 +%0% 6!.0!
:*,%!%2'+%6!+:%!G)./!.G!3.<<%03%!
DSchechterF!
&
)%"*D845&'(&E*,$&VW76YZC*,*)'6*+%(!*3+!.G!M.9&0%((!A*99'9&!'9+%0(+*+%!+0*6%!'9!).++%0C!+'3[%+(!
• M.9&0%((Z(!;./%0!+.!0%&4)*+%!includes!+:%!;./%0!+.!;0.:'A'+!D3*9!%23)4 6 %!% , ') !'+% <(!G0.<!3.<<%03%F!
o ='<')*0!+.!McCullochP!+:%!;./%0!+.!+*2!T !; ./%0!+.!6%( +0 . C!
• $.++.!+'3[%+(!3.49+!*(!3.<<%03%P!+:%C!:*,%!3.9+'9&%9+!,*)4%!*96!< .9%+* 0C!,*)4%!D;4 03:* (%!;0'3%F!
F"**,#&'(&G"9,5%"#6&VW7WXZC*'9,*)'6*+'9&!*3+!.G!M.9&0%((!A*99'9&!&..6(!<*6%!AC !3: ') 6 !)* A . 0!
• Lf>!0%(%0,%(!* !a. 9 % !+ . !+: % !(+ * +% ( #!: %0 % P!; . /%0!+.!0%&4)* +% !<*94G*3+40% P!( . !G% 6 % 0* )!) * / !' (!4 9 3 . 9 ( +'+4 + '.9 * )!
• =+*+4+%!/*(!*++%<;+!+.!)%,%)!;)*C'9&!G'%)6!A%+/%%9!(+*+%(!+:*+!6.!*96!6.!9.+!*))./!3:')6!)*A.0*
o M.))%3+',%!*3+'.9P!M.9&0%((!;4(:%(!+.!<*2'<'a%6!;.('+'.9*
• "9+%0(+*+%!3.<<% 03%!? N K!9 %3%( (*0C !+.!*33 .< ; )'(:!+: %!< *9 4G* 3+4 0%!D+:% !+:'9& !A%'9 &!0% &4 )*+%6 F*
o -0.643+!,%0(4(!;0.3%((#!'G!C.4!3*9Z+!+%))!+:%!%,')!AC!)..['9&!*+!+:%!;0.643+P!+:%9!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!
6.%(!9.+!*;;)C!*
o N,%004)%6!*G+%0!(/'+3:!'9!+'<%#!;0.3%((B;0.643+!6'(+'93+'.9!<%*9'9&)%((!!
• @'((%9+!D`.)<%(F#!('<')*0!+.(ChampionP!&..6(!' 9 !'9+%0(+*+%!3. <<%03%!!
o `%0%P!+:%!>3+!6.%(9Z+!*GG%3+!'9+0 * (+ * +% !* 3+ ', '+' %( P!( +* +% ( !'9 !. ; ; . ( '+' . 9 !+. !M . 9 & 0 % (( '. 9 * )!+ 0* 6 % !( *9 3 +' . 9 (!
*0%!6%9'%6!+:%!b0*3%!+.!+:%!A.++.<c!
)"#6,#&'(&)"#6,#&)4":&VW7Y^ZC*(+0'[%(!6./9!H'+4<'9.4(!M.*)!M.9(%0,* +'.9!>3+!
• >3+(!+:*+!+0C!+.!0%&4)*+%!/.0['9&!3.96'+'.9(P!*96!9.+!(:';<%9+B(*)%P!*0%!.,%00%*3:'9&!D;.)'3%!;./%0!.G!(+*+%F!
• =+043[!6./9!*(!'96'0%3+P!*)+:.4&:!>3+!6'(34((%6!3.*)Z(!'<;.0+*93%!+.!9*+'.9*)!%3.9.<C!
H@%,@%6,#&I4=:6#>&)4#D(&'(&JH*VW7Y_ZC*(+0'[%(!6./9!?*+'.9*)!"964(+0'*)!8%3.,%0C!>3+!D(+*+4+%!;0%,%9+%6!(%))%0(!G0.<!
G.03'9&!A4C%0 (!+. !A4 C !('3[ !* ).9 & !/ '+: !:% * )+: C!3: '3[ % 9( !G0. < !()* 4 & :+ %0: . 4 (% (F!
C4@%5,#&'(&K,;&L4#<&VW76_ZC!A*[%0(!<*2 '<4<!:.40 ( !)% &' ()* + '. 9 !( +0 4 3[ !6 . /9!DhESP!(+0.9&!6'((%9+(F!
• M.40+!(+0'[%(!6./9!(+*+%!3.40+Z(!04)'9&!+:*+!+:%0%!'(!9.!bG0%%6.<!.G!3.9+0*3+c!'9!M.9(+'+4+'.9!
o W0%%6.<!.G!3.9+0*3+!'(!*!A*('3!0'&:+!496%0!@-!3)*4(%!
o ].,Z+!3*9!'9+%0G%0%!/'+:!G0%%6.<!.G!k!.9)C!G.0!,*)'6!;.)'3%!;40;.(%#!;.)'3%!;./%0(!9.+!'<;)'3*+%6!'9!
)'<'+'9&!/.0['9& !:. 4 0(P!*9 6!; 4 A)'3!( *G% +C!'(!9 .+!'<;)'3*+%6!
o 546'3'*)!0.)%!'(!+.!(304+'9'a%!)%&'()*+'.9!'9+%0G%0'9&!/'+:!G0%%6.<!.G!kP!;*((%6!G.0!;0.;%0!;40; .(%!
• 13.9.<'3!(4A(+*9+',%!@-#!49%94<%0*+%6!0'&:+(!*96!%3.9.<'3!G0%%6.<!D'<;.0+'9&!(4A(+*93%!'9+.!@-F!
o H*[%0(!*0%!9.+!/*06(!.G!+:%!(+*+%P!6.9Z+!'9+%0G%0%!/'+:!+:%'0!X46&<%9+!
o $'<'+'9&!:.40(!/*(!9.+!0%)*+%6!+.!;4A)'3!:%*)+:!0*+'.9*)%!
• =+*+%!3*99.+!A*0&*'9!*/*C!;.)'3%!;./%0P!(.!(+*+%!M>?!*A0.&*+%!3.9+0*3+(!496%0!police(power!
• `*0)*9Z(!6'((%9+#!+:%0%!'(!*!0%)*+'.9!+.!;.)'3%!;./%0!.AX%3+',%(!
o -4A)'3!:%*)+:!'((4%!
o 546'3'*)!6%G%0%9 3% !+.!)%&'()*+',%!3:.'3%(!
o =.3'.).&'3*)!3:*0*3+%0'a*+'.9!.G!A*[%0(!D<.0%!)'[%!<'9%0(!+:*9!;0.G%(('.9*)(P!9%%6!(;%3'*)!;0.+%3+'.9!
• `.)<%(Z(!6'((%9+#!0%*(.9*A)%!%2%03'(%!.G!;.)'3%!;./%0!
o ?.!%<A.6'<%9+!.G!%3.9.<'3!+:%.0'%(!D)*'((%aEG*'0%F!'9!M.9(+'+4+ '.9 !
o M.40+!'(!A%'9&!3.49+%0<*X.0'+* 0 '*9 #!!
O9%)%3+%6!X46&%(!(4A(+'+4+'9&!,*)4%(!G.0!+:.(%!.G!)%&'()*+40%!+.!;0.+%3+!49%94<%0*+%6!0'&:+(!
o M.40+!3*9!*((4<%!*9!49%94<%0*+%6!N?$\!/:%0%!6%%;)C!0..+%6!'9!9*+'.9Z(!:'(+.0C!*96B.0!'<;)'3'+!'9!
9.+'.9(!.G!.06%0%6!)'A%0+C!DG0%%6.<!.G!k!6.%(9Z+!G'+F!
!
?.+%#!Lochner(!*96!49%94<%0*+%6 !0 '& : + (#!9 . + !* !; 0. + % 3+ %6 !3 )* ( (P!( '<')*0!+.!3.9+0 * 3% ; + '. 9 P!( *<%!(%2!<*0 0 '* & %P!( . 6 . <CY!
>G+%0!LochnerP!<4(+!(:./!+:*+ !)* /!'(!3).(%)C!0 % )* + % 6 !+ . !; . ) '3 % !; . /%0!.G!*6,* 9 3 '9&!;4A)'3!: % * )+ : P!( * G% + C P!<.0*)'+C!
! "9+0.643+'.9!.G!H0*96%'(!A0'%G(P!4('9&!(.3'.).&'3*)!6*+*!Dsee(Muller(v.(Oregon!DLnfeF!*96!/.< % 9 ( Z!: % * )+: F !
!
]0./+:!.G!M.<<%03%!-./%0!4;!+.!?%/!@%*)#!!
• Lochner!%0*!;0.+%3+'. 9 !. G !%3 . 9 . <'3!0'&:+!496 % 0!@-!3)*4(%P!< * [ % (!k!3)*4(%!(4;% 0 G)4 . 4 ( !!
o M.9&0%((Z(!(3.;%!.G!;./%0!)'<'+%6P!*96!Lf>!0%(%0,%(!a.9%!.G!*4+:.0'+C!+.!(+*+%(!DM.40+!;0.+%3+%6!
%3.9.<'3!0'&:+(!G0.<!A.+:!(+*+%!*96!G%6%0*)!'9+%0G%0%93%F!
o Lochner!:*6!0%*6!)*'( ( %a !G* '0 % !'9 +. !+ : % !M . 9 (+ '+ 4 +'. 9 P!/:'3:!'(!9%'+: % 0!' <;)'3'+!'9!.06% 0 %6 !) 'A % 0 +C !. 0!
0..+%6!'9!+0*6'+'.9(B:'(+.0C!!
• W0%%6.<!.G!M.9+0*3+!/*(!*!A).3[!+.!.+:%0!&.,%09<%9+!0%&4)*+'.9(!A%('6%(!:%*)+:P!(*G%+CP!<.0*)'+C!
• ?%/!@%*)!;0.&0*<<'9&!(%%9!%((%9+'*)!A4+!M.40+!(:4+(!'+!6./9I!!W@8!*96!+:%!(/'+3:!'9!+'<%P!3.40+!;*3['9&!
;)*9!D/'+:'9!;./%0P!*(!>0+I!"""!6.%(!9.+!(;%3'GC!94<A%0!.G!X4(+'3%(!.9!=MN K O = I!!
• K:%9!no(enactment(of(Congress(under(Commerce(power(is(struck(down(between(1937(and(1995P!9.!+%2+4*)!)'<'+ !
.9!G%6%0*)!&.,%09<%9+Z(!(%%<'9&)C!;)%9*0C!;./%0I!!>)(.P!k!3)*4(%!.9)C!4(%6!+/'3%!+.!(+0'[%!6./9!)*/(I!
*
*
$=J:;>9;<OB*M-*<9*;LB*#BN*MB>?*Q@> C*Q A8 9 8 E<A*.<]L;:*
Lnfh!Lochner(v.(New(YorkP!G0%%6.<!.G!3.9+0* 3 + !
LnQR!Meyer(v.(NebraskaP!;*0%9+*)!*4+.9. <C!
LnQh!Pierce(v.(Socity(of(SistersP!;*0%9+*)!*4+.9.<C!
LnRp!West(Coast(Hotel(v.(Parrish,!G0%%6.<!.G!3.9+0*3+ !
$=J:;>9;<OB*M-3*$BA89F*+>OB*<9*56
;L
*!C*-@<O>AK*.<]L;:*
Lngh!Griswold(v.(Connecticut(D3.9+0*3%;+',%!4(%F!
LnpR!Roe(v.(Wade!D*A.0+'.9F!
LnnQ!Casey(v.(Planned(Parenthood!D0%;0.64 3+ ', %!* 4 + . 9 . <C!
QffR!Lawrence(v.(Texas(D(%24*)!'9+'<*3CF!
!
&
&
&
&
KCMN&'(&O45,$&P&C"=9%:85&H6,,:&)4#D(*VW7Y`ZC*?%/!@%*)!)%&'()*+'.9P!?$8H!. 06% 0(!0% '9 (+* +%<%9+!.G!49'.9!<% < A %0 ( !
• M.40+!:*(!@*<.3)%*9!(/.06!.G!+:%!M.40+!-*3['9&!=3:%<%#!8.A%0+(!(/'+3:%(I!!@'(+'9&4'(:%(!Schechter!.9!
&0.496(!+:*+!+:%!)*A.0!;0*3+'3%!'(!)%((!0%<.+%!'9!+:%!(+0%*<!.G!3.<<%03%#!(4A(+*9+'*)!%GG%3+!
• K%(+#!6.%(!*!3).(%!*96!(4A(+*9+'*)!0%)*+'.9!%2'(+(!A%+/%%9!+:%!'9+0*(+*+%!*3+','+C!*96!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!
• `%0%P!b:%*0!.G!*!(%)GE3.9+*'9%6P!:'&:)C!'9+%&0*+%6!A.6Cc#!60*/!0%(.403%(!G0.<!*96!(%))!.4+;4+!9*+'.9*))C!!
o H4+!%<;).C%%(!X4(+!A%'9&!'9,.),%6!'9!;0.643+'.9!'(!9.+!%9.4&:!'9!'+(%)G!
o -)%9*0C!;./%0!A%3*4(%!.G!'9+%0(+*+%!9*+40%!.G!&%++'9&!(4;;)'%(B/:%0%!(4;;)'%6!+.!
• M:';(!*/*C!*+!Hammer!/B.!6'0%3+)C!.,%00 4 )'9 & !
JH&'(&G"#+>&VW7^WZC*W*'0!$*A.0!=+*96*06(!>3+#!<'9'<4<!/*&%B<*2'<4<!:.40(P!4;:%)6!
• W)*+)C!.,%004)%(!Hammer(v.(DagenhartP!;0 . 3 % (( B ; 0 . 6 43+!6'(+'93+'. 9!6.%(!9.+!3 . 9 + 0.)d'9'+'*)!(+ %;!+.!(+.;;'9 & !
+0*9(;.0+*+'.9!'(!(+.;;'9&!;0.643+'.9!
o 0%X%3+(!Lf>!*;;0.*3:!+.!(+*+%!0%&4)*+'.9!.G!;0.643+'.9 !
o Lf>!6.%(!9.+!'9,*)'6*+%!G%6%0*)!)*/(!+:*+!*0%!/B'9!(3.;%!.G!M.9&0%((Z(!;./%0!DLf>!:*(!9.!
(4A(+*9+',%!3.9+%9+F!
o ;40;.(%!.G!+:%!>3+!'9!_4%(+'.9!/*(!+.!;0%,%9+!4(%!.G!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!+.!;0.<.+%!0*3%!+.!+:%!
A.++.<!A%+/%%9!(+*+%(!D(4A(+*96*06!/.0['9&!3.96'+'.9(F!
• >A*96.9!9.+'.9!+:*+!;./%0!+.!;0.:'A'+!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!'(!)'<'+%6!+.!*0+'3)%(!/:'3:!*0%!:*0<G4)!'9!
+:%<(%),%(!D*0&4%!+:*+!Hammer!/* ( !+: % !6 % ; * 0+ 4 0% P!+ : '(!9 .+'.9!/*(!9% , % 0!' 9 !M . 9 (+ '+4 + '. 9 F!
• 8%X%3+%6!A.+:!(4A(+*9+',%!@-!*96!G%6%0*)'(<!*0&4<%9+(P!.,%004)'9&!)'<'+(!.9!M.9&0%((Z(!;./%0!
!
N,%004)'9&!;0%3%6%9+#!Dsee(Planned(Parenthood(v.(CaseyP!A % ). /F#!US(v.(Darby!G'+(!*))!S!(+*96*06(!
• V.0[*A')'+C!D(4A(+*9+',%!%2;%0'%93%F!
o H'9*0'%(!.G!<*94G*3+40%B+0*6%P!6'0%3+B'96'0%3+!%GG%3+!U3!6'GG'34)+!+.!*;;)C!
o @'(+'93+'.9(!*0%9Z+!G.0<4)*'3!G.0!6%3'('.9!<*['9&!;40;.(%(!
• M:*9&%!'9!G*3+B;%03%;+'.9!.G!G*3+(!D(43:!+:*+!;0%3%6%9+!'(!(%%9!*(!*9!*A*96.9%6!6.3+0'9%F!
o $*'((%a!G*'0%!496%0<'9%6!AC!@%;0%(('.9!
• M:*9&%!'9!6.3+0'9%!D3:';;'9&!*/*C!*+!3*(%P!(')%93%!.9!'((4%!'96'3*+%(!'+!'(!;*((uF!
o NLRB!3*(%!3:';(!*/*C!*+!Hammer!
• 8%)'*93%!D6.9Z+!.,%004)%!'G!;%.;)%!:*,%!0%)'%6!.9!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)'+C!.G!*3+F!
o Hammer!6.%(!9.+!:*, % !( 4 A ( +* 9 +'* ) !0% )'* 9 3 % !
&
Q8@<"#?&'(&R8:+=#5&VW7^5ZC*/:%*+!*)).+<%9+!3*(%P!4;:%)6!*&0'34)+40*)!3*;(!.9!;0.643+'.9P!%,%9!'G!G.0!;0',*+%!4(%!
• ?%'+:%0!'9+%0(+*+%!9.0!3.<<%03%#!8*+'.9*)%#!'<;*3+!.9!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!A%3*4(%!:%!/'+:60%/!:'(!
6%<*96!G0.<!+:%!<*0[%+!
• >&0'34)+40%B<'9'9&B<*94G*3+40%!,%0(4(!3.<<%03%!6'(+'93+'.9!:*(!6'(*;;%*0%6!
• K:'(!'(!+:%!3*(%!+.!A%*+d%,%9!Lopez!6.%(9Z+!.,%0+4 0 9 P!X4 ( +!& % +( !* 0.496!'+I!
*
M=B*-@8AB::*!?>=:BC*(_4%%a%!+:%!A*))..9P!3.4)69Z+!(_4%%a%!'9+.!G0%%6.<!.G!3.9+0*3+!
F4*,&N=8:?859&P&C4"5&E$$S5&'(&N:"8$?,::&VW7Y^ZC*(+*+%!<.0+&*&%!<.0*+.0'4< !)*/!4;: %)6!*&*'9(+!M.9 +0*3+!M)*4(%!
• -046%9+'*)!<.6*)'+C#!%3.9.<'3!30'('(!
o W0*<%0Z(!'9+%9+!'00%)%,*9+#!+:'(!;4A)'3!9%%6!9.+!*;;0%:%96%6!*!3%9+40C!*&.!
• M.9+0*3+(!M)*4(%!'9'+'*))C!496%0(+..6!+.!;0%,%9+!(+*+%(!;0.+%3+'.9!.G!6%A+.0(P!Sturges(v.(Cowninshield!DLeLnF!
o M.9(+0'3+%6!'9!Stone(v.(Mississippi(DLeefFP!3*9!'<;*'0!k!'G!G.0!&%9%0*)!/%)G*0%!
o bV:*+!'(!+:'(!G0%%6.<!.G!3.9+0*3+Y!K:%!M.9(+'+4+'.9!6.%(!9.+!(;%*[!.G!G0%%6.<!.G!3.9+0*3+dc!
• b;0'(.9%0Z(!6')%<<*c!<%9+*)'+C#!)%+!M.9&0%(('.9*)!;./%0!34 0%!3.))%3+',%!*3+'.9!;0.A)%< (!
• =4A(+*9+',%!@-#!"96'3*+%(!M.40+Z(!/'))'9&9%((!+.!6%G%0!+.!&.,Z+!%3.9.<'3!0%&4)*+'.9(!D)%&'+'<*+%!%96P!
0%*(.9*A)%!<%*9(F!
o 8%+0%*+!G0.<!3.9+0*3+!3)*4(%!X40'(;046%93%!
o @'((%9+!D=4+:%0)*96F#!k!3)*4(%!/*(!6%A*+%6!*96!'93)46%6!+.!;0.:'A'+!(+*+%!'9+%0G%0%93%!/'+:!;0',*+%!k!
specifically!'9!+'<%(!.G !9 % %6 !
&
Q,$6&)4"$6&F46,:&'(&I"##8$%&VW7Y`ZC*4;:%)6!/.<%9Z(!<'9'<4<!/*&%!)*/P!M.40+!0%X%3+(!G0%%6.<!.G!3.9+0*3+!6%G%9(%!
• 1((%9+'*))C!.,%004)%(!Lochner(D.,%004)%(!AdkinsP!/:'3:!0%)'% 6 !: % *,')C!.9!LochnerF!
• $'A%0+C!3*9Z+!A%!6%;0',%6!/B.!64%!;0.3%((P!3.9(+'+4+'.9!6.%(9Z+!(;%*[!.G!G0%%6.<!.G!kI!!
• @.%(9Z+!+0C!+.!G'+!'9+.!+:%!;0.+%3+'.9!.G!/.<%9!0*+'.9*)%!.G!Muller(v.(Oregon(DLnfeF!
o @.9Z+!30%*+%6!/*06(!.G!(+*+%!AC!6%;0','9&!G*'0!)*A.0!+0%*+<%9+!+.!/.<%9P!6.9Z+!)%+!%<;).C%0(!%2;).'+!
!
$BA89F*.BA89:;@=A;<89C*MBIB@B9AB*I@8 E*W7Y`aW77_*
@4%!-0.3%((!
! -0.3%640*)#!9.+'3%P!.;;.0+49'+C!+.!A%!:%*06!
! =4A(+*9+',%#!0'&:+(!9.+!%94<%0*+%6!'9!M.9(+'+4+'.9P!)'[%!G0%%6.<!.G!k!
! 7%:'3)%!.G!'93.0;.0*+'.9#!+%2+4*))C!%94<%0*+%6!0'&:+(P!0%)%,*9+!(.,%0%'&9!
&
JH&'(&)"#4:,5,&I#4?=@6$&VW7YXZC*W'))%6!^')[!>3+!6.%(!9.+!,'.)*+%!M.<<%03%!M)*4(%P!@-!
• @'3+4<#!+:%!%2'(+%93%!.G!G*3+(!(4;;.0+'9&!+:%!)%&'()*+',%!X46&<%9+!'(!+.!A%!;0%(4<%6#!rational(basis!
• M.<<%03%!M)*4(%r%9*A)%(!M.9&0%((!+.!%23)46%!;0.643+(!G0.<!+:%!<*0[%+!
• M.9&0%(('.9*)!6%G%0%93%P!:%)6!3.<<'++%%!:%*0'9&(I!!HOK!%,%9!'G!+:%C!:*69Z+P!;0%(4<;+',%!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!
DM.40+!3*9!G'))!'+!'9!G.0!M.9&0%((F!!=+0 . 9 & !@ % G% 0 % 9 3% !
• 196!.G!)'9%!G.0!=4A(+*9+',%!@4%!-0.3%((!3*(%(!
• WNNK?NK1!S#!D6'6!9.+!&%+!*!<*X.0'+CF!
M.40+!/'))!6%G%0!49)%((!(+*+4+%!G*3'*))C!,'.)*+%(!*!M.9(+'+4+'.9*)!;0'93';)%#!'G!'+!'(!;.(('A)%!+.!
3.93%',%!*9C!)%&'+!;40;.(%!G.0!+:%!)*/!
^.0%!(%*03:'9&!'9_4'0C!/:%9!)*/!'9+%0G%0%(!/'+:!'96','64*)!0'&:+(P!0%(+0'3+(!;.)'+'3*)!;0.3%((P!
.0!6'(30'<'9*+%(!*&*'9(+!*!6'(30%+%!*96!'9(4)*0!<'9.0'+C!
o !b9*00./% 0 !(3 . ; % !G. 0 !. ; % 0* + '. 9 !. G!; 0 % (4 <;+'.9!.G!3. 9 (+ '+4 + '. 9 * )'+ C !/ : % 9 !) %& '( )* + '. 9 !* ; ; % *0 ( !. 9 !'+( !
G*3%!+.!A%!/'+:'9 !* !(; %3 'G'3!; 0. :'A '+'. 9!. G!+ : % !M . 9 (+ '+4+'.9c!!!
!b499%3%( (* 0 C !+. !3 . 9 (' 6 %0 !/:%+:%0!)%&'( )* + '. 9 !/:'3:!0%(+0'3+ (!+ : . (% !; . )' +'3 * )!; 0 . 3% ( (% ( !/:'3:!
3*9!.06'9*0')C!A%!%2;%3+%6!+.!A0'9&!*A.4+!0%;%*)!.G!496%('0*A)%!)%&'()*+'.9!'(!+.!A%!(4AX%3+%6!
+.!<.0%!%2*3+'9&!X46'3'*)!(304+'9C!496% 0!+: %!&%9%0*)!;0.:'A'+'.9(!.G!+:%!LS>!+:*9!*0%!.+:%0!
+C;%(!.G!)%&'(c!
• M.40+!'(!0%G%0%%!.G!6%<.30*+'3!;0.3%((P!;.)'3'9&!;.)'+'3*)!0'&:+(!
?.!9%%6!+.!%9_4'0%!/:%+:%0!('<')*0!3.9('6%0*+'.9(!%9+%0!'9+.!+:%!0%,'%/!.G!(+*+4+%(!6'0%3+%6!
*+!0%)'&'.4(P!9*+'.9*)P!0*3'*)PP!/:%+:%0!;0%X46'3%!* & * '9 ( +!6 '( 3 0% +% !* 9 6 !'9 ( 4 )* 0 !<'9.0'+'%(!< * C!
A%!*!(;%3'*)!3.96'+'.9P!/:'3:!340+*')(!+:%!.;%0*+'.9!.G!;.)'+'3*)!;0.3%((%(!+:*+!4(4*))C!;0.+%3+!
<'9.0'+'%(!
• M.49+%0<*X.0'+*0'*9!G493+'.9!.G!M.40+!+.!;0.+%3+!<'9.0'+'%(!
• 1)C#!M.40+!(+%;(!'9!+.!;0.+%3+!(.3'%+CZ(!;*0'*:(!
• K0'A%#!3:..('9&!/:'3:!&0.4;(!+.!;0.+%3+!6%;%96(!'+(%)G!.9!;./%0!.G!+:%!b;./%0)%((c!
&0.4;!
• >3[%0<*9#!b6'(30%+%!*96!'9(4)*0c!0%_4'0%(!+:*+!<'9.0'+'%(!<4(+!A%!&:%++.'a%6!+.!A%!
;0.+%3+%6!
• O96%0!&*<%!+:%.0CP!+:.(%!&0.4;(!+:*+!*0%!'9(4)*0!3*9!<.A')'a%!A%++%0Y!
• N,%0,'%/#!-)%9*0C!;./%0P!*96!6%G%0%9+'*)!X46'3'*0C!D.9)C!&%+!:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9C!'G!A)*+*9+!H.G8!,'.)*+'.9P!
6%<.30*+'3!;0.3%((!G*')P!.0!6%<.30*+'3!+C0*99C!.,%0!6'(30%+%!*96!'9(4)*0!<'9.0'+'%(F!
o 12;0%((!0'&:+(!'9!H'))!.G!8'&:+(!
@'(+'9&4'(:!LochnerP!/:'3:!0%)'%6!.9!49%94 <%0*+%6!0'& : + !
"93.0;.0*+%6!,'*!LS >!
o "9G0'9&%(!.9!6%<.3 0*+'3!; 0.3 %((!
7.+%P!*((%<A)CP!*((.3'*+'.9P!U3I!
M.40+!'(!3.49+%0<*X.0'+*0'*9P!A4+!;0.+%3+(!G493+'.9*)'+C!.G!6%<.30*+'3!(C(+%<!
@.%(!9.+!'<;)'3*+%(LochnerP!A%3*4 (% !0 '& : + !'( !;.)'+'3*)P!9.+!%3.9.<'3!
o `*0<G4)!+.!6'(30%+%!*96!'9(4)*0!<'9.0'+'%(!
-%0%99'*)!)./%0(!(4&&%(+!*!6%<.30*3C!G*')P!;0.+%3+!<'9.0'+'%(!+.!G.)6!+:%<!'9+.!+:%!<*X.0'+C!
@'(30%+%!*96!'9(4)*0#!:'(+.0C!.G!6'(30'<'9*+'.9P!;.)'+'3*)!;./%0)%((9%((P!
'<<4+*A )%B , '('A )% B 6 '(+'9&4'(:'9&!3:*0*3+%0'(+'3(!
• M.40+Z(!(4A(+*9+',%!,*)4%!X46&<%9+(!496%0!Carolene!
o V:'3:!&0.4;(!*0%!6'(30%+%B'9(4)*0!<'9.0'+'%(!
o V:'3:!&.,%09<%9+!'9+%0%(+(!*0%!3.<;%))'9&!
o V:*+!)%,%)!.G!&%9%0*)'+C!*+!/:'3:!+.!'6%9+'GC!+:%!3.<;%+'9&!'96','64*)!0'&:+!
o H*)*93'9&!
!
Q8::8"*$45&'(&C,,&BD68@":*VW7_ _ZC*=+*+4+%!6'(+'9&4'(:%(!.;:+:*)<.).&'(+(B.;+.<%+0'(+(!*96!.;+'3'*9(#!4;:%)6!
• @-!*96!1-!3:*))%9&%(P!%2+0%<%!6%G%0%93%!+.!)%&'()*+40%r*9C!'<*&'9*A)%!0*+'.9*)%!
o -0%(30';+'.9(!3.9+*'9!'<;.0+*9+!'9G.0<*+'.9!
o 1C%!%2*<(!3*9!6%+%3+!)*+%9+!*')<%9+(!
o 8%<.,%!G0.<!3.<<%03'*)!0%*)<!
• M*9!.9)C!%2:*4(+!0*+'.9*)'+C!/:%9!C.4!3*9!(:./!+:*+!*9'<4(!'(!+:%!.9)C!0%*(.9!
• ?%%6!G.0!X46'3'*)!6%G%0%93%#!)%&'()*+40%P!9.+!3.40+(P!A*)*93%!*6,*9+*&%(!*96!6'(*6,*9+*&%(!
o `C;.+:%('a%6!0%*(.9(!G.0!+:%!)%&'()*+40%!
o @-!3)*4(%!9.!).9&%0!4(%6!+.!(+0'[%!6./9!0%&4)*+'.9(!.G!A4('9%((!G.0!A%'9&!.4+!.G!<.6%!/'+:!*!
;*0+'34)*0!(3:..)!.G!+:.4&:+!D)*'((%aEG*'0%F!
&
!<O<?*.<]L;:*(A;*=GLB?F*=9FB@*!8EEB@AB*!?>=:B*V-?B9>@K*-8NB@*8I*!89]@B::Z*
F,"#6&47&E6:"56"&!46,:&'(&JH*VW7b^ZC*M',')!8'&:+(!>3+!4;:%)6!496%0!M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!
• 8*+'.9*)!A*('(#!'+!*GG%3+(!3.<<%03%P!9.+!6%3'6%6!496%0!LRB L S > !
o :.+%)!&%+(!.4+!.G!(+*+%!A4('9%((!
o )*3[!.G!*33.<< . 6 *+'. 9( !G.0!A )*3[ (!'(!( %, %0% !
• M',')!8'&:+(!>3+!.G!LephP!('<')*0)C!;0.:'A'+%6!0*3%EA*(%6!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!'9!;4A)'3!*33.<<.6*+'.9(P!/*(!
(+C<'%6!496%0!LRIQ!*96!LSIh!
o ?.0<*+',%!6'GG'34)+C!/:%9!*99.493'9&!496%0!M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!!
o M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!,%0C!;./%0G4)!*+!+:%!+'<%P!A4+!%AA'9&!'9!(+0%9&+:r;0.A)%<Y!
• K%(+!;0',')%&%(!<.+',%P!A4+!.9)C!'G!'9,'6'.4(!'9!9*+40%!!
T"6U,5+"@%&'(&!@):=59&VW7b^ZC*!0%(+*40*9 +!& % + (!<%*+!G0.<!. 4 +!. G !(+ * +% P!(4 G G'3 '% 9 +!+ . !*;;)C!M.<< % 0 3 %!M ) *4 ( % !
• >0+'G'3'*)!0%(+0'3+'.9!.9!<*0[%+!D9.!A)*3[(!(;%96'9&F!'9+%0G%0%(!/'+:!G)./!
• O90%(+B6%;0%((%6!A4('9%((!*3+','+C!'9!(%&0%&*+%6!3.<<49'+'%(!
• @%+%00%93%!.G!;0.G%(('.9*)B(['))%6!)*A.0!3)*((%(!G0.< !'9 : *A '+'9& !(%& 0% &* +%6 !*0% *(!
*
&
JH&'(&C4D,U&VW77_ZC*]49!W0%%!=3:..)!v.9%(!>3+!.,%0+409%6P!9.!9%24(!A%+/%%9!&49(!'9!(3:..)(!*96!3.<<%03%!
]49(!'9!(3:..)(!'(!9*+'.9*)P!A4+!9.+!G%6%0*)!;0.A)%<I!!1643*+'.9!*96!30'<%!*0%!+0*6'+'.9*))C!(+*+%!3.93%09(I!
• M.9&0%((!3*9!0%&4)*+%6!R!A0.*6!3*+%&.0'%(!.G!*3+','+C!
o M:*99%)(!.G!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!D/*+%0/*C(P!+0*9(;.0+F!
o "9(+04<%9+*)'+'%(!.G!'9+%0(+* +%!3. < < %03 %P!.0!;% 0(.9 (!.0 !+:'9& (!'9!'9+%0 (+*+%!3. < < % 03%!D3 *00'% 0(F!
o >3+','+'%(!+:*+!b(4A(+*9+'*))C!*GG%3+c!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!
13.9.<'3!'9!9*+40%#!6'(+'9&4'(:%(!Wickard(v.(FillburnP!&0./'9&!/:%*+!' (!%3.9 .<'3!'9!9*+40%P!
/:%0%*(!&49!;.((%(('.9!'(!9.+!
540'(6'3+'.9*)!% )%<%9+#!b+:*+!:*(!< . ,% 6 !'9!. 0!+: * +!.+ :% 0/'(%!*GG%3+(!'9+%0(+* +%!. 0!G. 0% '&9 !
3.<<%03%cP!:%0%P!&49(!6'69Z+!:*,%!+.!A%!&49(!+:*+!:*6!<.,%6!'9!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!
M.9&0%(('.9*)!G'96'9&(#!:%0%P!9.+:'9&!'9!)%&'()*+',%!:'(+.0CdG'96'9&(!*0%!9%'+:%0!9%3%((*0C!
9.0!(4GG'3'%9+P!A4+!+:%C!:%);!
?%24(#!:%0%P!)'9[!A%+/%%9!*3+','+C!*96!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!3*9Z+!A%!too(attenuated(DH0%C%0Z(!
(4&&%(+%6!)'9[!'(!+..!*++%94*+%6F!
• >3[%0<*9#!<.<%9+!.G!:'&:%0!)*/E<*['9&P!9%/!M.9(+'+4+'.9*)!%0*Y!
o k%99%6CZ(!3.93400%93%#!(+043+40*)!<.6*)'+CP!;0'93';)%(!.G!G%6%0*)'(<!
1643*+'.9!'(!(+*+%!3.93%09!
=+*+%(!*0%!)*A.0*+.0'%(!.G!%2;%0'<%9+*+'.9!
o K:.<*(Z(!3.93400%93%#!.;%9!+.!0%,'('+'9&!;0%ELnRp!3*(%(P!+0%*+'9&!;.(+E?%/!@%*)!%0*!*(!*AA%0*+'.9!
K%2+4*)#!*&&0%((',%)C!.0'&'9*)'(+P!!9*00./!4(%!.G!b3.<<%03%Pc!.0!%)(%!.+:%0!%94<%0*+%6!
;./%0(!*0%!(40;)4(*&%!
"9+0*+%2+4*)P!3.<< % 03%!(: .4 )6!*)/ * C(!< % *9 !+:%!(*<%!+:'9&!D'9!-.0+!-0%G%0%93%!M)*4(%P!
M.<<%03%!<%*9(!(*)%B+0*9(;.0+F!
o =+%,%9Z(!6'((%9+#!<'(3*)34)*+%6!3*+%&.0'%(P!+:%!&49(!*0%!3*+%&.0C!QP!b+:'9&(!'9!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%c!
o =.4+%0Z(!6'((%9+#!6.3+0'9*)B;046%9+'*)#!6.3+0'9*)!'9(+*A')'+C!.G!;0%ELnRp!X40'(;046%93%!
o H0%C%0Z(!6'((%9+#!<.0%!6%G%0%93%!+.!M.9&0%((!0%_4'0%6P!)'9[!A%+/%%9!&49(!*96!(3:..)(!'(!0*+'.9*)P!
3.40+!<4(+!0%,'%/!34<4)*+',%!%GG%3+(!/'+:!)*+'+46%!
!
JH&'(&!4##8$45&V5666ZC*7'.)%93%!>&*'9(+!V.<%9!>3+P!3',')!*3+'.9!+.!0*;%!,'3+'<(r)'9[!+..!*++%94*+%6 !
• 8%*GG'0<!Lopez!+%(+!D3:*99%)(P!'9(+0 4 <%9+*)'+'%(P!(4 A ( +* 9 + '* )!% GG% 3 +F !
• $'+'&*+'.9!.33400%6!A%G.0%!M.9&0%((!3.4)6!*<%96!7>^>!*G+%0!Lopez!
• NZM.99.0Z(!(/'9&!,.+%!&.%(!A%3*4(%!.G!+:%!(+*+%Z(!0'&:+(!'((4%#!(+*+%(!:*,%!3',')!*3+'.9!;0.,'('.9(#!+0*6'+'.9*)!
*0%*!.G!(+*+%!)*/P!*96!9.+!%3.9.<'3!!
o M.9&0%((!"?MN881MK$\!3.93)46%6!+:*+!'+!6.%(!*GG%3+!M.<<%03%!D9.!6%G%0%93%F!
o @'((%9+#!9.+!+:%!A4('9%((!.G!+:%!M.40+!+.!(%3.96!&4%((!M.9&0%(('.9*)!G'96'9&(!
A45U":,$&'(&M"8@%*V566_ZC*(+*+%!<*0'X4*9*!)*/ (P!A4+!9.!%23%;+'.9 !G.0!<%6'3*)!4(%!'9!G%6!)*/!
• K%(+!3*(%#!*))!;403:*(%B4(%!'9!M>P!9.!3.99%3+'.9!+.!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%P!A4+!4;:%)6!Wickard(v.(Fillburn!
• >;;)'%6!Lopez!+%(+#!'9+0*(+*+%!;0.64 3 +!. G !3. <<.6'+C!(. ) 6 !'9 !'9 +% 0 ( +* +% !3 . <<%03%!"=!% 3. 9 . <'3!'9!9*+40%!
o M*9!:*,%!(4A(+*9+'*)!%GG%3+!A*(%6!.9!34<4)*+',%!'<;*3+!
o M.40+!*&&0%&*+%(P!%,%9!'G!9.+!;403:*('9&!'9+%0(+*+%P!C.4!*0%!+*['9&!6%<*96!.4+!.G!+:%!'9+%0(+*+%!
<*0[%+!
• M.9&0%((!@N1=!:*,%!;./%0!+.!0%&4)*+%P!*96!G%6%0*)!)*/!+04<;(!(+*+%!)*/!D(+*+%!/.9Z+!;0.(%34+%P!A4+!G%6(!3*9F!
!
?NK1#!*(!M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!;)%9*0C!;./%0!'(!/'+:60*/9P!M.9&0%((!+409(!+.!.+:%0!;./%0(!+.!0%&4)*+%!D'I%IP!(;%96'9&!
;./%0P!/'+:!60*/!G%6%0*)!G496'9&!49)%((!(+*+%(!3.<;)CF!
*
$GB9F<9]*-8NB@*(?;B@9> ;<O B C *;0.,'('.9(!G.0!&%9%0*)!/%)G*0%!D>0+I"!je!M)ILF!*96!+*2*+'.9!;./%0!D'9G%0!(;%96'9&F!
! V:%9!M.9&0%((!3*9Z+!*3:'%,%!+:'9&(!+:0.4&:!6'0%3+!0%&4)*+'.9!D'I%IP!0%(+0*'9+!.9!M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!;.(+ELopez(
H4=6%&G"<46"&'(&G4:,*VW7X`ZC*/:%9!M.9&0%((!3*9!4(%!G%6%0*)!G496'9&!*(!'93%9+',%(!G.0!(+*+%!*3+','+C!&
• >3+!&*,%!(+*+%(!'93%9+',%!+.!0*'(%!60'9['9&!*&%!+.!QLP!+.!&%+!:' &: /*C!G496(!
• K%(+#!S!0%_4'0%<%9+(!G.0!3.96'+'.9(!.9!G%6%0*)!&0*9+(!
o "9!;40(4'+!.G!&%9%0*)!/% )G*0%!
o O9*<A'&4.4(P!(.!+:*+!(+*+%(![9./!0*<'G'3*+'.9(!.G!9.93.<;)'*93%!
o 8%)*+%6!+.!+:%!G%6%0*)!'9+%0%(+!'9!;*0+'34)*0!9*+'.9*)!;0.X%3+(!.0!;0.&0*<(!
o ^*C!9.+!,'.)*+%!.+:%0!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)!;0.,'('.9(!
*
*
28@<c89;>?*/BFB@>?<:E#!$'<'+(!.9!(+ * +% !; . / % 0*
! -0%%<;+'.9!D/:%0%!M.9&0%((!:*(!*3+%6P!=4;0%<*3C!M)*4(%P!3*9!A%!%2;0%((!.0!'<;)'%6F!
@.0<*9+!M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!D/:%0%!3.9&0%((!:*(9Z+!*3+%6P!A4+!(+*+%(!3*9Z+!A406%9!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%F!
-0',')%&%(!*96!"<<49'+'%(!D>0+I!"7F!D)'<'+(!*A')'+C!.G!(+*+%(!+.!6'(30'<'9*+%!*&*'9(+!.4+E.GE(+*+%0(F!
W4))!W*'+:!*96!M0%6'+!D>0+I!"7F!
*
M8@E>9;*!8EEB@AB*!?>=:B*
• 1,%9!/:%9!M.9&0%((!:*(9Z+!*3+%6P!+:%!M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!0%(+0'3+(!(+*+%!0%&4)*+'.9!.G!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!
(43:!+:*+!(+*+%(!3*99.+!%9&*&%!'9!%3.9.<'3!;0.+%3+'.9'(<I!D(+*+%(!<*C !9.+!A406% 9!'9+%0(+*+%!3.< <% 03%F!
• M.40+(!:*,%!;./%0!+.!;)*3%!)'<'+(!.9!(+*+%!*4+:.0'+C!
o >0&4<%9+(!G.0#!:'(+.0'3*)P!%3.9.<C!A%++%0!.GG!/B.!(+*+%!;0.+%3+'.9'(<P!;.)'+'3*)!0%;0%(%9+*+'.9!
49%,%9!A%+/%%9!0%('6%9+(!*96!9.90%('6%9+(!.G!(+*+%(!DMcCullochF!
o >0&4<%9+(!*&*'9(+#!9.!+%2+4*)!A*('(P!-U"!'9!M.9(+'+4+'.9P!X.A!G.0!M.9&0%((!9.+!X46'3'*0C!+.!6%3'6%!
/:*+!(+*+%(!0%+*'9!3.9+0.)!.,%0!D+:.4&:P!3*9!M.9&0%((!%9&*&%!'9!+:'(!<43:!.,%0('&:+YFP!!
• M.9&0%((!*)(.!3*99.+!%2%03'(%!3%0+*'9!;./%0(!6%)%&*+%6!+.!M.9&0%((!'9!*A(%93%!.G!M.9&0%(('.9*)!*3+'.9#!
o ?N!V*0B+0%*+C!;./%0(!
o \1=!+*2*+'.9!D3.93400%9+!;./%0F!
o ?.!%94<%0*+'.9!'96'3*+%(!/:'3:!;./%0(!*0%!%23)4(',%!.0!3.93400%9+!D6.3+0'9%B:'(+.0C!6%3'6%(F!
• =+*+%!)*/(!+:*+!6'(30'<'9*+%!*&*'9(+!.4+E.GE(+*+%0(!D(4(;'3'.4(P!.9)C!*))./%6!'G!9%3%((*0C!*96!)%*(+!0%(+0'3+',%FP!
.0!(+*+%!)*/!+:*+!+0%*+(!+:%!(*<%!A4+!(+'))!A406%9(!DA*)*93'9&!+%(+F!
• 123%;+'.9(#!
o M.9&0%((!:*(!;)%9*0C!;./%0!+.!0%&4)*+%!3.<<%03%P!<*C!*4+:.0'a%!(+*+%!)*/(!
o ^*0[%+!;*0+'3';*9+!%23%;+'.9!D(+*+%!&.,Z+!<*C!G*,.0!./9!3'+'a%9(!'9!6%*)'9&!/'+:!&.,Z+!./9%6!
A4('9%((%(#!*(!3.9(4<%0(P!(+*+%(!3*9!;0%G%0!+:%!(4;;)C!.G!+:%'0!./9!3'+'a%9(F!
• ?.+!%23)4(',%#!(+*+%!*3+'.9(!<*C!*)(.!A%!3:*))%9&%6!.9!-U"!DG496*<%9+*)!0'&:+!.0!'<;.0+*9+!%3.9.<'3!
*3+','+CF!.0!1-!D)*/!(!+:*+!6'(30'<'9*+%!*&*'9(+!.4+E.GE(+*+%0(!3*9!A%!3:*))%9&%6F!
&
A8++45$&'(&B9?,5*VWX5^ZC**
^*0(:*))#!;./%0!b+.!0%&4)*+%c!%23)46%(!+:%!*3+'.9(!.G!.+:%0(!.9!+:%!(*<%!+:'9&!
• H0.*6!6%G'9'+'.9!.G!M.9&0%((Z(!;./%0#!!
o M.<<%03%!T!*))!(+*+%(!.G!A4('9%((P!b*<.9&!+:%!(+*+%(c!T!*9C+:'9&!*GG%3+'9&!<.0%!+:*9!.9%!(+*+%!
o "96%;%96%9+!)'<'+!.9 !(+*+% !;./%0P!%,%9!/:%0%!M.9& 0%(( !:*(9 Z+!*3+%6 #!/: %0% !(+*+%!0%& 4 )*+%(!3. < < % 03%!
/'+:!G.0%'&9!9*+'.9(!.0!*<.9&!+:%!(+*+%(!
M.93400%93%#!%,%9!(+0.9&%0P!(*+%!3*9Z+!&',%!<.9.;.)'%(!.9!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!%,%9!/:%0%!M.9&0%((!:*(!*3+%6!
&
Q8:$45&'(&N:"@<VN8#?&)#,,<&!"#$%&)4(&VWX57ZC*@%)*/*0%!*4+:.0'a%6!*!6*<!
• `%0%P!(+*+%!*3+'.9!'(!6'(+'9&4'(:%6!A%3*4(%!A4')6'9&!*!6*<!'(!;%0<'(('A)%!%2%03'(%!.G!;.)'3%!;./%0!
o 8%X%3+!6.0<*9+!3.<<%03%!3)*4(%!+.!4;:.)6!(+*+%!*3+'.9#!;.)'3%!;./%0(!*0%!9.+!0%;4&9*9+!+.!
'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!'G!9.!%3. 9 . < '3 !; 0. +% 3+ '.9 '( <!
• >))./%6!@%)*/*0%!+.!%9&*&%!'9!*3+','+C!+:*+!*GG%3+(!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!*(!).9&!*(!M.9&0%((!:*(9Z+!(;.[%9!
• M.9&0%((!9%%6(!+.!(;%*[!'G!'+Z(!&.'9&!+.!&%+!/:*+!'+!/*9+(!
!
-0.A)%<!/'+:!Gibbons(v.(Ogden!+%(+#!;.)'3%!;./%0 !* 9 6 !3.<<%03%!0 % &4)*+'.9!.,%0)* ; !
N+:%0!G*3+.0(!+.!A*)*93%#!9*+'.9*)B(+*+%!(4AX%3+!<*++%0P!6'0%3+B'96'0%3+!%GG%3+(!.9!3.<<%03%!
!
@.0<*9+!M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!*9*)C('(!.G!=+*+%!8%&4)*+'.9!
LI =+0.9&!;0%(4<;+'.9!.G!'9,*)'6'+C!'G!(+*+4+%!6'(30'<'9*+%(!*&*'9(+!.4+E.GE(+*+%0(Z!
*I "G!6'(30'<'9*+.0CP!+:%9!4; :%)6 !only(if!'+!'(!9%3% (( * 0 C!+ . !* 3: ' %, % !* 9 6 !'<;.0+*9+!;4 0 ; . ( % !
AI "G!9.96'(30'<'9*+. 0C P!+:%9!'9, *)'6 *+%!only(if!'+(!A40 6 % 9(!.9 !'9+%0(+*+%!3.<< %03% !.4+/% '&:!'+(!A%9%G'+(!
QI @.%(!(+*+%!0%&4)*+'.9!'<;'9&%!.9!*3+','+C!3.,%0%6!AC!(+*+%!0%&4)*+'.9Y!
*I \1=#!'9,*)'6!496%0!;0%E%<;+'.9!*9*)C('(!'G!3.9G)'3+(!DGibbons(v.(OgdenF!
AI ?N#!&.!+.!_4%(+'.9!Q!
RI @.%(!(+*+%!0%&4)*+'.9!6'(30'<'9*+%!*&*'9(+!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%Y!
*I W*3'*)!@'(30'<'9*+'.9#!'9,*)'6!49)%((!'+!<%%+(!(+0'3+!(304+'9CP!,'0+4*)!per(se!04)%!.G!'9,* )'6 '+ C I!!!
AI 123%;+'.9(#!?*00./)C!K*').0%6!.0!M.9&0%(('.9*)!>;;0.,*)!.0!^*0[%+!-*0+'3';*9+!123%;+'.9!
'I ?*00./)C!K*').0%6#!9.9E%3.9.<'3!(+*+%!'9+%0%(+!*96!9.!0%*(.9*A)%!9.96'(30'<'9*+.0C!
*)+%09*+',%(I!!^%*9(E%96!+*').0'9&!'<;.0+*9+I!!?.!%3.9.<'3!;0.+%3+'.9'(<P!<.0%!+:*9!<%0%!
6%G%0%93%!+.!b)%&'+'<*+%!;40;.(%c!
LI $'<'+'9&!*33%((!+.!'9E(+*+%!0%(.403%(!
*I Hughes(v.(Oklahoma(DLnpnFP!'9,*)'6!)*/!+:*+!0%(%0,%6!;0.G'+'9&!G0.<!
<'99./!G'(:'9&!+.!(+*+%!0%('6%9+((!
AI Philadelphia(v.(New(Jersey!DLnpeF#!A*9!.9!'<;.0+*+'.9!. G!/*(+%!'(!(+043 [ !
6./9P!;0.+%3+'.9'(+!)'<'+!.G!*33%((!+.!'9E(+*+%!0%(.403%(!
QI $'<'+'9&!*33%((!+.!).3*)!<*0[%+(!
*I Maine(v.(Taylor!DLnegF#!A*9!.9!'<;.0+'9&!.4 +E.GE(+*+%!G'(:!4;:%)6!
'I K:0%*+!.G!'9G%3+'.9B9.99*+',%!(;%3'%(!+:0%*+!+.!%9,'0.9<%9+!
''I ?.!)%((!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!<%*9(!+.!;0.<.+%!).3*)!;40;.(%!
RI 8%_4'0'9&!4(%!.G!).3*)!A4('9%((%(!
*I Pike(v.(Bruce(Church!DLnpfFP!'9,*)'6 * +% 6 !>v!0%&!+:*+!3* 9 +* ). 4 ; % ( !& 0. /9!'9!
(+*+%!A%!;*3[%6!'9!(+*+%#!!
'I M.40+!(4(;'3'.4(!.G!(+*+4+%(!0%_4'0'9&!A4('9%((!.;%0*+'.9(!+.!A%!
;%0G.0<%6!'9!(+*+%!/:%0%!+:%C!3.4)6!A%!<.0%!%GG'3'%9+!%)(%/:%0%!
SI "9,*)'6!'G!+:%0%!*0%!*,*')*A)%!9. 96 '(30'< '9 *+. 0C!< % *9 (!DHughes(v.(OklahomaF!
''I M.9&0%(('.9*)!*;;0.,*)#!
LI M.9&0%((!3*9!%9*3+!)%&'()*+'.9!permitting!+:%!(+*+%!0%&4)*+'.9 P!/ : % 0 % !+: % 0 %!/.4)6!
.+:%0/'(%!A%!*[email protected]<*9+!M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!;0.A)%<I!!!
QI M.9&0%((!3*9!A*9!/:*+!+:%!M.40+!:*(!A)%((%6P!*96!A)%((!/:*+!+:%!M.40+!:*(!A*99%6I!
'''I =+*+%!'(!*!<*0[%+!;*0+'3';*9+!
LI =+*+%!<*C!G*,.0!'+(!./9!3'+'a%9(!'9!6%*)'9&!/'+:!&.,Z+!./9%6!A4('9%((%(!*96!
0%3%','9&!&.,%09<%9+!A%9%G'+(!
QI ?.!6.0<*9+!3.<<%03%!3)*4(%!/:%0%!+:%!(+*+%!'(!?NK!*!0%&4)*+.0!
*I ?.+%#!X4(+!AB3!@MM!6.%(9Z+!*;;)CP!>0+I!"7!-U"!.0!LS>!1-!<'&:+!
RI Hughes(v.(Alexandria(Scrap(Corp.(DLnpgF#!(+*+%!9.+!*3+'9&!*(!*!0%&4)*+.0!
*I ^@!0'6(!(+*+%!.G!*A*96.9%6!*4+.<.A')%(!AC!;*C'9&!G.0!'9.;%0*A)%!3*0(I!!
^.0%!;0..G!.G!./9%0(:';!0%_4'0%6!G.0!.4+E.GE(+*+%0(I!!!
AI >(!<*0[%+!;*0+'3';*9+!DA4C'9&!+:%!3*0(F!(+*+%!3*9!%2%03'(%!'+(!0'&:+!+.!G*,.0!
'+(!./9!3'+'a%9 ( !
SI M.96'+'.9(!'<;.(%6!<4(+!9.+!:*,%!(4A(+*9+'*)!0%&4)*+.0C!%GG%3+!.4+('6%!+:%!<*0[%+I!
hI V:%0%!(+*+%!'(!(;%*['9&P!L>!6.%(9Z+!*;;)CP!AB3!(+*+%!:*(!*!G.04<!+.!60./9!.4+!.+:%0(!
gI $'9%!A%+/%%9!0%&4)*+.0!*96!<*0[%+!;*0+'3';*9+!'(!A)400CP!3*9!(+'))!A%!;0.+%3+'.9'(+!
3I ?.!6'(30'<'9*+'.9#!H*)*93%!A406%9!.9!'9 +%0 (+* +%!3. < <%03%!*&*'9(+!).3*)!A %9 %G'+( I!!].!+. !_4 % (+'.9 !R I !
SI @.%(!+:%!(+*+%!0%&4)*+'.9!A406%9!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%Y!!H*)*93%!A%9%G'+!.G!(+*+%!)*/!*96!A406%9!.9!3.<<%03%!
Amanda Bakale 4/27/09 3:55 PM
Comment: =%%!G)./3:*[email protected]<*9+!
M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!*9*)C('(!.G!(+*+%!
0%&4)*+'.9!
*I "9,*)'6!'G!A406%9(P!49)%((!+:% !(+*+%Z(!'9+% 0%(+!'9!0%& 4 )*+'.9 !.4 +/ %'&: (!+:%!A4 06%9!.9 !'9+%0(+*+%!
3.<<%03%I!!!
AI -0.A)%<#!'(!+:'(!A*)*93'9&!+%(+!(4'+%6!+.!X46'3'*0CY!!=+*+%!'9+%0%(+(!*96!3.<<%03%!A406%9(!*0%!6'GG'34)+!
+.!3.<;*0%I!
hI M*9!A%!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!'9!%GG%3+P!'G!9.+!'9!;40;.(%I!
*I Pike(v.(Bruce(Church!DLnpfF#!!
'I K1=K#!/:%0%!(+*+4+%!0%&4)*+%(!%,%9:*96%6)C!G.0!)%&'+'<*+%!).3*)!'9+%0%(+P!*96!+:%!%GG%3+(!.9!
'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!*0%!.9 )C !'9 3'6 % 9 +* )P!'+!/ ') )!A% !4 ; :% )6 !4 9 )%( (!+: % !A4 0 6 %9 !. 9 !3. < <%03%!'(!
3)%*0)C!%23%((',%!'9!0%)*+'.9!+.!+:%!).3*)!A%9%G'+(!
LI $%*(+!0%(+0'3+',%!*)+%09*+',%!D3*9!'9+%0%(+!A%!;0.<.+%6!*(!/%))!/'+:!*!)%((%0!'<;*3+!
.9!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%FP!A4+!3.40+!:*(!9%,%0!'9,*)'6*+%6!.9!+:'(!&0.496(!D*))!
0%X%3+%6!)*/(!496%0!6.0<*9+!3.< < %03%!3)*4(% !:*,%!A%%9 !6'(30'<'9* +.0CP!A4+!6.. 0!
'(!.;%9F!!`./ % , %0P!)% * (+!0 %( +0'3 +', % !< % *9 ( !'(!&% 9 % 0 *))C!.9)C!4(%6!/:%0%!+:%0%!'(!
:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9C!
QI "(!0%&4)*+'.9!%,%9E:*96%6!/'+:!'93'6%9+*)!%GG%3+(!.9!3.<<%03%P!.0!6.%(!'9!
6'(30'<'9*+%!*&*'9(+!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!.9!G*3%!.0!'9!%GG%3+Y!D1"K`18!'9+%9+!.0!
%GG%3+F!
''I M.40+(!3*9!%2%03'(%!).+(!.G!6'(30%+'.9!
'''I ?.!'9+%9+!+.!6'(30'<'9*+%!*&*'9(+!.4+!.G!(+*+%!3.<<%03%P!A4+!A406%9!.9!3.<<%03%!%23%%6%6!
+:%!(+*+%!A%9%G'+(I!
AI Hughes(v.(Oklahoma!DLnpnF#!(+*+4+%!; 0 %, % 9 + (!+ 0* 9 ( ; . 0+ !. G!<'99./(!G. 0!( * )% !. 4 +( '6 % !+ : %!( + *+ %!
'I 8%G'9%6!Pike!04)%!
LI @.%(!3:*))%9&%6!(+*+4+%!0%&4)*+%!%,%9E:*96%6)C!/'+:!.9)C!'93'6%9+*)!%GG%3+(P!.0!6.%(!
'+!6'(30'<'9*+% !*& * '9 (+ !'9+ %0 (+* + %!3 .<<%03%!.9!'+(!G* 3% !.0 !'9 !;0 * 3+'3 * )!%GG% 3+!
QI @.%(!(+*+4+%!(%0,%!*!)%&'+'<*+%!).3*)!;40;.(%P!*96!'G!(.P!3*9!*)+%09*+',%!<%*9(!
;0.<.+%!+:'(!;40;.(%!*(!%GG%3+',%)C!/'+:.4+!6'(30'<'9*+'9&I!
!
!
-@<O<?B]B*>9F*&EE=9<;<B:*!?>=:B*D0'&:+(!*0%!49%94<%0*+%6F!
=+*+%(!3*99.+!6'(30'<'9*+%!*&*'9(+!.4+E.GE(+*+%0(!/'+:!0%(;%3+!+.!%'+:%0!fundamental(rights (.0(imp o r ta n t (ec o n o mic(
activities!
! W496*<%9+*)!0'&:+(r3*9!A%!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)P!A4+!(4'+(!&%9%0*))C!A0.4&:+!496%0!H.G8BLS>!*9C/*C !
! 13.9.<'3!*3+','+'%(r<.(+!6%*)!/'+:!).3*)!)*/(!'9+%0G%0'9&!/'+:!*A')'+C!+.!%*09!*!)',%)':..6I!
! ! 12IP!3*9Z+!0%(+0'3+!%9+0C!+.!*!;0.G%(('.9P!3*9Z+!3:*0&%!<.0%!G.0!)'3%9(%!
>))./%6!N?$\!"W!(4A(+*9+'*))C!0%)*+%6!+.!*!(4A(+*9+'*)!(+*+%!'9+%0%(+I!
$'<'+%6!+.!3'+'a%9(!D3.0;.0*+'.9(!*96!*)'%9(!3*99.+!(4%!496%0!-U"F!
@'(+'9&4'(:!G0.<!-0',')%&%(!.0!"<<49'+'%(!M)*4(%!.G!LS>#!LS>!:*(!9*00./!3.9(+043+'.9P!0*0%)C!4(%6I*
>0+I!"7!0'&:+(!*0%!9.+!G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+(!'9!+:%!+0*6'+'.9*)!(%9(%d-U"!0'&:+(!'9!LS>!*0%!G496* <%9+*)!DCorfieldF!
!
)4#78,:?&'(&)4#>,::&V!!QM*->*WX5YZC*=MNKO=!0'6'9&!3'034'+P!0%3.&9'a%(!(%,%0*)!-U"!D&%9%0*)P!*A(+0*3+F!
o -0.+%3+'.9!AC!&.,%09<%9+!
o $'G%!*96!$'A%0+C!
o 8'&:+!+.!;*((!+:0.4&:B+0*,%)!'9!*!(+*+%!
o 8'&:+!+.!0%('6%!'9!*!(+*+%!G.0!A4('9%((!.0!.+:%0!;40;.(%(!
o 8'&:+!+.!6.!A4('9%((!'9!*!(+*+%!
o 8'&:+!+.!+*[%P!:.)6P!*96!6'(;.(%!.G!;0.;%0+CP!%'+:%0!0%*)!.0!;%0(.9*)!
• 1_4*)'+C!;0'93';)%#!3'+'a%9(!.G!.+:%0!(+*+%(!<4(+!:*,%!(*<%!0'&:+(!
o 8'&:+(!:%)6!G496*<%9+*)!'9!M.9(+'+4+'.9!.0!'9!6.3+0'9%P!9.+!%94<%0*+%6!'9!-U"!3)*4(%!
!
-U"!D>0+I!"7F!K%(+!
LI @.%(!)%&'()*+'.9!+0%*+!.4+E.GE(+*+%!3'+'a%9(!6'GG%0%9+!/0+!*!0%3.&9'a%6!-U"Y!D?.!;%0!(%!04)%P!A4+!(+0.9&!
;0%(4<;+'.9F!
*I =4A(+*9+'*)!0%*(.9!G.0!6'GG%0%93%!'9!+0%*+<%9+!
AI =4A(+*9+'*)!0%)*+'.9(:';!+.!(+*+%Z(!.AX%3+',%!D'I%IP!*,*')*A')'+C!. G!)% * ( + !0% ( + 0' 3+ ', % !<%*9(F!
'I NH(v.(Piper!DLnehF#!X4(+'G'3 *+ '. 9 ( !G. 0 !)'<'+'9&!A*0!+. !3'+ 'a % 9 (!/%0%!0%X%3+%6!
LI N4+E.GE(+*+%0(!3.4)6!*)(.!A%!%+:'3*)P![9./!).3*)!04)%(P!A%!*,*')*A)%P!6.!;0.!A.9.!
QI "G!C%(P!'(!+:%!)%&'()*+'.9!+*').0%6!+.!*!(4A(+*9 +'*) !X4 ( +'G' 3* +' . 9 Y!
Amanda Bakale 4/29/09 5:17 PM
Comment: ?.+!'9!3.40(%Y!
*I Toomer(v.(Witsell!DLnSeF#!M.4 0 +!( +0 '[ % ( !6 . /9!(+*+4+%!0%_ 4 ' 0'9 & !9 . 9 E0%('6%9+(!+.!;*C!<43:!:'&:%0!
)'3%9(%!G%%!G.0!(:0'< ;!A . *+( I!!!
'I M.<<%03'*)!*3+','+C!'(!/B'9!;40,'%/!.G!-U"I!!!
''I @.'9&!A4('9%((!.9!+%0<(!.G!(4A(+*9+'*)!%_4*)'+C!/'+:!(+*+%!3'+'a%9(I!
AI Baldwin(v.(Montana(Fish(&(Game(DLnpeF#!M.40+!4;:%)6!)'3%9('9&!(3:%<%!+:*+!3:*0&%(!9.90%('6%9+(!
<.0%!G.0!:49+'9&!)'3%9(%!!
'I 1)[!:49+'9&!9%'+:%0!G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+!9.0!'<;.0+*9+!%3.9.<'3!*3+','+C!
''I A4('9%((!+0%*+%6!A%++%0!+:*9!;)%*(40%#!9.+!*!<%*9(!+.!)',%)':..6!
! !
!
@.0<*9+!M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!
-0',')%&%(!U!"<<49'+'%(!M)*4(%!
$*/(!3*9!A%!'9,*)'6*+%6!0%&*06)%((!.G!/:%+:%0!+:%C!
6'(30'<'9*+%!*&*'9(+!.4+E.GE(+*+%0(I!!
!
M.0;.0*+'.9(!*96!*)'%9(!3*9!(4%I!
!
"G!(+*+%!0%&4)*+'.9!6'(30'<'9* +%(P!+:% !*3+'.9 !'(!'9,* )'6!49 )%((!
'+!%'+:%0!
LI W40+:%0(!*9!'<;.0+*9+P!9.9E%3.9.<'3!(+*+%!'9+%0%(+!
*96!+:%0%!*0%!9.!0%*(.9*A)%!9.9E6'(30'<'9*+.0C!
*)+%09*+',%(m!.0!
QI K:%!(+*+%!'(!*!<*0[%+!;*0+'3';*9+I!
!
13.9.<'3!;0.+%3+'.9'(<!&.%(!+.!@MMI!
!
-%0+*'9(!+.!M.9&0%(('.9*)!;./%0I!
!
"G!M.9&0%((!*;;0.,%( !(+*+%!)*/(P!+:%0%!'(!9.!,'.)*+'.9P!*96!'G!
M.9&0%((!:*(!*3+%6P!+:%9!+:%!3.<<%03%!;./%0!'(!9.+!
6.0<*9+I!
!
^*0[%+!;*0+'3';*9+!%23%;+'.9I!
$*/(!<4(+!6'(30'<'9*+%!*&*'9(+!.4+E.GE(+*+%0(I!
!
!
N9)C!O=!3'+'a%9(!3*9!(4%I!
!
"G!(+*+%!0%&4)*+'.9!6%;0',%(!*9 !.4 +E.GE(+*+%0!.G!
'<;.0+*9+!%3.9.<'3!'9+%0%(+(!D%I&IP!)',%)':..6F!.0!
3',')!)'A%0+'%(P!+:%!)*/!'(!'9,*)'6!49)%((!+:%!(+*+%!
:*(!*!(4A(+*9+'*)!X4(+'G'3*+'.9!*9!+:%0%!*0%!9.!)%((!
0%(+0'3+',%!<%*9(I!!K:%0%!'(!9.!<*0[%+!;*0+'3';*9+!
%23%;+'.9I!
!
@'(;*0*+%!+0%*+<%9+!&.%(!+.!-"MI!
!
-%0+*'9(!+.!%_4*)'+C!*<.9&!M'+'a%9(I!!!
!
M.9&0%((!3*99.+!496.!M.40+Z(!(+*+4(!_4.!AC!
*;;0.,'9&!*!-U"!,'.)*+'.9I!!?.!*((4<;+'.9!+:*+!
M.9&0%((!'(!b6.0<*9+Ic!
!
?.!<*0[%+!%23%;+'.9I!
&
/=??*/><;L**D*!@BF<;*!?>=:B*
WWUM!&',%9!'9!%*3:!(+*+%!+.!+:%!;4A)'3!*3+(P!0%3.06(P!*96!X46'3'*)!;0.3%%6'9&(!.G!%,%0C!.+:%0!(+*+%I!!>96!+:%!M.9&0%((!
<*C!AC!&%9%0*)!)*/(!;0%(30'A%!+:%!<*99%0!'9!/:'3:!(43:!*3+(P!0%3.06(P!*96!;0.3%%6'9&(!(:*))!A%!;0.,%6P!*96!+:%!%GG%3+!
+:%0%.GI!!!>0+I!"7P!jLI!
WWUM!8%_4'0%<%9+(!G.0!546'3'*)!6%3'('.9(!
M.40+!<4(+!:*,%!X40'(6'3+'.9P!!
M*(%!<4(+!A%!6%3'6%6!.9!+:%!<%0'+(P!*96!
@%3'('.9!<4(+!A%!G'9*)!/'+:!0%(;%3+!+.!+:%!.0'&'9*+'9&!(+*+%I!
*
*
$BG>@>;<89*8I*-8NB@:*
• 546'3'*0C#!!
o X46'3'*)!0%,'%/ !. , %0!% 2 %3 4 +', %!
o X46'3'*)!0%,'%/ !. , %0!)% & '()* +4 0 %!
• 12%34+',%#!!
o *;;.'9+<%9+!*96!9.9E%9G.03%<%9+!.,%0!X46'3'*0C!
o ,%+.!.,%0!)%&'()*+40%!
• $%&'()*+40%#!!
o '<;%*3:< % 9 +P!*<%96<%9+!, '* !(+* +% !0* +'G'3 * +'. 9 P!X40 '(6 '3+ '. 9 E(+0';;'9&P!3.40+E;*3['9&P!A46&%+'9&!.,%0!
X46'3'*0Cm!!
o '<;%*3:< % 9 +!* 9 6!, % +. !., % 00'6 % !., %0 !%2 % 34 +', %!
V*0!-./%0(!
• M.9&0%((#!6%3)*0%!/*0P!30%*+%!*0<CB9*,CP!3.9+0.)!<')'+'*!
• -0%('6%9+#!3.<<*96%0!'9!3:'%GP!%9G.03%<%9+!.G!+:%!)*/(!
• 546'3'*0C#!+0C!3*( %(!
(@;0*&&C*QSBA=;<OB*G8NB@:*>9F*ALBAd:*
O9)%((!>0+I!"!)*9&4*&%!DbAll!)%&'()*+',%!; . / % 0 ( !: %0 % '9 !& 0 *9 + % 6 d c F!+ : % 0% !'( !9 . !0 % (+ 0'3 +' , %!) *9 & 4 * & % !'9 !> 0 +I!" "!D bK :%!
%2%34+',%!-./%0!(:*))!A%!,%(+%6dFI!!>)+%09*+%!,'%/P!.9)C!>0+I!""!%94<%0*+%6!;./%0(I!!!
V*0!+'<%!
7%+.!*96!QBR!.,%00'6%!DjRP!3)IQF!
-*06.9P!9.+!G.0!'<;%*3:<%9+!.0!(+*+%!30'<'9*)!)*/!DjQP!3)ILF!
K0%*+C!;./%0P!*6,'3%!*96!QBR!3.9(%9+!.G!=%9*+%P!3*9!AC;*((!/B%2%34+',%!*&0%%<%9 +!D9 . +!'9 !M .9 ( +F!D jQ P!3) IQF !
=;%%6!*96!(%30%3C!'<;.0+*9+Y!
`'%0*03:C#!O=!M.9(+P!K0%*+'%(B=+*+4+%(!/'+:!)*(+!'9!+'<%!04)%P!12%34+',%!>&0%%<%9+(P!=+*+%!)*/(!
>;;.'9+<%9+!.G!*<A*((*6.0(P!;4A)'3!<'9'(+%0(P!X4(+'3%(P!.GG'3%0(!.G!O=P!*6,'3%!*96!3.9(%9+!.G!=%9*+%!DjQP!3)IQF!
! M.9&0%((!3*9!*)).3*+%!+:%!*;;.'9+<%9+!.G!'9G%0'.0!.GG'3%0(!*(!+:%C!(%%!;0.;%0!'9#!
! ! K:%!;0%('6%9+!
! ! K:%!3.40+(!.G!)*/!D'I%IP!k%9!=+*00!*;;.'9+%6!AC!+:%!3.40+P!9.+!+:%!;0%('6%9+!'9,%(+'&*+%6F!
! ! K:%!:%*6(!.G!6%;*0+<%9+(!
!
L4=59$64;5&H%,,6&P&W=+,&'(&H";>,#&VW7 _5ZC*(+0'[%!640'9&!V V ""P!(+%%)!9%3%((*0C!+.!/*0!%GG.0+P!6'0%3+%6!(%'a40%!
• ^*X.0'+C#!'<;%0<'(('A)%!(%'a40%I!!K%2+4*)'(+P!+:'(!;./%0!'(!9.+!'9!M.9(+'+4+'.9!
o ?.!'9:%0%9+!;0%('6%9+'*)!;./%0m!<*C!*3+!.9)C!'G!+:%0%!'(!%2;0%((!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)!.0!(+*+4+.0C!*4+:.0'+C!
-0%('6%9+!3*9Z+!<*[%!)*/(P!3*9!.9)C!*3+!,'*!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)!;./%0(!.0!,'*!M.9&0%((!6%)%&*+'.9!
o M.<<*96%0E'9E3:'%G#!(3.;%!6.%(!?NK!'93)46%!(%'a40%!.G!;0',*+%!;0.;%0+C!
o =%%!)*/(!G*'+:G4))C!%2%34+%6#!;0%('6%9+!'(!?NK!*!)*/<*[%0!
• W0*9[G40+%0Z(!3.93400%93%#!=+043+40*)!*96!1+:'3*)[email protected]+0'9*)!
o -0%('6%9+!<*C!%2%03'(%!49%94<%0*+%6!;./%0(!'G!:%!6.%(9Z+!,'.)*+%!*!(+*+4+%!.0!+:%!M.9(+'+4+'.9!
o M.9&0%((!:*(!forbidden!;0%('6%9+' *) !(% 'a 4 0 %( P!+:.4&:!;046 % 9 +'* )!3 . 9 3 % 09 ( !<'&:+!;%0< '+!
K*G+E`*0+)%C!>3+!;0.,'6%(!G.0!(+0'[%!;0.3%640%(!?NK!'93)46'9&!;0%('6%9+'*)!(%'a40%!
o K0*6'+'.9*)!/*C(!.G!&.,%09*93%!3*9!&',%!<%*9'9&!+.!M.9(+'+4+'.9*)!+%2+!
• @.4&)*(Z(!3.93400%93%#!0%X%3+!;046%9+'*)!*;;0.*3:I!!!
o "9:%0%9+!*4+:.0'+C!49 )%((!'+!'9+%0 G%0%(!/ '+: !+:%!G49 3+'.9 '9& !.G!.+: %0!A0* 9 3: %(!
o K%2+!*96!'9+%9+!(:./!6%)'A%0*+%!3:.'3%!.G!W0*<%0(!+.!,%(+!+*['9&(!;./%0!'9!M.9&0%((!
• 5>Mk=N?Z= !MN ?MO881?M 1 #!D5*3[( .9!/ *(!%2 %34 +',%!'9('6%0P!;0'.0!W@ 8!M* A'9%+!< % < A%0F !
o V:%0%!;0%('6%9+!*3+(!/'+:!%2;0%((!.0!'<;)'%6!*4+:.0 '+C !. G!M .9&0%((!
:'(!*4+:.0'+C!'(!*+!:%'&:+!D;0%(4<;+',%) C!, * )'6F!
X46'3'*0C!&',% (!%2 + 0%<%!6%G%0%93%P!'9, * )'6 * +%!. 9 )C !G.0 !3. 9 (+ '+4 +'. 9 * )!; 0'9 3'; ) %!DH . G8 F!
o V:%0%!;0%('6%9+!!*3+(!/'+:!M.9&0%(('.9*)!(')%93%!
4;:%)6!*(!).9&!*(!'+!6.%(!9.+!+*[%!.,%0!+:%!G493+'.9!.G!*9.+:%0!A0*93:!.G!&.,%09<%9+!
D'<;.(('A)%!+.!G.0<4)*+%!&%9%0* )!04 )% (P!6 %; % 9 6 (!. 9!'<;%0*+',%(!.G!%, %9 + (F!
o V:%0%!;0%('6%9+!*3+(!*&*'9(+!+:%!%2;0%((!/'))!.G!M.9&0%((!!
'9,*)'6!49)%( (!+: % !)*/!%9*3+%6!AC!M . 9 &0 %( (!'(!4 9 3 .9 ( +'+4 + '. 9* ) !
X46'3'*0C!&',% (!9 . !6% G%0 %9 3 %P!< * C !A %!; 0% (4 <;+'.9!*&*'9( +!
`%0%P!M*+%&.0C!R#!*((4<'9&!+:*+!K*G+E`*0+)%C!>3+!%2;0%(()C!;0.:'A'+(!(%'a40%!
• 7'9(.9w(!6'((%9+#!'9:%0%9+!;./%0(!+:*+!<*C!9.+!A%!0%(+0'3+%6!AC!M.9&0%((P!.9)C!M.9(+'+4+'.9!0%96%0(!'9,*)'6!
o K*G+E`*0+)%C!>3+!6.%(!9.+!;0.:'A'+!(%'a40%P!*96!+:%0%G.0%!+:%!3*(%!'(!'9!M*+%&.0C!Q!
o =+%/*06(:';!+:%.0C#!%2%34+',%!(4AX%3+!.9)C!+.!+:%!;%.;)%P!,*)'6!49)%((!M.9(+'+4+'.9!%2;)'3'+)C!G.0A'6(!
o M.9&0%((!3.<<'++%6!+.!/*0P!;0%('6%9+!%2%34+'9&P!3.9&0%(('.9*)!(')%93%!.9!K04<*9Z(!*99.493%<%9+!
3*9!0%;0%(%9+!*GG'0<*+'.9P!+:%0%G.0%!+:%!3*(%!could!A%!M*+%&.0C!L!
&
T4#,*"6$=&'(&JH&VW7^^ZC*30'<%!+.!,'.)*+%!<')'+*0C!3.<<*96%0Z(!.06%0I!!N06%0!G.0!5*;*9%(%!6%(3%9+!+.!0%;.0+!+.!
>((%<A)C!M%9+%0(I!!k.0%<*+(4!0%<*'9(!'9!:.<%!6%(;'+%!%23)4('.9!.06%0P!3.9,'3+'.9!4;:%)6I!!D@-P!9.+!1-P!3*(%F!
o W'0(+!1-!3*(%!6%3'6%6!?NK!/0+!A)*3 [ ( !
• ^*X.0'+C#!>))!0%(+0'3+'.9(!.G!3',')!0'&:+(!A*(%6!.9!0*3%!.0!9*+'.9*)!.0'&'9!*0%!G*3'*))C!(4(;%3+P!=+0'3+!=304+'9C#!
o ?*00./)C!+*').0%6!+.!*!3.<;%))'9&!&.,%09<%9+*)!'9+%0%(+I!!`%0%P!9*+'.9*)!(%340'+CI!
Hirabayashi(DLnSQFP!(*<%!(+*+4+%!4;:%)6!/ 0+!340G%/ !;0.,'('.9!AB 3!.G!&.,Z+!'9+%0%(+!'9!
;0%,%9+'9&!%(;'.9*&%!*96!(*A.+*&%!
• W0*9[G40+%0Z(!3.93400%93%#!;046%9+'*)B(+043+40*)!
o >3+'.9!(:.4)6!9.+!A%!(+'&<*+'a%6!*(!)*/)%((!A%3*4(%!'+!'(!640'9&!/*0+'<%!Dinter(arma(silent(legesF!
o @%G%0%93%!+.!<')'+*0C!'9!+'<%(!.G!/*0!D546'3'*0C!:*(!9.!;./%0!.,%0!<')'+*0CP!49)'[%!.+:%0!A0*93:%(P!(.!
'+!/.4)6!(+*9 6 !6. /9F!
• ^40;:CZ(!6'((%9+#!G*')(!496%0!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!
o N,%0E'93)4(',%!D9.!0%)'* A )% !%, '6 %9 3 %!. G!6 '(). C *) +C F!* 9 6!4 9 6 %0E'93)4(',%!D5*; * 9 % (%P!A 4 +!9 . +!] % 0<*9(P!
"+*)'*9(FI!!!
o M)*(('3!=+0'3+!=304+'9C#!3*9Z+!4(%!;0%+%2+I!!8*3'*)!*9'<4(P!9.+!9*+'.9*)!(%340'+C!;0%+%2+P!<.+',*+%(!:%0%I!
• 5*3[(.9Z(!6'((%9 + #!
o -..0)C!+*').0%6!(+*+4+%!G*')(!=+0'3+!=304+'9C!
o 546'3'*)!.;'9'.9 ( !)*( +!).9 & %0 !+: *9 !% 2% 34 +', % !.0 6% 0(I!
&
2>JB>:*!8@G=:C!0%60%((!G.0!49 )* /G4)!6%+%9+'.9P!9.+!%94< %0* +%6 !'9!M.9(+'+4 +'.9P!A4+!'9G%00%6 !G0.< !(4(; %9( '.9!3)*4( %# !
bK:%!;0',')%&%!.G!+:%!/0'+!.G!`M!(:*))!9.+!A%!(4(;%96%6P!49)%((!/:%9!'9!3*(%(!.G!0%A%))'.9!.0!'9,*('.9!;4A)'3!(*G%+C!<*C!
0%_4'0%!'+Ic!!"<;)'3*+'.9#!/B'9!M.9&0%((Z(!;0./%((!.9)CP!('93%!'9!>0+I!"P!jn!D)'(+!.G!0%(+0'3+'.9(!.9!M.9&0%((Z(!;./%0(FI!
&
"@F<9>@K*;@<>?*
H<?<;>@K*;@<J=9>?:*
540C!
^')'+*0C!X46&%(!D9.+!>0+"""!/'+:!+%940%F!
=;%%6C!*96!;4A)'3!
?.9E;4A)'3!
8'&:+!+.!3.9G0.9+!/'+9%((%(!*96!(4A;.%9*!6%G%9(%!/'+9%((%(!
?.!3.<;4)(.0C!;0.3%((!G.0!6%G%9(%!/'+9%((%(!
-0..G!A%C.96!0%*(.9*A)%!6.4A+!G.0!30'<'9*)!3.9,'3+'.9(!
?.!A406%9!.9!;0.(%34+'.9!+.!3*00C!;0..G!
@%+*')%6!;0.3%640*)!;0.+%3+'.9(!+.!%9(40%!*3340*3C!A%G.0%!
6%*+:!;%9*)+C!'(!'<;.(%6!
?.!49*9'<'+C!0%_4'0%<%9+!G.0!6%*+:!;%9*)+C!D+:.4&:!
<')'+*0C!0%&4)*+'.9(!9./!0%_4'0%!+:'(F!
"96'3+<%9+!AC!*!&0*9 6 !X40C!
?.!'96'3+<%9+!AC!&0*96!X40C!
&
XY&D"#6,&!8::89"5&VWXbbZC*;)*99%6!4;0'('9&!640'9&!M',')!V*0P!<')'+*0C!3.93%09%6!+:*+!"96'*9*!3.40+(!/.4)6!*3_4'+I!
• M.40+!.06%0(!0%)%*(%P!<')'+*0C!3*9!.9)C!+0C!'96','64*)(!/:%9!3',')'*9!3.40+(!*0%!3).(%6I!!!
o "96'*9*!'(!9.+!*!+:%*+%0!.G!/ *0P!.+: %0!;. (('A )%!*6<'9'(+0*+'.9!.G!X4(+'3%I!
o $'<'+%6!640*+'.9P!3*9Z+!3.9+'94%!*G+%0!3.40+(!0%'9(+*+%6I!
• M.93400%93%#!<')'+*0C!3.40+(!3*9!+0C!'96','64*)(!/:%9!3',')'*9!3.40+(!*0%!.;%9!496%0!(.<%!3'034<(+*93%(!
o ?.+!'9!+:'(!3*(%#!9.!%2;%6'%93C!3.93%09P!+0'A49*)(!9.+!9%3%((*0C!
XY&D"#6,&Z=8#85*VW7^5ZC*?*a'!(*A.+%40(P!W@8!.06%0(!%2%3!.06%0!G.0!<')'+*0C!+0'*)(P!M.40+!4;:.)6(!6%*+:!(%9+%93%(!
• O;:.)6!4(%!.G!<')'+*0C!+0'A49*)(#!;0%('6%9+!:*(!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)!*4+:.0'+C!+.!+0C!'96','64*)(!!
• @'(+'9&4'(:!Milligan:!!
o -49'(:*A)%!*3+(!*0%!.G!*!6'GG%0%9+!3:*0*3+%0!D.GG%9(%(!*&*'9(+!)*/!.G!/*0P!9.+!+0'*A)%!AC!X40CF!
o @'(+'9&4'(:!)*/G4)B49)*/G4)!3.<A*+*9+(#!49)*/G4)!<*C!A%!+0'%6!AC!+0'A49*)!/:%9!+0'A49*)!'(!30%*+%6!
AC!%2%34+',%!(4AX%3+!+.!M.9&0%(('.9*)!6%)%&*+'.9!
)*/G4)!3.<A *+* 9 +(!(4 A X%3+!+. !3* ;+4 0% !*(!- N V(!
49)*/G4)!3.<A*+*9+(!*0%!(4AX%3+!+.!+0'*)!*96!;49'(:<%9+!AC!<')'+*0C!+0'A49*)(!G.0!49)*/G4)!
*3+(!D:%0%P!49)*/G4)!AB3!+:%C!A40'%6!+:%'0!49'G.0<(P!)*/!.G!/*0!0%_4'0%(!'6%9+'G'3*+'.9!*(!
%9%<CF!
o O=!3'+'a%9(:';!.G!.9%!o!6.%(!9.+!0%)'%,%!:'<!.G!3.9(%_4%93%(!.G!3.<A*+*9+!(+*+4(!
!
F"*?8&'(&M=*$7,:?&V566^ZC*O=!3'+'a%9P!(%'a%6!'9!>G&:*9'(+*9P!<4(+!A%!*33.06%6!@-!*96!<%*9'9&G4)!G*3+4*)!:%*0'9&!
NZM.99.0Z(!-)40*)'+C!.;'9'.9#!%9%<C!3.<A*+*9+(!3*9!A%!6%+*'9%6P!A4+!:*,%!0'&:+!3:*))%9&%!+:%'0!3.<A*+*9+!(+*+4(I!!M*9!
A%!+0'%6!AC!<')'+*0C!+0'A49*)!'G!'+!*33.06(!+:%<!64%!;0.3%((!0'&:+(I!
?.+%#!'<;)'3'+!4(%!.G!YoungstownZ(!3*+%&.0'%(!'9!%,*)4* + '9 & !% 2 %3 4 +' , %!* 3 +'. 9!
LI @.%(!%2%34+',%!:*,%!*4+:.0'+C!+.!6%+*'9!3'+'a%9(!/:.!_4*)'GC!*(!b%9%<C!3.<A*+*9+cY!\1=!D;40(4*9+!+.!*9!*3+!
.G!M.9&0%((P!+:%!>O^WF!
*I @%G'9%!%9%<C!3.<A*+*9+#!b;*0+!.G!.0!(4;;.0+'9&!G.03%(!:.(+')%!+.!O=d%9&*&%6!'9!*0<%6!3.9G)'3+!
*&*'9(+!O=c!
AI M.9&0%(('.9*)!>4+:.0'a*+'.9!G.0!+:%!O(%!.G!^')'+*0C!W.03%!DnBLeBfLF!&*,%!;0%('6%9+!*4+:.0'+C!+.!
6%+*'9!3'+'a%9(I!!DYoungstown!M*+%&.0C!LF!
'I >O^W#!;0%('6%9+!*4+:.0'a%6!+.!4(%!9%3%((*0C!*96!*;;0.;0'*+%!G.03%!*&*'9(+!+:.(%!/:.!
;)*99%6!+%00.0'(+!*++*3[(P!'9!.06%0!+.!;0%,%9+!G4+40%!*3+(!.G!+%00.0'(<!
''I ?.9E@%+%9+'.9!>3+!.G!LnpL#!9.!3'+'a%9!(:*))!A%!'<;0'(.9%6!.0!.+:%0/'(%!6%+*'9%6!AC!+:%!O=!
except(pursuant(to(an(act(of(Congress!
'''I >33I!-)40*)'+CP!+:%!>O^W!'(!(43:!*9!*3+!.G!M.9&0%((P!*(!b9%3%((*0C!*96!*;;0.;0'*+%!G.03%c!
'93)46%(!6%+% 9 +'. 9 !D? U > !'(!* !A 0. * 6!& 0* 9 +P!( '<')*0!0%*(.9'9& !* (!? U - !'9 !McCullochF!
',I -0%('6%9+Z(!;./%0!(+0.9&%0!/:%9!M.9&0%((!(4;;.0+(!DYoungstown(M*+%&.0C!QF!
3I ?.+%#!6%+%9+'.9!3*9!.9)C!)*(+!*(!).9&!*(!+:%!3.9G)'3+!
'I H4+P!*(!9*+40%!.G!3.9G)'3+!3:*9&%(P!6%+%9+'.9!<*C!A%!%2+%96%6P!9.+!+0*6'+'.9*)!/*0!
''I ^*X.0'+C!:%('+*9+!+.!:.)6!%2%34+',%!+.!3.<;)'*93%!/'+:!'9+%09*+'.9*)!)*/!
QI V:*+!;0.3%((!'(!64%!*!3'+'a%9!/:.!3.9+%(+(!:'(!b%9%<C!3.<A*+*9+c!(+*+4(Y!
*I H%3*4(%!:*A%*(!3.0;4(!'(!?NK!(4(;%96%6!AC!M.9&0%((P!o!3*9!3.9+%(+!(+*+4(!A%G.0%!9%4+0*)!+0'A49*)!
AI ].,Z+!*0&4%(#!
'I ?.!X46'3'*)!0%,'%/!.G!'96','64*)!;0.3%((P!.9)C!0%,'%/!b/:%+:%0!)%&*)!*4+:.0'a*+'.9!%2'(+(!G.0!
A0.*6!6%+%9+'.9!(3:%<%!
''I 546'3'*)!6%G%0%9 3% !!
3I Mathews(v.(Eldridge(+%(+#!6%3'6'9&!/:%9!*!6%;0',*+'.9!:*(!.33400% 6!*9 6!@- !'(!0%_4'0%6 #!A*)*93'9 & !
'I -0',*+%!'9+%0%(+!D6%+%9+'.9F!
''I 8'([!.G!%00.9%.4(!6%;0',*+'.9!*96!-0.A*A)%!,*)4%!.G!*66'+'.9*)!;0.3%640*)!(*G%&4*06(!
'''I ].,%09<%9+Z(!'9+%0%(+!D(%340'+CF!
LI D9.!&4'6*93%P!:./%,%0P!.9!:./ !+.!A *)*93 %!+:%!3.<;%+'9&!'9+%0%(+(d6'(30%+'.9!+.!*6!
:.3!/%'&:'9&!)%+(!M.40+!(4AX%3+',%)C!,*)4%!+:%!496%0)C'9&!'9+%0%(+(F!
6I -0.3%((!0%_4'0%6#!!
'I 9.+'3%!.G!*))%&*+'.9(!
''I .;;.0+49'+C!+.!0%A4+!A%G.0%!9%4+0*)!+0'A49*)!D<')'+*0C!+0'A49*)!<'&:+!/.0[F!
'''I 30'<'9*)!;0.3%640%!(+*96*06(!DA4+!%,'6%93%!04)%(!<*C!A%!0%)*2%6F!
',I :*A%*(!0%,'%/!'9!G%6%0*)!3.40+!
%I -)40*)'+C!0%X%3+(!A.+:!&.,Z+!*0&4<%9+(#!0%<*96!G.0!A*)*93'9&!+%(+!G0.<!Mathews(v.(Eldridge!!
'I V*0!'(!9.+!*!A)*9[!3:%3[!+.!;0%('6%9+P!'96','64*)!;0.3%((!*;;)'%(P!*+!<'9'<4<!0%_4'0%(!
9.+'3%P!*!<%*9'9&G4)!G*3+4*)!:%*0'9&P!*96!0%;0%(%9+* + '. 9!AC!3.49(% ) !
LI $./%0!(+*96*06(#!'I%IP!:%*0(*CP!A406%9!.G!;0..G!.9!oY!!8%<*96P!A4+!3*(%!(%++)%6!(.!9.!
.33*('.9!G.0!M.40+!+.!*99.493%!+:%(%!;0.3%640%(!D`*<6'!(400%96%0(!O=!3'+'a%9(:';F!
''I ^')'+*0C!3*99.+!30%*+%P!*6X46'3*+%P!.0!;0.3%((!04)%(!
=.4+%0Z(!3.93400%93%B6'((%9+!
• M.9&0%((!<4(+!%2;0%(()C!*4+:.0'a%I!!?.9E@%+%9+'.9!>3+P!3*9Z+!:.)6!O=!3'+'a%9!*(!%9%<C!3.<A*+*9+!
• >O^W!6.%(9Z+!%2;)'3'+)C!*4+:.0'a%!6%+%9+'.9!.G!%9%<C!3.<A*+*9+!
=3*)'*B=+%,%9(!6'((%9+#!9.!*4+:.0'+C!+.!6%+*'9!49)%((!M.9&0%((!%2;0%(()C!(4(;%96(!:*A%*(!
• M'+'a%9B9.93'+'a%9!6'(+'93+'.9!<*++%0(!
o `*<6'!'(!3'+'a%9P!3.40+(!*0%!.;%9!DMilliganF!
o =4(;%9('.9!3)*4(%#!6%+*'9%6!3'+'a%9!/'))!A%!+0'%6!.0!0%)%*(%6d&.,%09<%9+!3*9!+0C!`*<6'!'9!*9!>0+I!"""!
3.40+P!.0!M.9&0%((!3*9!(4(;%96!:*A%*(I!
K:.<*(!6'((%9+#!@-!6.%(9Z+!0%_4'0%!(%3.96!&4%(('9&!+:%!;0%('6%9+I!!M'+'a%9B9.93'+'a%9!6'(+'93+'.9!<*++%0(!
!
I"?8::"&'(&M=*$7,:?&V566^ZC**00%(+%6!'9!O=!G.0!30'<%!;)*99%6!'9!+:'(!3.49+0C!
• H0'9&!:*A%*(!;%+'+'.9!'9!+:%!;)*3%!/:%0%!6%+*'9%6P!*&*'9(+!+:%!;%0(.9!0%(;.9('A)%!G.0!6%+%9+'.9!DA0.4&:+!'9!
+:%!/0.9&!;)*3%F!
• @'(+!M.40+#!&.,Z+!<4(+!30'<'9*))C!3:*0&%!o!.0!0%)%*(%!:'<dS
+:
!M'0!0%,%0(% 6 I!!] . , Z+!'9!Qffh!'((4% (!'9 6'3+<%9+P!
9.!).9&%0!:%)6!*(!%9%<C!3.<A*+*9+I!
&
M"$=:&'(&N=$%*V566^ZC*9.9E3'+'a%9(!6%+*'9%6!*+!]'+<.!:*,%!:*A%*(!0'&:+P!*33.06'9&!+.!M.9&0%(('.9*)!statute!
• $'<'+%6!+.!/:%+:%0!G%6%0*)!3.40+(!3*9!:%*0!:*A%*(!;%+'+'.9(!.G!]'+<.!6%+*'9%%(!
• K.!G')%!G.0!:*A%*(P!<4(+!A%!3'+'a%9!N8!496%0!+:%!3.40+Z(!X40'(6'3+'.9I!
• @'(+'9&4'(:%(!Johnson(v.(Eisentrager!DLn h f F !D9 . !( +* +4+.0C!0'&:+!+. !: *A%*(!G.0!]%0<*9!3'+'a%9(!3 * ; +4 0 % !A C !O = !
G.03%(!'9!M:'9*P!3. <A*+*9+(!3.+!< ')'+* 0C !+0'A49*)!+0'*)FP!A%3*4(%!]'+<.P!49)'[%!M:'9*P!O=!3.40+(!:*,%!%23)4(',%!
X40'(6'3+'.9P!]'+<.!6%+*'9%%(!6. 9 Z+!& %+ !+0'A 4 9 * )!+0 '*)I!
!
Hamdi(t!Rasul!T!6%+*'9%% ( !3* 9 !3 : * ))% 9 & % !%9 % <C!3.<A* +* 9 +!( +* + 4 (P!3 * 9 !G')% !: * A % * ( !; % +'+ '. 9 ( !/ : % + : % 0!3 '+' a% 9 !. 0 !9 . +P!* 9 6 !
/:%+:%0!'9!+:%!O=!.0!]'+<.I!!@.@!30%*+%(!M.<A*+*9+!=+*+4(!8%,'%/!K0'A49*)(P!+.!6%+%0<'9%!3.<A*+*9+!(+*+4(I!
&
F"*?"5&'(&M=*$7,:?*V566_ZC*].,%09<%9+!(%%[ ( !6 '(<'((*)!D@"]F !A % 3* 4 ( % !. G!'9 +% 0 , % 9 '9 & !@ % +* '9%%!K0%*+< % 9 +!> 3 +#!!
-0.+%3+(!;0'(.9%0(!G0.<!'9:4<*9%!+0%*+<%9+P!A4+!(+0';(!=MNKO=Z(!:*A%*(!X40'(!!
M.9&0%((!3*9!3.9+0.)!*;;%))*+%!X40'(!.G!=MNKO=P!Marbury!
LF 6%(;'+%!@K>P!M.40+!3*9!:%*0!+:%!3*(%!
*I @K>!jLffhD%FDLF!(+0';(!X40'(6'3+'.9!+.!:%*0!:*A%*(!;%+'+'.9(P!*96!jLffhD%FDQFEDRF!;)*3%6!%23)4(',%!
X40'(6'3+'.9!G0.<!0%,'%/!+0'A4 9 *)( !'9 !@M!M'034'+!
AI D%FDQFEDRF!/%0%!*;; )'3*A)%!+.!;% 96'9 &!3*(%( P!A4+!9.+!D%FDL FP!(.!3.40+Z(!X40'(6'3+'.9!? NK !(+0';;%6 !
QF <')'+*0C!3.<<'(('.9(!*0%!9.+!*!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)!%2%03'(%!.G!%2%34+',%!*4+:.0'+C!
*I 49)*/G4))C!6%+*'9%6!A%3*4(%!<')'+*0C!+0'A49*)!'<;0.;%0)C!3.9(+'+4+%6!
Amanda Bakale 4/27/09 11:49 PM
Comment: (%%!;./%0;.'9+!
AI O9',%0(*)!M.6%!.G!^')'+*0C!54(+'3%P!*96!@K>P!>O^WP!6.!9.+!;%0<'+!+:%(%!+0'A49*)(!AB3!+:%C!
*3[9./)%6&%P!A4+!9.+!*4+:.0'a%!+:%<!
3I OM^5!'9+%09*)'a%6!)*/!.G!/*0P!'93)46'9&!]%9%,*!M.9,%9+'.9!D'G!,'.)*+%(P!]%9%,*!M.9,%9+'.9P!+:%9!
,'.)*+%(!OM^5F!
'I 84)%(!.G!3.40+E<*0+'*)!*96!<')'+*0C!+0'A49*)(!<4(+!A%!49'G.0<P!A4+!+0'A49*)(#!
LI ?.96'(3).(40%!.G!3%0+*'9!%,'6%93%!+.!o!*96!*++.09% C !
QI "9*A')'+C!.G!*++.09%C!+.!6'(34( (!%,'6 %93 %!/ '+:!o !
RI 8%)*2%6!04)%(!.G!%,'6%93%!DX4(+!;0.A*+',%F!
SI ?.!>0+I!"""!*;%*)!
6I Youngstown!*9*)C('(#!!
'I Executive(power(9.+!3*+%&.0C!L!'G!+:%!(+*+4+%(!6.%!9.+!*4+:.0'a%!+:%!%2%34+',%!+.!6%+*'9!
LI @'((%9+%0(!*0&4%!+:*+!+:'(!"=!M*+%&. 0 C !L P!A * ( %6!.9!'9+%0;0% +* +' . 9 !. G!O M^5!
''I >33I!=+%,%9(P!+:'(!'(!M*+%&.0C!RP!('93%!M.9&0%((!'96'3*+%(!.+:%0/'(%!
LI -0%('6%9+!<*C!9.+!6'(0%&*06!)'<'+*+'.9(!+:*+!M.9&0%((!:*(P!'9!;0.;%0!%2%03'(%!.G!'+(!
./9!/*0!;./%0(P!;)*3%!.9!:'(!;./%0(I!!-0%('6%9+!3.4)6!:*,%!*3+%6!'G!M.9&0%((!:*6!
A%%9!(')%9+!
%I -0%('6%9+!3*9!0%+409!+.!M.9&0%((!*96!(%%[!+:%!*4+:.0'+C!:%!/*9+(I!
k%99%6C!3.93400%93%#!6.%(!9.+!X.'9!.;'9'.9!/0+!/:%+:%0!b3.9(;'0*3Cc!'(!*!/*0!30'<%!
=3*)'*!6'((%9+#!@K>!(+0';(!:*A%*(!0%,'%/!.G!]'+<.!6%+*'9%%(P!9.93'+'a%9!6'GG%0%93%!T!9.!0'&:+(!496%0!=4(;%9('.9!M)!
K:.<*(!6'((%9+#!9.!:*A%*(!;%0!=3*)'*P!>O^W!*4+:.0'a%(!%2%3!4(%!.G!<')'+*0C!+0'A49*)(!
!
!
!
H*)*93'9&#!3',')!3.40+(P!3.40+E<*0+'*)P!<')'+*0C!+0'A49*)d<')'+*0C!/*9+(!+.![%%;!'96','64*)!*/*C!G0.<!G4))!;*9.;)C!.G!
0'&:+(P!AB3!.G!+%00.0'(<!0'([!
M.40+!<*0+'*)!
^')'+*0C!K0'A49*)!
-0%('6'9&!.GG'3%0!<4(+!A%!<')'+*0C!X46&%!
-0%('6'9&!.GG'3%0!3*9!A%!*!<')'+*0C!)*/C%0!
h!<%<A%0!3.40+!0%_4'0%6!
R!<%<A%0!3.40+!(4GG'3'%9+!
1,'6%9+'*0C!(+*96*06(!A*(%6!.9!W%6%0*)!84)%(!.G!
1,'6%93%!
8%)*2%6!%,'6%9+'*0C!(+*96*06(!D:%*0(*CP!49(/.09!
6%3)*0*+'.9(P!3.%03%6!(+*+%<%9+(!*6<'(('A)%F!
&
!
N4=*,?8,5,&'(&N=$%&V566XZC*H4(+!('&9(!M.9&0%((Z(!^')'+*0C!M.<<'(('.9(!>3+P!*(!;%0!Hamdan!6%3'('.9P!(%%[ '9 & !
M.9&0%(('.9*)!*4+:.0'+C!+.!*3+I!!K:'(!0%+409(!+:%!Youngstown!*9*)C('(!+.!M*+%&. 0 C !L I!!? . /P!9.!X40'(6'3+ '. 9 !G. 0 !: * A % * (!' G!
o!6%+*'9%6!*(!%9%<C!3.<A*+*9+P!*))!;0.,'('.9(!*;;)C!+.!;%96'9&!3*(%(I!
• MN?=K"KOK"N?>$!:*A%*(!3)*'<!D9.+!(+*+4+.0CP!*(!'9!RasulF!
• `*(!M.9&0%((!493.9(+'+4+'.9*))C!(4(;%96%6!:*A%*(Y#!?NK!%2+0%<%!3'034<(+*93%(!D9.+!<*0+'*)!)*/F!
• @.!G.0%'&9!*)'%9(!:*,%!:*A%*(!0'&:+(Y!
o "G!9.P!+:%9!M.9&0%((!:*(9 Z+!493 .9 (+'+4+'. 9* ))C!(4(; %9 6!* !0'&:+!+:* +!6.% (9Z+!%2 '(+I!
o `'(+.0'3*)!<.6*)'+C!(:%6!)'++)%!)'&:+!.9!/:%+:%0!*)'%9(!:*,%!:*A%*(!0'&:+(I!
o =+043+40*)!<.6*)'+C#!(.,%0%'&9+CB3.9+0.)I!!O=!:*(!9.!(.,%0%'&9+C!DM4A*F!A4+!'+!6.%(!3.9+0.)I!
M.40+!*3+(!'9!'9(+'+4+'.9*)!(%)GE'9+%0%(+P!+04<;'9&!;.)'+'3 * )!A 0* 9 3: % (!
• K1=K#!>33I!k%99%6CP!*))!R!G*3+.0(!<%+!
LI 3'+'a%9(:';!*96!(+*+4(!.G!+:%!6%+*'9%%!*96!+:%!*6%_4*3C!.G!+:%!;0.3%((!+:0.4&:!/'+:!+:%!(+*4(!
6%+%0<'9*+'.9!/*(!<*6%!
QI 9*+40%!.G!+:%!('+%(!/:%0%!*;;0%:%9('.9!*96!6%+%9+'.9!+..[!;)*3%!
RI ;0*3+'3*)!.A(+*3)%(!'9:%0%9+!'9!0%(.),'9&!;0'(.9%0Z(!0'&:+!+.!:*A%*(!
• @'((%9+#!+:'(!/*(!*!A*'+!*96!(/'+3:#!Hamdan!'9,'+%6!M.9& 0 % (( !+. !0 % (; . 9 6 P!* 9 6 !M . 40+!+:%9!496 %0< '9% (!!
!
W4+40%#!NA*<*!3).('9&!]'+<.P!:*A%*(!;%+'+'.9(!*))./%6I!!Al[Mari!3*(%!'(!+%(+!G.0!NA* <*!+.!6'(+*93 % !G0. <!H4(:!;.) '3' %( !
/B.!&','9&!4;!9*+'.9*)!(%340'+C!D:./!0.A4(+!(: . 4 )6 !o Z( !0'& : + (!A%!*+!+0'*)d/ ')) !; 0% ( '6 % 9 +' *) !; . /%0!3.9+'94% !+. !( % )GE
*&&0*96'a%YF!
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
/8=@;BB9;L*(EB9FEB9;*
-0%ELS>#!H.G8!9.+!*;;)'3*A)%!+.!(+*+%(I!!Barron(v.(Baltimore:!0%(+0'3+!G%6%0*)!*3+'.9 ( P!9 . +!( +* +% !* 9 6 !). 3 * )I!D+ : % !& . ,Z+ !+: * + !
30%*+%6!+:%!'9(+04<%9+F!
G#,?&H@466&'(&H"574#?&VWX_`ZC*()*,%!(4%(!G.0!G0%%6.<P!'9!G0%%!(+*+%#!M.40+!(*C(!9.P!9.+!3'+'a%9!!
• =+*+%!3'+'a%9(:';!6'6!9.+!&4*0*9+%%!x!O=!3'+'a%9(:';!
• =)*,%(!*0%!9.+!3'+'a%9(P!(.!3*99.+!A0'9&!(4'+!'9!G%6%0*)!3.40+!
• M.9&0%((!<4(+!&',%!3'+'a%9(!G4))!;0.+%3+'.9!.G!H.G8!D;0.;%0+C!T!()*,%(F!
!
W^(3*eWC!D;*((%6!AC!,'3 +. 0 '. 4 ( !? . 0 +: !* G +% 0!M ' ,' )!/*0P!LegeP!'< ; ) '3' +)C !. , % 00 4 )'9&!Dred(ScottF#!b>))!;%0(.9(!A.09!.0!
9*+40*)'a%!'9!+:%!O=P!*96!(4AX%3+!+.!+:%!X40'(6'3+'.9!+:%0%.G!*0%!3'+'a%9(!.G!+:%!O=!*96!.G!+:%!(+*+%!/:%0%'9!+:%C!0%('6%Ic!
W^(3*e5C!b?.!(+*+%!(:*))!< * [ % B% 9 G . 03 % !* 9 C!) */!/:'3:!(:* )) !*A0'6&%!+:%!privilege(or(immunities!.G!3'+'a%9(!.G!+: %!O=m!9.0!
(:*))!*9C!(+*+%!6%;0',%!*9C!;%0(.9!.G!)'G%P!)'A%0+CP!.0!;0.;%0+CP!/'+:.4+!due(process(of(lawm!9.0!6%9C!+.!* 9C!;%0(.9!
/'+:'9!'+(!X40'(6'3+'.9!+:%!equal(protection!.G!+:%!)*/Ic!
• -U"E(4A(+*9+',%!0'&:+(!D-U"!*)(. !0 % G% 0% 9 3 % 6 !'9 !> 0 +I!" 7 P!; 0 . +% 3 +( !G4 9 6 * <%9+*)!0'&:+( P!6 '(; 4+*A)%!3)*'< !+: * +!
W0*<%0Z(!'9+%9+!/*(!+.!*;;)C!+:%!H.G8!+.!+:%!(+*+%(!,'*!LS>F!
• @-E;0.3%640*)!0'&:+(!
• 1-E(4A(+*9+',%!0'&:+(!6'(A40(%6!'9!%,%9!:*96%6!<* 99% 0!
W^(3*e_C*bM.9&0%((!(:*))!:*,%!+:%!;./%0!+.!%9G.03%P!AC!*;;0.;0'*+%!)%&'()*+'.9P!+:%!;0.,'('.9!.G!+:'(!*0+'3)%Ic!!H0%*6+:Y!
8*+'G'3*+'.9!496%0!<')'+*0C!.334;*+'.9!.G!8%3.9(+043+'.9!=.4+:P!M.9&0%((!(:4+!.4+!=.4+:%09!<%<A%0(!+.!&%+!LS>!
;*((%6r;0.3%640*))C!G)*/%6P!A4+!D>3[%0<*9F!<.<%9+!.G!:'&:%0!)*/<*['9&I!
!
!
H6#"=?,#&'(&Q,$6&[8#9858"*VWXX6ZC*>G0'3*9!><%0'3*9!3.9,'3+%6!AC!X40C!G0.<!/:'3:!>>(!*0%!%23)46%6!AC!(+*+4+%I!!!
1-!,'.)*+'.9I!
• 1-!6.%(!9.+!&4*0*9+%%!*!<%<A%0!.G!oZ(!./9!0*3%P!A4+!+:%0%!3*99.+!A%!*!0*3'*)!A*0#!3',')!0'&:+!+.!X40C!.G!;%%0(!
• 8'&:+(!.G!%23)46%6!;.+%9+'*)!X40.0!*96!0'&:+(!.G!o#!;.)'+'3*)!0'&:+P!9.+!'9'+'*))C!%9,'('.9%6!*(!496%0!1-!
o -.+%9+'*)!X40.0(!*96!(+*96'9&!;0.A)%<#!*0%9Z+!+0C'9&!+.!&%+!.9!X40'%(P!9.+!)'[%)C!+.!A0'9& !: '(!. / 9 !
3)*'<(P!*))./!R
06
!;*0+C!DoF!+. !A 0 '9 & !3)* ' <!
>A')'+C!+.!(%0,%!.9!X40'%(!'(!%_4*)!*30.((!*3%(!
o M.9(+'+4+'.9!.G!X40'%(!'(!'<;.0+*9+!;*0+!.G!0'&:+!+.!X40C!+0'*)P!(.!0'&:+(!.G!o!
$'[%)C!+.!A%!+0%*+%6!A%++%0!A*(%6!.9!6%<.&0*;:'3!('<')*0'+C!
• HNK`!+:%!*9+'E(4A.06'9*+'.9!*96!*9+'E3)*(('G'3*+'.9!34+!*&*'9(+!+:'(!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!
o K:%(%!;*+:(!6',%0&%!'9!*GG'0<*+',%!*3+'.9!3*(%(d(%%!A%)./!
• $'<'+(#!%I&IP!/.<%9!o(!6.9Z+!:*,%!0'&:+!+.!9.+!:*,%!G%<*)%(!%23)46%6!G0.<!X40C!
• @'((%9+#!LS>!;0.+%3+(!3',')P!9.+!;.)'+'3*)!.0!(.3'*)!0'&:+(I!
o M',')#!:.)6!;0.;%0+CP!(4%P!3.9+0*3+P!+0*,%)!
o -.)'+'3*)#!,.+%P!:.)6!.GG'3%!
o =.3'*)#!*((.3'*+%P!<*00C!
!
!
?%')!].+*96*#!A(Critique(of(“Our(Constitution(is(Color[Blind”(*96!6'GG%0%9+!3.93%;+'.9(!.G!0*3%!
• =+*+4(#!<*0[%+!.G!(.3'*)!(+*+4(P!%(;I!/:'+%!(4;0%<*3C!
o M.9(%9(4(!+:*+!+:'(!'(!'9,'6'.4(!
• W.0<*)#!A)..6)'9%(B(['9!3.).0!D+:'9!A'.).&'3*)!3.93%;+F!
o >9+'E3)*(('G'3*+'.9P!0%;0%((!3.).0!
• `'(+.0'3*)#!;:%9.<%9.9!30%*+%(!6'GG%0%93%!.9)C!+:0.4&:!3.9+'9&%9+!:'(+.0'3*)!;0*3+'3%!
o >9+'E(4A.06'9*+'.9P!6.9Z+!0%; 0 % ( (!6'GG%0%93%!
• M4)+40%#!3.<<49'+C!*96!3.9(3'.4(9%((P!.A(%0,%!3.99%3+'.9(!*96!(+*+'(+'3(!/B.!*((4<;+'.9(!
o -)40*)'(+P!6',%0('+C!'(!*!A%9%G'+!D*((4<%(!+:*+!6'GG%0%9+!0*3%(!actually!:*,%!6'GG%0%9 +!; % 0 (; % 3 +', % ( F!
!
M.40+!'(!'93.9('(+%9+!'9!:./!'+!3.93%',%(!.G!0*3%!D(*<%!'<;)'3*+'. 9 (!G. 0!& %9 6 % 0!'9 !+0* 9 (& % 9 6% 0% 6 !3* (% (F!
• Ozawa(v.(S(DLnQQF#!>('*9(!3*9Z+!9*+40*)'a%P!X4(+!A%!A.09I!!O;:%)6P!biological!
• US(v.(Thind!DLnQRF#!/: '+% !<%*9(!3*43* ( '* 9 P!* 9 6 !<*9C!A'.).& '(+ (!3 . 9 ( '6 % 0 !=. 4 + : !> ( '* 9 (!M*43*('*9I!!M. 4 0 +!( * C (!
/:*+!'+!0%*))C!<%*9+!'9!Ozawa!/*(!public(knowledge!
$%&*)!+0%*+<%9+!A*(%6!.9!status!'(!3)*(('3!1-#!<%< A % 0 !. G!3 )* (( !* 9 6 !+0 % * +% 6 !6 'GG% 0 % 9 +)C !AB3!.G!(+*+4(I!
8*3'*)!G.0<*+'.9!,%0(4(!0*3'*)!+0%*+<%9+#!6%G'9'9&!0*3%!D'I%IP!'<<'&0*+'.9!)*/F!*96!+0%*+'9&!0*3%!D3',')!0'&:+(F!
! 8*3'*)!+0%*+<%9+!3*(%(#!M.40+!)%+(!(+*+%(!6%G'9%!0*3%!*(!+:%C!/'))!D'I%IP!.9%E60.;!04)%(F!
!
W%,&H:"=9%6,#%4=$,&)"$,$*VWX`YZC*$>!)*/!&0*9+(!<.9.;.)C!+.!=)*4&:+%0:.4(%!3.<;*9C!.,%0!*))!A4+3:%0'9&!'9!?NI!!
LR!*96!LS>!3:*))%9&%I!!$*/!4;:%)6!*&*'9(+!A.+:I!!Narrow(reading(of(Priv.(or(Imm.(Clause.(
• -U"!0%96%0%6!<%*9'9&)%((#!M.40+!G*')%6!+.!3.93%',%!.G!+:%!8%3.9(+043+'.9!><%96<%9+(!*(!(:'G+'9&!+:%!
G%6%0*)'(+!A*)*9 3% !*/*C!G0.<!(+*+%( I!
• LR>!*96!LS>!(.)%)C!+.!;0.+%3+!G.0<%0!()*,%(#!49'+C!.G!;40;.(%!
o LR>#!A4+3:%0Z(!<.9.;.)C!'(!9.+!()*,%0C!
o LS>!@-#!*+!+:'(!;.'9+P!@-!T!9.+'3%!*96!.;;.0+49'+C!+.!A%!:%*06I!!?.!(4A(+*9+',%!@-I!
?.+%#!'G!Slaughterhouse!:*69Z+!:*;;%9 %6 P!+ : % 9 !Lochner!/ . 4 ) 6 !: *, % !A % !6 % 3 '6 % 6 !4 9 6 % 0!- U"I!
o LS>!1-#!:'&:!)%,%)!.G!&%9%0*)'+C!'9!+%2+P!(4(3%;+'A)%!+.!%+:'3*)!<.6*)'+CI!
o LS>!-U"#!?NK!*!,'.)*+'.9P!+:.4&:!6%;0',%(!*!;0',')%&%!+.!;40(4%!*!,.3*+'.9d!
-U"!'(!0.A4(+!496%0!>0+I!"7Z(!%_4*)!+0%*+<%9+!0%_4'0%<%9+I!!!
M.9+0*(+!>0+I!"7!/'+:!LS>!)*9&4*&%I!!-U"!.G!O=!3'+'a%9(!'(!9.+!*(!0.A4(+!*(!+:%!G.0<%0I!
W%6%0*)B(+*+%!6'(+'93+'.9#!&4*0*9+%%!0'&:+(!*&*'9(+!(+*+%!&.,Z+P!3*9!.9)C!A0'9&!>0+I!"7!3)*'<!
*&*'9(+!*9.+:%0!(+*+%I!!?NK!C.40!./9!(+*+%I!
• ?.+%#!*))!.+:%0!0%(+0'3+',%!'9+%0;0%+*+'.9(!.G!LS>!/%0%!(4A(%_4%9+)C!.,%0+409%6P!%23%;+!G.0!-U"!
o @-!)*+%0!'9+%0;0%+%6!+.!;0.+%3+!0'&:+!+.!;0*3+'3%!+0*6%!
o 1-!)*+%0!'9+%0;0%+%6!+.!;0.+%3+!.+:%0(!+:*9!A)*3[(!
o -U"Z(!0%(+0'3+',%!'9+%0;0%+*+'.9!:*(!;0%,%9+%6!+:%!4(%!.G!+:*+!;0.,'('.9!+.!*;;)C!+:%!H.G8!
• W'%)6Z(!6'((%9+#!LS>!<%*9+!+.!%9(40%!+:*+!(+*+%Z(!3'+'a%9(!3.4)6!(4%!G.0!(*<%!-U"!+:*+!9.9E3'+'a%9(!3.4)6!(4%!
G.0!496%0!>0+I!"7 I!!
o ^*X.0'+CZ(!'9+%0;0%+*+'.9!<*[%(!-U"!(40;)4(*&%P!&0*9+'9&!.9)C!0'&:+(!+:*+!*)0%*6C!%2'(+%6#!-U"!94))!
o M400%9+)CP!>0+I!"7!-U"!!'(!'9+%0;0%+%6!*(!+:%!1-!3)*4(%!G493+'.9'9&!*30.((!(+*+%!A.06%0(!
• H0*6)%CZ(!6'((%9+#!A0.*6%0!496%0(+*96'9&!.G!LS>!-U"P!*(!'93.0;.0*+'9&!+:%!H.G8!
o W*))(!+.!@-#!0%;.('+.0C!.G!49%94<%0*+%6!0'&:+(!496%0!(4A(+*9+',%!@-!,%:'3)%!*96!'93.0;.0*+'.9!
o K:'(!%,%9+4*))C!A%3.<%(!+:%!<*X.0'+C!,'%/!.G!=MNKO=!
!
H",5U&'(&M4,*VW777ZC*0%,',*)!.G!LS>!-U" !
• W'0(+!+'<%!-U"!4(%6!+.!'9,*)'6*+%!*!(+*+%!)*/!D)*/!)'<'+%6!/%)G*0%!A%9%G'+(!G.0!9%/!0%('6%9+(!.G!*!(+*+%!+.!+:%!
)%,%)!.G!+:.(%!.G!+:%!(+ *+% !+: %C !< ., %6 !G0. < F!
• =+%,%9(#!0'&:+!+.!+0*,%)!'(!G496*<%9+*)P!9%/!0%('6%9+(!+0%*+%6!+:%!(*<%!AB3!.G!-U"!
o =+*+%!3.93%09!*A.4+!A%'9&!*!<*&9%+!G.0!+:.(%!/:.!/*9+!:'&:%0!A%9%G'+(#!A406%9!+..!(<*))!+.!X4(+'GC!
496%0!(+0'3+!(304+'9C!
• 8%)*+%6!+.!3.<<%03%!*96!6.0<*9+!3.<<%03%!3)*4(%!D3*9Z+!A406%9!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%F!*96!>0+I!"7!-U"!
D3*9Z+!6'(30'<'9*+%!*&*'9(+!.4+E.GE (+* +%0(F!
o W*3')'+*+%(!(+0%9&+:!.G!49'.9P!9*+'.9*)!3'+'a%9(:';!(:.4)69Z+!A%!'<;%6%6!AC!;0.,'3'*)'(<F!
• O93%0+*'9!G4+40%!.G!-U"#!9%/!,%0(4(!).9&!+'<%!0%('6%9+(!.G!*!(+*+%P!A4+P!'9,.),%(!(+*+%Z(!*A')'+C!+.!6%G'9%!/:%9!*!!
;%0(.9!A%3.<%(!*!0%('6%9+!.G!*!(+*+%!G.0!+:%!;40;.(%(!.G!0%3%','9&!*!A%9%G'+!D(43:!*(!'9E(+*+%!+4'+'.9F!
o ^'&:+!A%!4(%6!+.!;0.+%3+!0'&:+(!+:4(!G*0!&4*06%6!496%0!@-!D(43:!*(!;0',*3C!.0!*;;)'3*+'.9!.G!H.G8F!
1)C#!0'&:+!+.!0%).3*+%P!%(3*;%!G0.<!.;;0%((',%!%9,'0.9<%9+!DG40+:%0P!,.+%!/'+:!C.40!G%%+F!
See(also(Shapiro(v.(Thomspson:!3*9Z+!'<;.( %!C %* 0E).9 &!0% ('6 %9 3C !0%_ 4 '0%<%9+(!G.0!(+*+%!A%9% G'+( !
!
!
!
V.0[:.0(%!G493+'.9!.G!@-#!!
• ?.+'3%!*96!.;;.0+49'+C!+.!A%!:%*06!D-0.3%640*)!'9!9*+40%P!+%2+P!*96!'9+%9+F!
• 8%;.('+.0C!.G!49%94<%0*+%6!0'&:+(!,'*!(4A(+*9+',%!@-!
• "93.0;.0*+'.9!.G!H.G8 !*& *'9 (+!+:%!(+* +%(!
o \.(:'9.#!(:.4)69Z+!&',%!+:%!)*(+!Q!+.!@-P!A4+!0*+:%0P!-U"I!!M*9Z+P!AB3!.G!SlaughterhouseI!
o 12I!Gitlow(v.(NY(DLnQhF#!L>!*;;)'%(!+.!(+*+%(!
o 12I!Powell(v.(Alabama!DLnRRF#!6%9'*)!. G !3. 4 9 ( % )!'9 !3 * ; '+* )!3 * ( %!, '. ) * +% 6 !@ - !D = 3. + +( A . 0 . F!
o =%)%3+',%!,%0(4(!+.+*)!'93.0;.0*+'.9!
`'(+.0'3*)#!*0&4<%9+(!.9!A.+:!('6%(!
W%6%0*)'(<#!G%6%0*)!0%(+0'3+'.9(!.9!(+*+%(P!G*'+:!'9!(+*+%(Z!%2+%9('.9!.G!0'&:+(!/B.!H.G8!
• 1I&IP!K:.<*(!*96!6%9C'9&!+:*+!1(+*A)'(:<%9+!M)*4(%!'<;*3+(!(+*+%(#!bM.9&0%((!(:*))!
<*[%!9.!)*/dc!
8.)%!.G!X46'3'*0C#!(%)%3+',%!&',%(!X46&%(!6'(30%+'.9B(4AX%3+',%!3:.'3%!
o M*06.a.#!@-!3)*4(%!'93)46%6!;0'93';)%(!.G!X4(+'3%!0..+%6!'9!+0*6'+'.9!*96!3.9(3'%93%III*96!'<;)'3'+!'9!
+:%!3.93%;+!.G!.06%0%6!)'A%0+CI!!Palko(v.(Ct.!DLnRpF!!
"93.0;.0*+%6!8'&: +(#!!
L>!D%(+*A)'(:<%9+P!%2%03'(%P!(;%%3:P!;0%((P!*((%<A)CP!;%+'+'.9F!
S>!D(%*03:!*96!(%'a40%P!/*00*9+B;0.A*A)%!3*4(%P!%23)4('.9*0C!04)%F!
h>!D6.4A)%!X%.;*06CP!(%)GE'930'<'9*+'.9 P!X4( +!3 .<;%9(*+'.9F !
g>!D(;%%6C!+0'*)P!X40CP!9.+'3%P!3.9G0.9+!*6,%0(%!/'+9%((%(P!3.<;4)(.0C!;0.3%((!+.!G'96!G*,.0*A)%!/'+9%((%(P!
*(('(+*93%!.G!3.49(%)!G.0!;.(('A)%!'<;0'(.9<%9+F!
e>!D%23%((',%!A*')P!304%)!*96!494(4*)!;49'(:<%9+F!
O9'93.0;.0*+%6!8'&:+(#!
! Q>!D4;:%)6!&49!3.9+0.)!)*/(F!
! R>!D9%,%0!6%%<%6!AB3!9%,%0!0%*3:%6!+:%!3.40+F!
! h>!D0'&:+!+.!&0*96!X40C!'9!30'<'9*)!'96'3+<%9+(F!
! p>!DX40C!+0'*)!'9!3',')!3*(%(F!
! e>!D%23%((',%!G'9%(F!
! *
)<E<;>;<89C*!<O<?*.<]L;:*!>:B:*;8*R@8N9*
LR>!jL#!9.!()*,%0C!.0!(%0,'+46%P!%23%;+!3.9,'3+(!3*9!6.!:*06!)*A.0!
LR>!jQ#!M.9&0%((!(:*))!:*,%!;./%0!+.!%9G.03%!+:'(!*0+'3)%!AC!*;;0.;0'*+%!)%&'()*+'.9!
LR>!jQ!19G.03%*A)%!*&*'9(+!;4A)'3!*96!;0',*+%!*3+.0(!G.0!A*6&%(!*96!'93'6%9+(!.G!()*,%0C!D.9)C!*3+'.9!*&*'9(+!
;0',*+%!*3+.0(F!
LS>!jL#!(+*+%!6%9'*)!.G!1-!'(!(%)GE*3+',*+'9&P!6.!9.+!9%%6!M.9&0%(('.9*)!*3+'.9!+.!A0'9&!1-!3)*'<!
LS>!jh#!M.9&0%(('.9*)!*3+'.9!9%%6%6#!M.9&0%((!:*(!;./%0!+.!'96%;%96%9+)C!%9G.03%!.+:%0!;0.,'('.9(P!A4+!9.+!jh!
! LS>!jh!*&*'9(+!;4A)'3!*3+.0(!.9)C!G.0!A*6&%(B'93'6%9+(P!1-P!*96!,'.)*+'.9(!A%C.96!A*6&%(B'93'6%9+(!
!
&
W%,&)8'8:&M89%6$&)"$,$&VWXXYZC*8%_4'0%<%9+!.G!(+*+%!*3+'.9!D;0',*+%!3.9643+!9%%6!9.+!3.<;)CFI!!O9+')!(+*+%!)*/!:*(!
A%%9!;*((%6!+*['9&!*3+'.9!*6,%0(%!+.!+:%!0'&:+(!.G!3'+'a%9(P!+:%9!M.9&0%((!3*9!9.+!;*((!)%&'()*+'.9!496%0!LS>!
• =+0'[%(!6./9!M',')!8'&:+(!>3+!.G!Leph!*(!'9!%23%((!.G!M.9&0%((Z(!;./%0!496%0!LS>!jhI!*
o $%&'()*+'.9!(:.4)6!A%!*6*;+%6!+.!+:%!<'(3:'%G!*96!/0.9&!/:'3:!LS>!/*(!'9+%96%6!+.!;0.,'6%!*&*'9(+#!
(+*+%!*3+'.9!*6,%0(%!+.!+:%!0'&:+(!.G!+:%!3'+'a%9!(%340%6!AC!+:%!*<%96<%9+*
o M.9&0%((!3*99.+!)%&'()*+%!;0.*3+',%)C!/0+!;0',*+%!*3+'.9(*
o M*9!A%!;0.;:C)*3+'3!"W!'+!(%%(!+:%!(+*+%!)%&'()*+'.9!3.<'9&*
• ?.+!'9+%))%3+4*))C!3.:%0%9+P!A4+!M.9&0%((!)*+%0!4(%(!M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!D;)%9*0C!;./%0F!+.!;*((!M8>!LngS*
• M.9+0*3+(!M)*4(%!D>0+I!"!jLfFP!/:*+!(+*+%(!*0%!;0.:'A'+%6!G0.<!6.'9&m!.93%!(+*+%!*3+(!+.!,'.)*+%!k!3)*4(%P!+:%9!
M.9&0%((!3*9!)%&'()*+%I!!DHOK!+:'(!(4&&%(+(!+:*+!jh!'(!(40;)4(*&%dF*
• ?.!;./%0!496%0!LR>!jQP!0%G4(*)!+.!(%0,%!'(!9.+!*!A*6&%!.G!()*,%0CP!X4(+!3',')!'9X40C*
• =+*+%!>3+'[email protected]+0'9%#!3.93%;+4*)!6'(*(+%0!*0%*#!<40[C!)'9%!A%+/%%9!(+*+%!*96!;0',*+%!*3+'.9*
o >33I!^*X.0'+CP!.9)C!3.<;*9C!+./9(!DMarsh(v.(Alabama!LnSgF!.0 !04 9 9 ' 9 & !%) %3 +' . 9 (!3 * 9 !; 0 ', *+ % !* 3+ . 0!
A%!6%%<%6!*!(+*+%!*3+.0*
o =+*+%!'9*3+'.9#!DeShaney(DLnenFP!G*')40%!.G!(+*+%!+.!'9+%0,%9%!'9!3:')6!*A4(%P!9.!1-!3)*'<!*&*'9(+!@% ;+!
.G!=.3'*)!=%0,'3%!G.0!failure!+.!*3+*
?.!*GG'0<*+',%!0'&:+!+.!<%6'3*)!3*0%P!.9)C!/:%9!'9!(+*+%!3.9+0.)B34(+.6C!AB3!.G!(+*+%!*3+'.9*
• `*0)*9Z(!6'((%9+#!;4A)'3!*33.<<.6*+'.9(!*0%!;4A)'3P!%,%9!+:.4&:!049!AC!;0',*+%!%9+'+'%(*
o W493+'.9*)'(+P!9.+!G.0<*)'(+#!A406%9(!*96!6'(*A')'+'%(!/:'3:!3.9(+'+4+%!A*6&%(!.G!()*,%0C*
*
$;>;B*>A;<89C*
W%/!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)!04)%(!*;;)C!+.!;0',*+%!*3+.0(!D%I&IP!LR>F!
123%;+'.9(#!
• -4A)'3!G493+'.9(#!;0',*+%!3.9643+!+:*+!'(!+0*6'+'.9*))C!%23)4(',%!&.,Z+!6.<*'9!DMarsh(v.(AlabamaF!
• 19+*9&)%<%9+#!'G!&.,Z+!*GG'0<*+',%)C!*4+:.0'a%(B%93.40*&%(BG*3')'+*+%(!493.9(+'+4+'.9*)!3.9643+!DShelley(v.(
Kramer!DLnSeF#!3.40 +!% 9 G. 0 3% <%9+!3*9Z+!(4 ; ; . 0+ !; 0 ', *+ % !* &0 % % <%9+(!+.!6'(30 '<'9*+%P!Bell(v.(Maryland!DLngSF#!
(+*+%!4('9&!;.)'3%!+.!%9G.03%!(%&0%&*+'.9!.G!0%(+*40*9+(!/*(!(+*+%!*3+'.9F!
• =+*+4+.0C#!(+*+%!*96!G%6%0*)!(+*+4+%(!3*9!0%_4'0%!;0',*+%!3.9643+!+.!<%%+!:'&:%0!(+*96*06(!
>0&4<%9+(!G.0!(+*+%!*3+'.9!6.3+0'9%#!
• K%2+4*)#!b9.0!(:*))!*9C!(+*+%dc!LS>!
• `'(+.0'3*)#!3.<<.9!)*/!*96!9*+40*)!)*/P!;%0(.9*)!)'A%0+'%(!
• -.)'3C#!;0',*+%!*4+.9.<CP!*96!a.9%(!.G!(+*+%!(.,%0%'&9+C!
&
&
I:,$$>&'(&R,#9=$45*VWX7bZC*$>!)*/!(%;*0*+'9&!88!3*0(P!LBe
+:
!A)*3[!'(!0%<.,%6P!3:*))% 9 & % 6 !. 9 !1 - !& 0 . 4 9 6 (!
• M.))4(',%!(4'+P!+%(+!3*(%!/'+:!x!/:.!)..[%6!/:'+%I!
• M)*'<#!<'(3)*(('G'3*+'.9!+*[%(!*/*C!b(+*+4(c!;0.;%0+C!.G!A%'9&!/:'+%I!
o M.40+#!x!'(9Z+!/:'+%P!(.!9.+:'9&!+*[%9!*/*C!
o =.3'*)!0'&:+(!%23)46%6!G0.<!LS>!;0.+%3+'.9P!(+*+%(!3*9!0%&4)*+%!0%*(.9*A)C!!
• `*0)*9Z(!6'((%9+!D0%G)%3+%6!'9!BrownF!
o =%;*0*+'.9!'(!(+'&<*+'a'9&P!A*(%6!.9!/:'+%!(4;0%<*3CI!!M',')P!9.+!(.3'*)P!0'&:+I!
o bM.9(+'+4+'.9!'(!3.).0!A)'96c!*96!6.%(!9.+!+.)%0*+%!3*(+%!(C(+%<(!
M:'9%(%!3*9!('+!/B/:'+%(!*96!+:%C!3*9Z+!%,%9!A%!3'+'a%9(!DA4+P!'9!+:*+!3*(%P!+:%C!*0%!9.+!*!
+:0%*+!+:%!/*C!+:*+!A)*3[(!*0%F!
o H.+:!*9+'E(4A.06'9*+'.9!*96!*9+'E3)*(('G'3*+'.9!
!
QU=>?*-@8;BA;<89*
1-!*9*)C('(!
LI /:*+!'(!+:%!3)*(('G'3*+'.9!
*I G*3'*))C!6'(30'<'9 * +. 0C!
AI G*3'*))C!9%4+0 *)!A 4 +!6 '(30 '< '9 * +. 0C !'< ; * 3+!D<4(+!:*,%!6'(30'< '9 * +. 0C !'< ; * 3+!> ? @ !purposeF!
QI /:*+!'(!+:%!*;;0.;0'*+%!)%,%)!.G!(304+'9C#!6%;%96(!.9!3)*(('G'3*+'.9!D3.9('6%0!'<<4+*A)%!3:*0*3+%0'(+'3(P!6'6!9.+!
3:..(%P!3*9Z+!3:*9&%P!*A')'+C!.G!&0.4;!+.!;0.+%3+!'+(%)G!;.)'+'3*))CP!:'(+.0C!.G!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!
*I =+0'3+#!0*3%P!9*+'.9*)!.0'&'9!!
'I 9%3%((*0C!+.!*3:'%,%!3.<;%))'9&!;40;.(%P!&.,Z+!:*(!A406%9!.G!;0..GP!*)<.(+!*)/*C(!G*+*)! !
AI "9+%0<%6'*+%#!&%9 6% 0P!9.9 < *0 '+*)!3:')60 %9 !
'I =4A(+*9+'*))C!0%)*+%6!+.!'<;.0+*9+!&.,Z+!;40;.(%P!&.,Z+!:*(!A406%9!.G!;0..G!
3I 8*+'.9*)!H*('(#!0*+'.9*))C!0%)*+%6!+.!)%&'+!&.,Z+!;40;.(%P!3:*))%9&%0!:*(!A406%9!.G!;0..G!
RI 6.%(!+:%!&.,%09<%9+!*3+'.9!<%%+!+:%!)%,%)!.G!(304+'9C!
*I <%*9(!*96!%96(!0%)*+'.9(:';!D'(!)*/!496%0B.,%0'93)4(',%YIII9.+!9%3%((*0')C!G*+*)P!A4+!3.9('6%0%6P!%(;!'9!
:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9CF!
*
*
$BG>@>;B*R=;*QU=>?*M<:B:;>J?<:LBF* *
=.3'*)!G*3+.0(#!A)*3[!(.)6'%0(!'9!VV""P!0*3%E:*+%!.G!?*a'(!%2;.('9&!:C;.30'(C!'9!+0%*+<%9+!.G!A)*3[(!
^*0(:*))!*96!`.4(+.9Z(!?>>M-!$'+'&*+'.9!(+0*+%&C#!=%;*0*+%!A4+!%_4*)!/'))!3.))*;(%!496%0!'+(!./9!/%'&:+!'G!C.4!
81>$$\!<*[%!+:%<!:*,%!Q!.G!%,%0C+:'9&!A%!+04)C!%_4*)I!!=+*0+!/'+:!&0*64*+%!(3:..)(!+:*+!*0%!:*06%0!+.!64;)'3*+%!*96!
<.,%!6./9I!!D$%((!0%('(+*93%!+.!&0*6!(3:..)(!*(!.;;.(%6!+.!;0'<*0C!(3:..)(P!G%*0!.G!<'(3%&%9*+'.9FI!
!8$$4=#8&,Y&#,:(&A"85,$&'(&)"5"?"*VW7YXZC*(%;* 0*+%!A4+!%_4 *)!9.+!(*+'(G'%6!AC!3)*'<(!+:*+!)*/!(+46%9+(!3*9!&.!
+.!)*/!(3:..)!'9!*9.+:%0!(+*+%!
H;,"66&'(&I"856,#*VW7_6ZC*=%;*0*+%!A4+!%_4*)!9.+!(*+'(G'%6!AC!:*(+')C!3.9(+043+%6!)*/!(3:..)!G.0!A)*3[(!
!@C"=#85&'(&B<:"%4*"*VW7_6ZC*=%;*0*+%!A4+!%_4*)!9.+!(*+'(G'%6!AC!(%;*0*+%!(%3+'.9(!G.0!>G0'3*9!><%0'3*9(!
'9!3)*((0..<(P!)'A0*0'%(P!*96!3*G%+%0'*(!D:'96%0%6!*A')'+C!+.!)%*09P!%23:*9&%!,'%/(P!U3F!
*
N#4;5&'(&N4"#?&47&X?=@"6845*VW7_^ZC*49*9'<.4(!6%3'('.9!496%0<'9%(!(%;*0*+%!A4+!%_4*)I!!V*00%9!M.40+!%0*P!
X46'3'*)!)'A%0*)!* 3+ ', '(<!DV*00%9!0%; )* 3% 6 !7'9 ( .9 !. 9 !3. 4 0+ P!7!/.4)6!)'[%)C!:*,%!6'((%9+%6P!9./!'+Z(!49*9'<.4(F!
54(+'3%(!*([!)'+'&*9 + (!+. !*6 6 0%( (!R !'((4 % (#!
• W0*<%0Z(!6'0%3+!'9+%9+!
o ?>>M-B^*0(:*))!U!8.A'9(.9#!W%*0(!.G!'9+%&0*+'.9!%2;0%((%6!'9!G)..0!6%A*+%(P!A4+!9.+!_4*(:%6!
o @*,'(#!Qn
+:
!M.9&0%((!; 0 . ; . ( % (!L S > !>?@!,.+%(!. 4 +!G 496'9&!+.!A)*3[!(3:..)(!
• W0*<%0Z(!b(;0'9&'9&c!'9+%9+!
o ?>>M-B^*0(:*))!U!8.A'9(.9#!LS>!G0*<%6!'9!A0.*6!+%0<(P!Strauder(v.(WVa!
o @*,'(#!8%;%*+%6)C!'9!M.40+(P!W0*<%0Z(!'9+%9+!:*(!9.+!A%!'9+%0;0%+%6!+.!;%0<'+!6%(%&0%&*+'.9!
• 546'3'*)!;./% 0!'9 6 %; % 96 % 9 +!.G!W 0* <%0Z(!'9+%9+!
o ?>>M-B^*0(:*))!U!8.A'9(.9#!546'3'*0C!:*(!*)0%*6C!0%_4'0%6!de(facto(6%(%&0%&*+'.9!'9!+:%!
0'&.0.4(!%_4*)'a*+'.9!3*(%(!
o >0&4<%9+!G.0!8%;.(%I!
• N;'9'.9!'(!49*9'<.4(P!9.9E*334(*+.0CP!0%*6*A)%P!9.9E0:%+.0'3*)P!49%<.+'.9*)I!!!
o 5*3[(.9#!'9!:.( ; '+*)P!V*00%9!&%+(!:'< !+. !( '& 9 I!!8 % % 6 #!= . 4 +: % 0 9 % 0P!: ' (!6 '( ( % 9 +!/.4)6!:*,%!& ', % 9 !
=.4+:!0%*(.9!9.+!+.!3.<;)CP!/:'3:!/.4)6!A%!A*6!G.0!9*+'.9P!(.!:%!('&9(I!!!
o "9(+'+4+'.9*)!6%3'('.9!D)'[%!/ :% 9!^ * 0(:* ))!3.4 0+!6%, '*+%6 !G0.< !(%0'* +4<FI!
• =+043+40%!.G!*0&4<%9+!
o @'(<'((%(!:'(+.0'3*)!%,'6%93%!*(!'93.93)4(',%!
o @%(30';+'.9!.G!3*(%(!+:*+!3:';;%6!*/*C!*+!=%;!A4+!1_4*)!
o "<;.0+*9+!.G!%643* +'.9 !
o M.9+%<;.0*0C!(.3'.).&'3*)!%,'6%93%!D6.))!(+46CF!
o =%;*0*+%!G*3')'+'%(!*0%!'9:%0%9+)C!49%_4*)!
o @%G%00*)!.G!(+*+%<%9+!.G!0%<%6C#!)%+!;%.;)%!)',%!496%0!'6%*)(!A%G.0%!G.03%6!+.!)', % !4 ; !+. !+ : % <!D*))!
6%)'A%0*+%!(;%%6F!W)%2'A)%!%9G.03%<%9+P!9.+!6'0%3+!3.%03',%!%GG%3+(!D'6%*)'(+'3F!
H4+P!`.))./!`.;%I!
• i4%(+'.9(#!'(!(%;*0*+%!0%*))C!49%_4*)Y!!1-!0%_4'0%(!('<')*0)C!('+4*+%6!A%!+0%*+%6!+:%!(*<%d.,%0(+%;Y!
o =:.4)6!3.40+!:*,%!0%)'%6!.9!;(C3:.).&'3*)!(+4 6 '% ( !+. !( +0 '[ % !6 . /9!=A4+1Y!!V:*+!'G!(3'%9+ 'G'3 !
3.93)4('.9(!3:*9&%Y!
• N0'&'9*)'(<#!
o N0'&'9*)!'9+%9+#!<%*9'9&!*(30'A%6!AC!W0*<%0(!
o N0'&'9*)!496%0(+*96'9&#!*(!496%0(+..6!AC!0*+'G'%0(P!.0!;)*'9!<%*9'9&!
o N0'&'9*)!*;;)'3*+'.9#!<%*9'9&!'(!+:*+!*++0'A4+%6!AC!W0*<%0(!*96!0*+'G'%0(!640'9&!+:%!;%0'.6!.G!
%9*3+<%9+!
• H0./9!(['0+(!_4%(+'.9!.G!.0'&'9*)'(<!
o "93.93)4(',%!D9.!3.9 (%9 (4 (F!
o "9*;;.('+%!D'9!)'&:+!.G!3:*9 &%6 !3'034 < (+* 93 %(F!
o "9_4'0C!<4(+!A%!G.0!'9+%9 +!.G!'< < %6 '*+%!> ? @!).9 & E +% 0< !%GG%3+(!
H'3[%)#!M8>!.G!Legg!<.,%6!*/*C!G0.<!3',')!0'&:+(!+.!@-!G.0<4)*+'.9!
N4::859&'(&H%"#D,*VW7_^ZC*Brown’s!3.49+%0; *0 +!G . 0!@M!D*0&4%6!(%;*0*+%)C!AB3!'+!*660%((%6!+:%!G%6%0*)!9.+!(+*+%!&.,Z+F!
• M.9(+'+4+'.9!;0.:'A'+(!(+*+%!G0.<!<*'9+*'9'9&!0*3'*))C!(%&0%&*+%6!;4A)'3!(3:..)(P!(.!(*<%!M.9(+'+4+'. 9 !3 * 9 Z+!
;%0<'+!W%6(!+.!6.!'+I!
• 1-!*;;)'%(!+.!G%6%0*)!&.,%09<%9+!+:0.4&:!h>!D6'(30'<'9*+'.9!<*C!A%!(.!49X4(+'G'*A)%!*(!+.!,'.)*+%!@-F!
>G+%0<*+:!.G!Brown:!(%0'%(!.G!;%0!340'* <!6%3'('.9(!% 2 +% 9 6 ( !'+!; * ( +!% 6 4 3 * +'. 9 * )!3 . 9 + %2 + !+. !. + : % 0!; 4 A)'3!(%0,'3%(I!
!
K:%!=.4+:%09!^*9'G%(+.#!Brown!,'.)*+%(!M.9(+'+4+' . 9 *) !; 0' 9 3'; ) % (!. G!X 4 6 '3 '* )!0% , '% /#!0%(+0*'9+P!*6 : % 0 %9 3 % !+. !) . 9 &E
%2'(+'9&!;0%3%6%9+P!G'6%)'+C!+.!.0'&'9*)!496%0(+*96'9&P!0%(;%3+!G.0!G%6%0*)'(<!
!
!
"93.0;.0*+'.9B0%, %0( %!'93. 0; .0* +'.9!
H.G8!!h>!@-!!)'<'+!G%6!&.,Z+!
LS>!!LS>!@ - !!)'<'+!(+*+ %!& . , Z+ !
LS>!!h>!@- !!!Y!'93.0;. 0 * +% !H.G8!*&*'9(+!( + *+ % (!
*
$;@<A;*$A@=;<9K*
M)*(('G'3*+'.9(!8%3%','9&!^.0%!+:*9!b8*+'.9*)!A*('(c!O96%0!M400%9+![email protected]+0'9%#!
=+0'3+!=304+'9C#!9*00./)C!+*').0%6!+.!*!3.<;%))'9&!
&.,%09<%9+*)!'9+%0%(+!
8*3%!DO=!,I!k.0%<*+(4P!LnSSF!
?*+'.9*)!N0'&'9!DNC*<*!,I!M>P!LnSeF!
>)'%9*&%!D]0*:*<!,I!8'3:*06(.9P!LnpLPF!!;.)'+'3*)!G493+'.9!
%23%;+'.9!
"9+%0<%6'*+%!=304+'9 C#!(4A (+* 9+'* ))C!0%)*+%6 !+.!*9 !
'<;.0+*9+!& . , %09 <%9+*)!'9+%0%(+ !
=%2!DM0*'&!,I!H.0%9P!LnpgF!
?.9E<*0'+*)!;*0%9+*&%!DK0 '<A)%!,I!].06.9 P!Ln pp F !
8*+'.9*)!H*('(!/'+:!H'+%#!0*+'.9*))C!0%)*+%6!+.!*!
)%&'+'<*+%!&.,%09 <%9+*)!'9+%0%(+!D9.+!'9 30% 6'A )C!
6%G%0%9+'*)P!cf!.;+.<%+0'(+!3*(%F!
@'(*A')'+C!DM)%A409%!,I!M)%A4096!$','9&!M%9+%0P!LnehF!
=%24*)!N0'%9+*+'.9!D8.<%0!,I!1,*9(P!LnngF!
8*+'.9*)!H*('(#!0*+'.9*))C!0%)*+%6!+.!*!)%&'+'<*+%!
&.,%09<%9+*)!'9+%0%(+!
1,%0C+:'9&!1)(%!
>&%!D^*((*3:4(%++(!H.*06!.G!8%+'0%<%9+!,I!^40&'*P!LnpgF!
N;+'3'*9(!DV'))'*<(.9!,I!$%%!N;+'3*)P!LnhhF!
*
>)+%09*+%!3.93%;+'.9(#!M.40+!%2%03'(%(!G)%2'A')'+C!D'I%IP!4964%!A406%9!(+*96*06!'9!CaseyF!
?.0<*+',%!*0&4<%9+!'9!G*,.0!.G!*!()'6'9&!(3*)%P!0*+:%0!+:*9!)%,%)(!D^*0(:*))!*96!=+%,%9(P!Craig(v.(BorenF#!3.9('6%0!
3.9(+'+4+'.9*)!*96!(.3'*)!'<;.0+*93%!.G!'9+%0%(+(!*GG%3+%6!*96!+:%!'9,'6'.4(9%((!.G!+:%!A*('(!.9!/:'3:!+:%!3)*(('G'3*+'.9!
'(!60*/9d<.0%!3*96'6!6'( 34 ( ('. 9 !.G!+ :% !3. <;%+'9&!'9+%0%( +(I!
8%*)'+C!'(!*!0*9&%!.G!(+*96*06(!*9C/*C!D(%%!4964%!A406%9P!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!/'+:!A'+%F!
!
^%*9(B196(!>9*)C('(!O96%0!@'GG%0%9+!K'%0(!.G!=304+'9C#!
!
^%*9(!
196(!
=+0'3+!
?*00./)C!K*').0%6!
M.<;%))'9&!].,+!"9+%0%(+!
"9+%0<%6'*+%!
=4A(+*9+'*))C!8%)*+%6!
"<;.0+*9+!].,+!"9+% 0%(+ !
8*+'.9*)!A*('(!
8*+'.9*))C!8%)*+%6!
$%&'+'<*+%!].,+!"9+%0%(+!
!
1_4*)'+CB$'A%0+C!<*+0'2#!
!
8'&:+(EA*(%6!(+0'3+!(304+'9C!
D)'A%0+CF!
8'&:+(EA*(%6!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!0%,'%/!
D)'A%0+CF!
M)*(('G'3*+'.9sA*(%6!(+0'3+!
(304+'9C!D%_4*)'+CF!
$*/!A*00'9&!<*00'*&%!.9!A*('(!.G!
0*3%!
$*/!A*00'9&!/%)G*0%!%9+'+)%<%9+!.9!A*('(!
.G!0*3%!
M)*(('G'3*+'.9EA*(%6!0*+'.9*)E
A*('(!0%,'%/!D%_4*)'+CF!
$*/!A*00'9&!<*00'*&%!.9!+:%!A*('(!
.G!*&%!
$*/!A*00'9&!/%)G*0%!%9+'+)%<%9+!.9!+:%!
A*('(!.G!*&%!
&
1((%9+'*))C!*!;%0(se(04)%!.G!'9,*)'6'+C#!6.9Z+!/*9+!)./%0!3.40+(!+.!*;; )C!=+0'3+!=304+'9C!+.!0*3%!*9 6!G'96!(+*+4+%(!,*)'6I!
@.!?NK!)%+!&.,Z+!4(%!0*3%!*(!*!;0.2C!D%((%9+'*))C!A%3*4(%!.G!;.+%9+'*)!'9!('+4*+'.9(!)'[%!KorematsuF!
&
K"8*&'(&K"8*3*;0'.0!+.!LovingP!M.40+!:.)6(!+:*+!'9+%&0'+C!.G!0* 3 % ( !'( !(4GG'3'%9+!X4(+' G'3 * + '. 9 !+ . !4;:.)6!7> Z(!
*9+'<'(3%&%9*+'.9!(+*+4+%!D%_4*)!*;;)'3*+'.9F!
>G+%0!NaimP!;.)'+'3*)!3)'<*+%!(: ' G+( P!<.0%!(4;; . 0 +!G.0!3',')!0'&:+( !<.,%<%9+ P!M ',')!8'&:+(!>3 + !.G!LngSI!!!
!@C"=9%:85&'(&R:4#8?"*VW7b^ZC*(+043[!6./9!)*/!;49'(:'9& !'9+%00*3'*)!3.:*A'+*+'.9!< .0%!(%,%0%)C!+:*9 !.+:%0!
3.:*A'+*+'.9P!1-!0%_4'0%(!M.40+!+.!*9*)Ca%!3)*(('G'3*+'.9(!60*/9!G.0!*0A'+0*0C!.0!'9,'6'.4(!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!DA%C.96!
(40G*3%!.G!)*/F!
!
C4'859&'(&[8#9858"*VW7b`ZC*'9+%00*3'* )!3. 4 ; )% !< * 0 0'%( !'9 !@ MP!0% +4 0 9( !+. !7 > P!/ : %0 %!<*00'*&%!9.+!%9 G. 03 %6!
• =+*+4+%#!/:'+%(!3*9Z+!<*00C!<%<A%0!.G!*9.+:%0!0*3%!D%23%;+!?*+',%!><%0'3*9(FP!6.%(!9.+!;0%,%9+!.+:%0!
0*3%(!G0.<!<*00C'9&!%*3:!.+:%0I!
• 8*+'.9*)!A*('(!'9(4GG'3'%9+#!(+0'3+!(304+'9C!0%_4'0%(!+:*+!(+*+4+%!A%!9*00./)C!+*').0%6!+.!3.<;%))'9&!
'9+%0%(+!
• ^*00'*&%!'(!*!fundamental(right!496%0!@-!3)*4(%!
• -'%03%!+:%!,%')!+.!(:./!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!;40;.(%!
o 1_4*)!*;;)'3*+'.9!*0&4<%9+!0%X%3+%6!AB3!'+!6.%(!9.+!+0%*+!/:'+%(B9.9/:'+%(!+:%!(*<%#!%_4*)!
*;;)'3*+'.9!6.%(!9.+!&4*0*9+%%!%_4*)!;0.+%3+'.9!
M.40+!6%G'9%(!+:%!*3+!*(!<*00C'9&!*!/:'+%!;%0(.9P!*96!/:'+%(BA)*3[(!+0%*+%6!6'GG%0%9+)C!
=<*3[(!.G!/:'+%!(4;0%<*3CP!493.9(+'+4+'.9*)!
?.!.,%00'6'9&!;40;.(%!'96%;%96%9+!.G!'9,'6'.4(!0*3'*)!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!
o 1_4*)!*;;)'3*+'.9!'(!?NK!%9.4&:!+.!%2%<;+!*!(+*+4+%!G0.<!LS>!(304+'9C!
• Carolene(Products!G9SP!;*0*!R#!b9.0!9 % % 6 !/%!%9_4'0%d /:%+:%0!;0% X4 6 ' 3% !* & * '9 (+ !6 '( 30 % +% !* 9 6 !'9 ( 4 )* 0 !
<'9.0'+'%(!<*C!A%!*!(;%3'*)!3.96'+'.9d/:'3:!<*C!3*))!G.0!*!3.00%(;.96'9&)C!<.0%!(%*03:'9&!X46'3'* )!
'9_4'0Cc!
!
W0.<!Loving!49+')!Grutter!'9!QffRP!(+0'3+ !'9 !+: % . 0 C !'(!G *+ * )!'9 !G* 3 +I!
&
I":*4#,&'(&H8?468*VW7X^ZC*34(+.6C!*/*06% 6!+.!/:'+%!G*+:%0!/:%9!/ :'+%!<.+:%0!< *00'%6!A)*3[!<*)%!
• H%(+!'9+%0%(+(!.G!3:')6!<*C!'93.0;.0*+%6!(.3'*)!;0%X46'3%!*&*'9(+!'9+%00*3'*)!G*<')'%(!
• =.3'*)!;0%X46'3%!3*9!?NK!A%!*!3.<;%))'9&!&.,Z+!'9+%0%(+!
O4%5$45&'(&)":874#5 8"*V 5 66_ZC*(+0'3+!(304+'9C!*;;)'%(!+.!0*3%EA*(%6!3%))!*(('&9<%9+!;0.&0*<!
• M.40+!'(!3.<;%+%9+P!9%%6%6!6%G%0!+.!;0'(.9!;.)'3Cd<.0%!+:*9!X4(+!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!
• 1-!*&*'9(+!0*3'*)!3)*(('G'3*+'.9!'(!9.+!'93'6%9+*)!+.!'93*03%0*+'.9!
o ?.+!9*00./)C!+*').0%6P!3.93%',*A)%!+:*+!;.)'3C!/'))!*3+4*))C!G40+:%0!,'.)%93%#!0%<*96%6!.9!+:'(!'((4%!
• M.93400%93%#!*9+'E(4A.06'9*+'.9!;0'93';)%!(:.4)6!&.,%09!+.!;%0<'+!A%9'&9!0*3'*)!3)*(('G'3*+'.9(P!A4+!+:'(!. 9 %!
'(!?NK!A%9'& 9 !
• @'((%9+P!=+%,%9(#!(:.4)6!A%!<.0%!9*00./P!3.4)6!(30%%9!;.+%9+'*))C!,'.)%9+!;0'(.9%0(!
• @'((%9+P!K:.<*(B=3*)'*#!6%G%0%93%!'(!64%!'9!;0'(.9!3.9+%2+!
!4#":,$&'(&G":>*V$0M0*%BS0*5666Z C!(+ 0 '3+ !(3 0 4 +'9 C !6 . % ( !? NK!*;;)C!+.!3 %9 ( 4 ( !_ 4%(+'.9(!(.)'3'+'9&!0*3%!
o ].,%09<%9+!'9+%0%(+(!*0%!3.<;%))'9&!*96!9*00./)C!+*').0%6!
o >((%(('9&!0*3'*)!6'(;*0'+'%(!'9!:%*)+:!*96!%9,'0.9<%9+*)!0'([(!
o 8*3'*)!0%6'(+0'3+'9&!0%_4'0%<%9+(!
o 19G.03%!;0.,'('.9(!.G!M8>!
N#4;5&'(&)86>&47&B5,456"*V5F*!<@0*W777ZC*;.)'3%!4(%!,'3+'<Z(!6%(30';+'.9!D'93)I!0*3%F!
• (+0'3+!(304+'9C!6.%(!?NK!*;;)C!+.!;.)'3%!4(%!.G!0*3'*)!(4(;%3+!6%(30';+'.9(!+.!3.9643+!(/%%;(!
• 6'(;*0*+%!'<;*3+P!A4+!?NK!;40;.(%!.0!*;;)'3*+'.9#!3.9+%2+4*)!D'I%IP!:./!<*9C!A)*3[(!'9!3.<<49'+CP!A406%9!.9!
+:.(%!3'+'a%9(P!(C<A.)'3!:*0<P!/%'&:%6!*&*'9(+!(%0'.4(9%((!.G!30'<%!*96!)*/!%9G.03%<%9+!9%%6(F!
• 7'3+'<!<*6%!0*3%!(*)'%9+P!;.)'3%!*))./%6!+.!4(%!3:*0*3+%0'(+'3(!D6.9Z+!:.AA)%!;.)'3%!'9,%(+'&*+'.9F!
!
O9+')!GrutterP!(+0'3+!'9!+:%. 0 C !'( !'9,*)'6!'9!G*3+ I!
Morales/Oneonta#!&%+!.4+!.G!b;%0!(%c!'9,*)'6'+C!AC!(*C'9 & !+: *+ !(+0'3 +!(30 4 +'9 C!6 .% (!9 . +!%, %9 !* ; ;)C!
o 0*3%EA*(%6!6'GG%0%9+'*)(!A*(%6!.9!treatment!60*/!(+0' 3+ !(3 0 4 +'9 C P!A 4 + !+: . ( % !A * ( %6 !. 9 !classification(.0!
formation!6.!9 . + !6 0* /!(+0'3+!(304+'9 C !
*
M<:G>@>;B*&EG>A;*M8A;@<9B*
=+*+4+%(!+:*+!0*'(%!3)*'<(!.G!0*3'*)!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!
LI W*3'*))C!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!
*I ^%9+'.9(!0*3%!.9!'+(!G*3%#!Strauder,(Loving!
AI @'GG%0%9+!A406%9(!+.!6'GG%0%9+!&0.4;(!DStrauderFP!.0!G.0<*)!%_4*)'+C!.G!*;;)'3*+'.9!DLovingF!
QI W*3'*))C!9%4+0*)P!*;;)'%6!'9!*!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!<*99%0!
*I M)*(('3!M*(%#!Yick(Wo#!G*3'*))C!9%4 +0* )P!A 4 + !*6 <'9'(+%0%6!/ '+ : !b% , ')!% C %!* 9 6 !4 9 % , % 9 !: *9 6 c!
RI W*3'*))C!9%4+0*)!)*/!;*((%6!/'+:!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!'9+%9+!
*I Hunter:!)*/!6'(%9G0*93:'( % 6 !G% ). 9 ( P!G* 3'* )) C!9%4+0*)P!A4+!'9 +% 9 6 % 6 !+ . !6 '( 30 '<'9*+%!
AI -'%03'9&!+:%!,%')!0%,%*)(!*!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!;40; . (% !
3I ='<')*0!+.!McCullochP!M.9&0%((!3*9Z+!*3+ !4 9 6 % 0 !* !;0%+%2+!*96 !& % + !6 % G% 0 % 9 3 % !/B.!(304+'9 C !
SI W*3'*))C!9%4+0*)!)*/!;*((%6!/B.!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!'9+%9+!+:*+!:*(!*!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!impact!
*I @'(30%+'.9*0C!%9G.03%<%9+!;%0<'++%6!*96!*))./(!G.0!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!*;;)'3*+'.9!
AI "W!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!%GG%3 +(!/ %0% !9.+!G.0 %(%% *A )%!DWashington(v.(DavisF!.0!'G!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!%GG%3+(!/%0%!
G.0%(%%9!A4+!9 . +!+: %!(; % 3'G'3!; 4 0; . (% !DFeeneyF#!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!0%,'%/ !
>))!3*+%&.0'%(!%23%;+!G.0!yS!/'))!60*/!(+0'3+!(304+'9CI!!"G!9.!intentP!+:%9!9.!*<.49+!.G!'< ; * 3 + !/'))!3*4(%!+: % !( +* + 4+%!+.!
60*/!*9C+:'9&!:'&:%0!+:*9!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!0%,'%/!
o $%,%)!.G!'9+%9+!<4(+!A%!(.!:'&:!+:*+!+:%!<%0%![9./)%6&%!.G!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!'<;*3+!/'))!9.+!%_4*)!'9+%9+m!
6'(30'<'9*+.0C!;40;.(%!<4(+!A%!<.0%!+:*9!<%0%![9./)%6&%!
o Rodgers(v.(Lodge:!]>!)%&'()*+40%!<*'9+*'9%6!+:*+!)*/!/*( !9 . +!. 0 '& '9 * ))C !'9 + % 9 +'. 9 * )) C !6 '(3 0 '<'9*+.0C!
M.40+!:.)6(!'+!*!,'.)*+'.9!.G!1-!A%3*4(%!)%&'()*+40%!:*6!maintained('+!
o =+*+4+.0C!+0%*+<%9+!.G!6'(;*0*+%!'<;*3+!
o ^.0%!;0.+%3+'.9!496%0!K'+)%!7""!G.0!;40%!'<;*3+!3)*'<(!
o K'+)%!7""!'93)46%(!3.).0!*96!0%)'&'.9P!9.+!X4(+!0*3%!
o 1<;).C%0!3*9!6%G%96!G*3'*)!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!.9)C!.9!A*('(!.G!A.9*!G'6%!.334;*+'.9*)!_4*)'G'3*+'.9!DA4+!
+:%0%!'(!9.!AG._!G.0!0*3%F!
o 1<;).C%0!3*9!6%G%96!*&*'9(+!6'(;*0*+%!'<;*3+!.9)C!.9!+:%!A*('(!.G!A4('9%((!9%3%(('+CI!!!
O96%0!M.9(+'+4+'.9P!%<;).C%0!:*(!9.!.A)'&*+'.9!+.!*660%((!'<;*3+!'G!:%!:*(!9.!'9+%9+!D.9)C!
0*+'.9*)!A*('(!0%,'%/F!
o @'(+'9&4'(:!A%+/%%9!'9+%9+!*96!'<;*3+!
o "(!+:%!G*3'*))C!9%4+0*)!;.)'3C!('< ;)C !*!;0%+% 2+!G.0!6 '(30'< '9 *+.0 C!int en tY!
"G!\%(P!'9,*)'6I!
"G!?.#!6.%(!+:%!;.)'3C!:*,%!*!6 '(30'< '9 *+. 0C!im p a c tY!
• "G!C%(#!3*9!+:%!%<;).C%0!;0 .6 43% !*!A4 ('9% ((!X4(+'G'3* +'.9 !G.0!+:%!; .)'3CY !
o "G!C%(P!,*)'6I!
o "G!9.P!'9,*)'6I!
o 12*<;)%#!19&)'(:!.9)C!0%_4'0%<%9+(#!D6'(;*0*+%!'<;*3+!G.0!9*+'.9*)!.0'&'9F!
K'+)%!7""#!9.+!0*3'*))C!6 '( 30 '<!.9!G*3%!!;0.A*A)C!9 . !' 9 +% 9 +P!: * 0 6 !+. !; 0 . , % !!6'(;*0*+% !
'<;*3+!.9!9 * +'. 9 *) !.0 '&'9 !!%<;).C % 0 !<4(+!(:./!b A 4 ( '9 % (( !9 % 3% ( (' +C c !X4 (+ 'G'3 * +' . 9!
!
!
!
M.9(+'+4+'.9*)!M.9+%2+!
• W*3'*))C!9%4+0*)P!A4+!/'+:!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!'9+%9+#!3)*(('3!b;0%+%2+c!
o =+0'3+!(304+'9C!*;;)'%(!
• /B.!'9+%9+P!*96!/'+:!'<;*3+P!+:%0%!'(!(+'))!3*4(%!.G!*3+'.9!496%0!K'+)%!7""!A4+!?NK!3.9(+'+4+'.9!
o .9)C!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!*;;)'%(!
o %23%;+'.9#!'G!+:%!'<;*3+!'(!;0.A*+',%!.G!'9+%9+!D%&0%&'.4(F!
• 12*<;)%#!.GG'3'*)!)*9&4*&%!'(!19&)'(:!
o W*3'*))C!6'(30'<'9*+.0CY!!?.I !
@'(30'<'9*+.0C!'9+%9+Y!!?.I!
• @'(;*0*+%!'<;*3+Y!!\%(I!
o H4+!)'[%)C!+.!A%!,*)'6*+%6!496%0!0*+'.9*)!A*('(d(+*+%!9.+!0%_4'0%6!+.!
0%(;.96!/'+:!'+Z(!,*)'6!0%*(.9(!D49)'[%!K'+)%!7""!('+4*+'.9F!
• K'+)%!7""!(+0.9&%0!;0.+%3+'.9P!;*0+)C!A%3*4(%!'+!'(!)'<'+%6!'9!(3. ; %!+. !%<;).C<%9+ !3. 9 +% 2 +I!!K. !(% %!6 'GG%0 %9 3 % P!
3.9+0*(+!Griggs!DK'+)%!7""F!*96!Washington(v.(Davis!DM.9(+'+4+'.9*)F !
*
@'(30'<'9*+.0C!;40;.(%#!:*06!+.!;0.,%!D.G+%9!493.9(3'.4(FdA4+!%_4*)'+C!.0!0%(4)+(!9.+!9%3%((*0CP!.9)C!(+.;;'9&!&.,Z+!
6'(30'<'9*+'.9!
• `'(+.0C!.G!+:%!*3+'.9!
• =+*0[!;*++%09!.G!'<;*3+!
• $%&'()*+',%!.0!*6<'9'(+0*+',%!:'(+.0C!
"G!G*3'*))C!9%4+0*)P!xZ(!A406%9!+.!(:. / !;4 0; .(% !*9 6!%GG%3+ !
! "G!(:./9P!&.,Z+!3*9!*++%< ; +!+.!(:. / !'+!/. 4)6 !:*, %!6. 9% !+:%!(*<%!0%&*06)%((!.G!0*3%B.0'&'9 !
! ! "G!&.,Z+!(:./(!+:'(P!+:%9!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!*;;)'%(!
! ! "G!9.+P!+:%9!'9,*)'6P!(+0'3+!(304+'9C!*9* )C('(!4 99 %3 %((* 0C!A B3!; 04; .( %!3*9 9 .+!A% !3.< ; %))'9&!
*
L8@<&Q4&'(&F4D<85$*VWXX^ZC*)*4960C!'9!(+. 9% BA 0'3[ !.0!9 %% 6 !;% 0< '+P!9 .!M :'9 %( %!&. +!/ * ',% 0(!A 4+ !*))!9. 9 !M: '9% (% !6'6!
• b*(!*;;)'%6cP!6'(30'<'9*+.0CP!0%,%0(%6!3.9,'3+'.9!
• =+*0[P!(+*+'(+'3*)!;*++%09!.G!'<;*3+!*).9%!3*9!(4(+*'9!1-!3)*'<!
A#899$&'(&G=<,&I4;,#&VW7`WZC*8%_4'0%<%9+!G.0!:'&:!(3:..)!6';).<*!*96!'9+%))'&%93%!+%(+!+:*+!'<;*3+(!A)*3[(!
• =+043[!6./9I!!^4(+!+0%*+!;%.;)%!6'GG%0%9+)C!'9!.06%0!+.!+0%*+!+:%<!%_4*))C!
• >))./*A)%!6'(30'<'9*+'.9(!*0%!G.0!A4('9%((!9%3%(('+C#!*A(%93%!.G!<*)'3'.4(!'9+%9+!.9!;*0+!.G!%<;).C%0!6.%(!
9.+!(*,%!
• K:'(!'(!*!K'+)%!7""!3*(%!
Q"$%859645&'(&G"'8$*VW7`bZC*('<')*0!G*3+!;*++%09P!+%(+'9&!G.0!;.)'3%!G.03%P!A)*3[(!G*')%6!<.0%!+:*9!/ :'+ %( P!1- !3 )* '<!
• O9)'[%!K'+)%!7""P!1-!6.%(!9.+!*))./!G.0!<%0%!(:./'9&!.G!6'(;*0*+%!'<;*3+!
o ^.0%!+:*+!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!0%,'%/!only('G!+:%0%!'(!6'(30'<'9*+.0 C !;4 0 ; .( %P!9 . !*<.49+!.G!6'(;*0 * +% !
'<;*3+!/'))!A % !(4 GG'3'% 9 +!* ). 9 %I !
o =)';;%0C!().;%!*0&4<%9+#!3.4)6!'9,*)'6*+%!(.!<*9C!&.,%09<%9+!*3+','+'%(!.9 !6'(;*0* +%!'< ;*3+!*). 9%!
o >;;0.;0'*+%!0%<%6C!G.0!6'(;*0*+%!'<;*3+!'(!)%&'()*+'.9!D(43:!*(!K'+)%!7""F!
• 1,%0C+:'9&!+409(!.9!<9;B9;I!!`%0%P!'9+%9+!)%G+!496%G'9%6I!!M.40+!4(%(!'9+%9+!G.0!b;40;.(%Pc!/*9+'9&!+:%!0%(4)+P!
9.+!X4(+![9./'9&!+:*+!J!/'))!0%(4)+I&
• =+%,%9(!3.93400%93%#!A*)*93%!<%0'+(!.G!'96','64*)!3*(%(&
E#:859645&F,89%6$&VW7``ZC*('2!;)*3%(!/%!3*9!)..[!G.0!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!;40;.(%!
• N9%!.G!+:%(%!G*3+.0(!'(!<EG>A;P!'9(.G*0!*(!'+!'(!;0.A * + ',%!.G!6'(30'< '9 * + . 0 C !; 40;.(%!
• `'(+.0'3*)!A*3[&0.496!.G!)%&'()*+'.9!
• =%_4%93%!.G!%,%9+(!)%*6'9&!4;!+.!)%&'()*+'.9!
• -0.3%640*)!6%;*0+40%(!G0.<!+:%!9.0<!
• =4A(+*9+',%!6%;*0+40%(!
• $%&'()*+',%!.0!*6<'9'(+0*+',%!:'(+.0C!
I,#$455,:&E?*858$6#"64#&'(&R,,5,>&VW7`7ZC&;0%G%0%93%!G.0!,%+%0*9(!'9!3',')!(%0,'3%!X.A(P!%23)46%(!/.<%9!
• M.40+!4(%(!'9+%9+!G.0!b;40;.(%Pc!/*9+'9&!+:%!0%(4)+P!9.+!X4(+![9./ '9&!+:*+!J!/ ') )!0 % (4)+I!
• W.0%(%%*A)%!'<;*3+!'9(4GG'3'%9+!+.!*(30'A%!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!'9+%9+!.G!)%&'()*+40%!D3.9+'9&%9+!.9!G*3+(YF!
• k9./)%6&%!+:*+!'+!/.4)6!'<;*3+!/.<%9!6'(;*0*+%)CP!A4+!9.+!purposeI!
o ^4(+!%9&*&%!'9!*3+','+C!9.+!in(spite(of(%GG%3+P!A4+!+,@"=$,&47!+:%!%GG%3+!D:% '& : +% 9 % 6 !( 30 4 + '9 C !. 9 )C !G. 0 !
+:%!)*++%0F!
o -0.,'9&!;40;.(%!0%_4'0%(!<.0%!+:*9!*/*0%9%((!.G!3.9(%_4%93%(&
• "G!/%!*33%;+!6'(;*0*+%!'< ; *3+!+: *+!(:'G+(!+:%!A406%9!+.!+:%!&.,%09<%9+!+.!(:./!0*+'.9*)%(!G.0!*))!;.)'3'%(!/'+:!
'<;*3+P!+:%0% !/ ') )!A% !%9 6 )% (( !)'+'& * +'. 9 !D54 (+'3 % !V:'+%!).,%(!()';;% 0C !(). ; % (!* 0& 4 < % 9 +( FI &
JH&'(&):"#>*VX
;L
*!<@0*W77^ Z C*LffEL!6'(;*0'+C!'9!(%9+%93'9&!G.0!30*3[!3.3*'9%!,%0(4(!;./6%0!
• @'(;*0*+%!'<;*3+!3*(%#!!
o ?.+!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!.9!G*3%P!9.!G'96'9&(!(4;;.0+!+:%.0C!.G!493.9(3'.4(!0*3'(<!'9!M.9&0%((!
o 8*+'.9*)!A*('(!0%,'%/#!9.+!%9*3+%6!/'+:!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!;40;.(%!DA*(%6!.9!6*9&%0.4(9%((!.G!604&F!
^'2%6!<.+',%!3*(%(#!%9.4&:!)%&'+'<*+%!<.+',%(!+.!X4(+'GC!
8*+3:%+'9&!4;!b;40;.(%c!0%_4'0%<%9+!'9!Feeney!<*[%(!'+!:*06!+ . !( : . / !;40;.(%I!
>)(.P!'9(+'+4+'.9*)!3.<;%+%93%#!/:.!(:.4)6!6%3'6%P!M.9&0%((!.0!M.40+(P!/:*+!;40;.(%!'(!)%&'+'<*+%I!
*
(II<@E>;<OB*(A;<89*
V:%0%!*!&0.4;!D'I%IP!0*3'*)!<'9.0'+'%(F!*0%!A%'9&!advantaged!AC!+:%!(+*+%I!!M* 9 !( +* +% !6 . !+ : '( P!4 9 6 % 0!1 - Y !
1_4*)'a*+'.9#!;0.,'6%!*6,*9+*&%!+.!3.49+%0;.'9+!:'(+.0CI!
>9+'E3)*(('G'3*+'.9!;0'93';)%!;0%,*')(#!M.9(+'+4+'.9!'(!9.+!3.).0EA)'96I!!!
• M.9&04%93C#!;*(+!6'(+'93+'.9!A%+/%%9!G%6%0*)B(+*+%!*GG'0<*+',%!*3+'.9!;0.&0*<(#!*G+%0!AdarandP!A.+:!G%6%0* )!* 96!
(+*+%!;0.&0*<(!&%+!(+0'3+!(304+'9C!DG%6!9.!).9&%0!&%+(!3.40+!(C<;*+:CF!
• M.9('(+%93C#!0%&*06)%((!.G!/:'3:!&0.4;!'(!*GG%3+%6!D*6,*9+*&%6!.0!6'(*6,*9+*&%6!&0.4;FP!*)/*C(!(+0'3+!(304+'9C!
• M.9+%2+#!K/.!<*'9!3.9+%2+(#!3.9+0*3+'9&!*96!%643*+'.9!
o M.9+0*3+'9&#!0%<%6'*+'.9!.G!;*(+!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!0*+'.9*)%!
o 1643*+'.9#!0%<%6'*)!*96!6',%0('+C!0*+'.9*)%(!
o ?.+%#!0%<%6'*+'.9!*96!6',%0('+C!*0%!compelling(government(interests!496%0!(+0'3+!(304+'9C !(+ *9 6 * 0 6 !
>([!'G!+:'(!'9+%0%(+!*3+4*))C!%2'(+(I!
"(!+:%0%!9*00./!+*').0'9& !+.!+:% !'9+%0%( +Y!
NAX%3+',%(!.G!>>#!0%<%6C!;*(+!6'(30'<'9*+'.9P!6',%0('+CP!0.)%!<.6%)(P!'930%*(%6!(%0,'3%(!+.!<'9.0'+C!3.<<49'+'%(!
D0'&'6!0%,'%/FI!
8*+'.9*)%(!G.0!>>#!DA.)6%6!0%<*'9F!
• 8*3'*)!A*)*93'9&!D0%G)%3+!;%03%9+*&%!'9!+:%!;.;4)*+'.9F#!3).(%!+.!_4.+*!(C(+%<P!(.!M*+%&.0'3*))C!8%X%3+%6!
• .BEBFK*G>:;*F<:A@<E<9>;<89*JK*$6"6,&"@64#3(<4(+!A%!AC!(*<%!(+*+%!*3+.0!+:*+!'(!;0.<4)&*+'9&!+:%!0%<%6C!
o K:'(!'(!/:C!O9',I!^'3:'&*9!6'6!9.+!0%)C!.9!0%<%6'*)P!A4+!0*+:%0!6',%0('+C!0*+'.9*)%!
o H0.*6B9*00./!D3)*((!.0!'96','64*)F!
o N0!'9!*!G'%)6!/:%0%!+:%0%!'(!;*(+!6'(30'<'9*+'.9P!Fullilove(v.(MutznickP!4;:%)6!)*/ !G. 0 !G496(!G.0!
<'9.0'+CE./9%6!A4('9%((%(!DA4+!.,%004)%6!AC!Adarand/CrosonF!
• 8%<%6C!(.3'%+*)!6'(30'<'9*+'.9#!>GG'0<*+',%!>3+'.9!3*9!?NK!A%!4(%6!+.!0%<%6C!
• -0.<.+%!:%*)+:!3*0%!'9!<'9.0'+C!3.<<49'+'%(#!:*(!6'(*;;%*0%6!*(!0*+'.9*)%P!G.0<!.G!(+%0%.+C;'9&!
• M<OB@:<;KC!(40,',%(!(+0 '3+ !(3 0 4 +'9 C !* 3 3I!- . /%))!'9!Bakke!
1643*+'.9B%<;).C<%9+!6','6%#!'9!G'0(+P!6',%0('+C!.G!,'%/;.'9+(!'(!3.<;%))'9&P!A4+!9.!(43:!L>!'((4%!'9!%<;).C< % 9 +I!
].*)(!,%0(4(!_4.+*(#!&.*)(!*0%!;%0<'(('A)%P!3*(%!AC!3*(%!*9*)C('(!.G!*;;)'3*9+(P!A4+!_4.+*(!*0%!9.+!*))./%6I!
!
M,9,56$&47&6%,&J58',#$86>&47&)":874#58"&'(&N"<<,*VW7`XZC*OM@*,'(!<%6!(3:..)Z(!_4.+*!(C(+%<#!Lg!(%*+(!G.0!<'9.0'+'%(!
• i4.+*!(C(+%<(!&%+!(+043[!6./9!per(se!D/:%0%*(!0 * 3% !* ( !*!; ) 4 (!G *3 +. 0 !G. 0 !+: . ( % !( %* + (!<'&:+!(40,', %F !
• K'+)%!7""!*96!M.9(+'+4+'.9*)!*9*)C('(!'6%9+'3*)!
• SELES!6%3'('.9I!!-./%))!(;)'+(!+:%!6'GG%0%93%!
o Q-!,'.)*+'.9!4 9 6 % 0!( +0 '3 +!( 30 4 +' 9 C P!*6 6 !H40&%0!S!D'9+ %0 <%6'*+%F!+.!(+ 0' [ % !; 0.&0*< !6./9!
o H4+!*)(.P!C.4!<'&:+!:*,%!*!;0.&0*<!+:*+!3.9('6%0(!0*3%P!*66!H0%99*9!S!+.!4;:.)6!4('9&!0*3%!*(!*!
G*3+.0!D9.+!6'3+*#!9 * 00. /!+*').0'9&!0%_4'0% (!* !goalP!9.+!* !quotaF!
N9)C!;*0+!/:%0%!h!X4(+'3%(!/'+:!'(!+:*+!b0*3%!3*9!A%!*!;)4(!G*3+.0c!
• =+0'3+!(304+'9C#!
o `*0<(#!
V:'+%(!<*C!A%!:*0<%6!AC!A406%9!.G!_4.+*!(C(+%<!
H)*3[(!<*C!A%!:*0<%6!AC!0%'9G.03%6!(+%0%.+C;%(!*96!G.(+%0'9&!6%;%96%93%!
o ].,%09<%9+!'9+%0%(+(!3.9('6%0%6#!
"930%*('9&!94< A% 0!.G!< '9. 0'+C!;: C( '3'*9 (#!0%X%3+%6 P!9.+!3. < ; %))'9& !*(!9. !%< ;'0'3 *)!%,'6 %9 3%!
+:*+!+:%C!/'))!( % 0, % !'9 !<'9.0'+C!3.<<49'+'%(!
M.49+%0'9&!(.3'*)!6'(30'<'9*+'.9#!<4(+!A%!(4;;.0+%6!AC!)%&'()*+',%!G'96'9&(!+:*+!(4&&%(+!
<.0%!9*00./!;0.A)%<!(4GG'3'%9+!+.!X4(+'GC!(:'G+'9&!+:%!A406%9!+.!/:'+%(!
H0%99*9!S!G'96(!+:%!6',%0('+C!*0&4<%9+!3.<;%))'9&#!L>!0'&:+(!.G!49',!+.!;'3[!6',%0(%!(+46%9+!
A.6C!
• @'((%9+#!DH0%99*9!SF#!6.9Z+!4(%!(+0'3+!(304+'9C!
o V:'+%(!)*3[!+0*6'+'.9*)!'96'3'*!.G!(4(;%3+9%((!
?.!:'(+.0'3*)!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!
Amanda Bakale 4/29/09 11:21 PM
Amanda Bakale 4/30/09 2:16 PM
Comment: =%%!+*A)%!.9!--K!()'6%!
Comment: =%%!:*96.4+!
?.+!(*66)%6!/'+:!6'(*A')'+'%(!
?.+!0%)%&*+%6!+.!;.)'+'3*)!;./%0)%((9%((!
o >;;)C!'9+%0<%6'*+%!(304+'9C!
"<;.0+*9+!&.,Z+!;4 0; .(% P!(4A( +*9 +'*))C!0%)* +%6!
=.<%!:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9C#!;*+%09*)'(+'3!(+%0%.+C;%P!'9(4)*0!;..0!/:'+%(!(4GG%0!
• H)*3[<49#!<*9*&%<%9+!.G!(3:..)(!'(!A%C.96!3.<;%+%93%!.G!3.40+!
• =+%,%9(#!K'+)%!7"!(:.4)6!6%3'6%!+:%!3*(%P!9.+!1-!D9.!6'(30'<!AC!'9(+'+4+'.9(!0%3%','9&!G%6!G496(F!
>9+'E(4A.06'9*+'.9!0*+'.9*)%#!CaroleneP!)..[!+.!3.40 + !+.!0%<%6C!; * ( +!6 ' (3 0 '<'9*+'.9P!+: . ( % !/:.!*0%!6'(* 6 ,*9+*&%6!'9 !
+:%!;.)'+'3*)!;0.3%((I!!!
!
R=::8:4',&'(&T:=6U58@<*VW7X6ZC*G%6%0 *)!3 .9 +0 *3 +'9 & !>> !; 0 .& 0* <P!(%+!*('6%!G496(!G.0!< '9 . 0'+C !A4 ( '9% (( %(!
• ?.!<*X.0'+C!.;'9'.9P!R!G.0!'9+%0<%6'*+%!+.!4;:.)6P!R!+.!4;:.)6!*(!X4(+'G'%6!+.!0%<%6C!;*(+!6'(30'<P!*96!R!
6'((%9+%0(!G.0!(+0'3+!(304+'9C!
• H40&%0#!49*0+'34)*+%6!(+*96*06!+.!4;:.)6!A%3*4(%!CONGRESS!*0+'34)*+%6!'9 !4 9 6 % 0!L S >!jhP!A4+!jL!'(!*!)'<'+!.9!
(+*+%(!D6'(+'93+'.9!A%+/%%9!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)'+C!.G!G%6%0*)!*96!(+*+%!>>!;0.&0*<(F!
o $'&:+!A406%9!(;0%*6!*30.((!'99.3%9+!/:'+%!;.;4)*+'.9!
• -./%))P!3.93400%93%P!/.4)6!*;;)C!==P!G'96'9&!3.<;%))'9&!'9+%0%(+!
&
Q>9"56&'(&O"@<$45&N4"#?&47&X?=@"6845&VW7XbZC*0.)%!<.6%)!0*+'.9*)%#!9%%6!(.<%.9%!/:.!)..[(!)'[%!<%!+.!)..[!4;!+.I!!
@'(0%&*06%6P!([%;+'3*)I!!>>!;)*9!0%;)*3%(!b)*(+!:'0%6P!G'0(+!G'0%6c!/'+:!3*+%&.0'3*)!04)%!+:*+!<'9.0'+'%(!*0%!G'0%6!)*(+!
=+0'3+!=304+'9C#!
• =+*+%!;40;.(%(!0%X%3+%6#!
o 8%<%6'*)#!9.!G*3+4*)!G'96'9&(!.G!;*(+!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!
o @',%0('+CB0.)%!<.6%)(#!*))./(!G.0!9.!(+.;;'9&!;.'9+P!+'%6!+.!z*&%!'9!(+46%9+!A.6C!
• ?.+!9*00./)C!+*').0%6#!
o `%*,C!A406%9!.9!'99.3%9+!;*0+'%(!
• @'((%9+#!40&%93C!.G!;0%(%0,'9&!'9+%&0*+'.9!/.4)6!;*((!==P!*96!%,%9!*3+',%!0%304'+<%9+!.G!<'9.0'+'%(!'(!4(%)%((!
AB3!.G!G'0(+EG'0%6!04)%(!
!
)86>&47&M8@%*45?&'(&O(E(&)#4$45&)4(&VW7X7ZC*3.9+0*3+'9&P!3.9+0*3+(!+.!<'9.0'+C!./9%6!3.<;*9'%(!
• ?.!<*X.0'+C!G.0!6%G'9'9&!(+*96*06P!A4+!<*X.0'+C!'9!*;;)C'9&!(+*96*06!
• =+0'3+!(304+'9C!DNZM.99.0#!(+'&<*+'3!:*0<!.G!>>F!
• W.0!0%<%6'*)!0*+'.9*)%P!)..[!+.!;0.<4)&*+'9&!%9+'+C!.G!+:%!>>!;0.&0*<#!+:%!*3+.0!<4(+!:*,%!%9&*&%6!'9!+:%!
;*(+!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!
• ?.!<*X.0'+C#!
o 8%<%6'*)!G.0!;*(+!;0',*+%!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!3*9!A%!3.<;%))'9&!"W!%,'6%93%!(4&&%(+(!+:*+!(+*+%!/*(!*!
;*((',%!;*0+'3';*9+!DA4+!9.!G'96'9&(!:%0%F!
• M.40+!0%X%3+(!(+*+%!0*+'.9*)%(!
o 0%)%,*9+!6%9.<'9*+.0!'(!9.+!+:%!;%03%9+*&%!.G!< '9.0'+'%(!'9!%9+'0%!;.;4)* +'.9P!A4+!+:%!;%03%9 +*&%!.G!
<'9.0'+'%(!/:.!*0%!qualified!
-./%))Z(!6'(+'93+'.9!A%+/%%9!(.3'%+C!*96!(+*+%!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!:*(!A'+%!
>GG%3+%6!AC!;*+:!6%;%96%93'%(!.0!34)+40*)!6'GG%0%93%(!
o 94<A%0!.G!;%.;)%!/:.!*3+4*))C!/*9+!+.!6.!+:'(!*96B.0!*0%!_4*)'G'%6!
o 9*+'.9*)!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!'(!9.+!%_4*)!+.!8'3:<.96Z(!6'(30'<'9*+'.9I!!M.9&0%((!:*(!(;%3'*)!*4+:.0'+C!
D)*+%0!NZM.99.0!0%;46'*+%(!:%0!./ 9!3)*'<(!:%0%!'9!AdarandF!
• M'+C!:*(!9.+!<%+!'+(!A406%9!.G!(:./'9&!+:*+!'+!/*(!*3+'9&!+.!0%<%6C!'+(!own!;*(+!6'(30'<'9*+'. 9 !
o ^4(+!A%!;*(+!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!/'+:!3.9+'94'9&!%GG%3+(!'9.!+:%!G4+40%!
• M*9!(+*+%!'9*3+'.9!3.49+!*(!(+*+%!*3+'.9Y!!!
o ]%9%0*))C!9.P!(%%!DeShaneyI!!!
o `%0%P!NZM.99.0P!/B.!+:%!3.40+Z(!(4;;.0+P!/0'+%(!*A.4+!;*((',%!;*0+'3';*+'.9!AC!(+*+%!D;%0:*;(!/:C!
(:%!6'69Z+!&%+!+:%!0%(+!.G!+:%!3.40+!.9!+:'(F!
• K*').0'9&!;0.A)%<(!
• ?.+!9*00./)C!+*').0%6#!3'+C!6'69Z+!3.9('6%0!*!0*3%E9%4+0*)!.;+'.9P!Rfz!_4.+*!'(!9.+!0%)*+%6!+.!*!&.*)P!
;%03%9+*&%!9.+!+'%6!+.!*3+4*)!'9X40'%(P!X4(+!0*3'*)!A*)*93'9&!D34)+40*))CP!9.!0%*(.9!+.!0%_4'0%!0*3%!+.!A%!%_4*))C!
0%;0%(%9+%6!'9!*))!;0.G%(('.9(P!+:.4&:!<*CA%!C.4!/ .4 )6!496% 0!G.0<*)!3.9 3%;+!.G!0*3%F !
!
?.+%#!K'+)%!7"!0%_4'0%<%9+(!*0%!,'%/%6!+.!A%!%((%9+'*))C!+:%!(*<%!*(!+:.(%!496%0!1-!
&
!,6#4&N#4"?@"$6859&'(&R))&VW776ZC&'9!A0.*63*(+'9&!3. 9 +% (+ P!.9 )C !'9 +% 0<%6'*+%!(304+'9 CP!A * (% 6!. 9 !6', % 0( '+C !0* +'. 9 *) %!
D6',%0('+C!'9!;0.&0*<<'9&B. ;'9'.9 (F!
"9+%0<%6'*+%!(304+'9C #!FulliloveI!!>660%( (' 9 & P!9 .+!*))%,'*+'9&!:*0<(!.G!;*(+!3.9643+I!W%6% 0*)!3)*(('G'3*+'.9!:* (!)%((!
(304+'9C!+:*9!(+*+%B).3*)P!.0!<*)'&9%6!0*3%EA*(%6!3)*(('G'3*+'.9(!
NZM.99.0!6'((%9+#!G%6%0*)!A.496!+.!(*<%!1-!*(!(+*+%(!
k%99%6C!6'((%9+#!0%&4)*+'.9!(+%0%.+C;%(!b<'9.0'+C!,'%/;.'9+(Pc!:*0<!+.!/:'+%(!
(
Metro(Broadcasting(.,%004)%6!.9!(304+'9C!&0.496(!AC!AdarandI!!H%+/%%9!Lnn f !* 96!LnnfhP!+: % 0 % G. 0 % P!A % ( +!+ '<%!G.0!>>!
;0.&0*<(!G.0!G%6%0*)!%9+'+'%(I!!?./P!M.40+!49)'[%)C!+.!*33%;+!6',%0('+C!'9!A0.*63*(+'9&!*(!*!0*+'.9*)%I!
!
1)C#!/:%9!+:%!&0.4;!3.9+0.))'9&!+:%!6%3'('.9(!3:..(%(!+.!A% 9% G'+!9. +!'+(% )G!A4 +!*!<'9.0'+CP!)%((!(4(;'3'.4( P!*!/ : '+%!
<*X.0'+C!'(!49)'[%)C!+.!6'(*6,*9+*&%!'+(%)G!AB3!.G!;0%X46'3%!
!
E?"#"5?&)45$6#=@64#$&'(&I,5"*VW77_ZC*(+0'3+!(304+'9C!+.!;0%G%0%93%!.G!3.9+0*3+(!+:*+!%<;).C!(.3'*)!.0!%3.9.<'3*))C!
6'(*6,*9+*&%6!(4A3.9+0*3+.0(!DA)*3[P!`'(;*9'3P!9*+',%!*<%0P!*('*9!*<%0F!
K:0%%!;0'93';)%(!
LI =[%;+'3'(<#!+./*06!any!0*3%EA*(%6!6'(+'93+'.9!
*I 1-!;0.+%3+(!;%.;)%P!9.+!&0.4;(!
AI >9+'E3)*(('G'3*+'.9!;0'93';)%!
QI M.9('(+%93C#!3*9Z+!:*,%!6'GG%0%9+!(+*96*06!G.0!/:'+%(!+:*9!G.0!0*3'*)!<'9.0'+'%(!D.,%004)%((Metro(B.F!
*I ==!0%&*06)%((!.G!;40;.(%!
AI M*9Z+!6'(+'9&4'(:!<*)'&9%6!G0.<!A%9'&9!;40;.(%(!
RI M.9&04%93C#!9.!6'GG%0%93%!A%+/%%9!G%6%0*)!*96!(+*+%!;0.&0*<(!
*I N9%!1-!6.3+0'9%P!Bolling!%2+%96%6!h>!+. !G% 6 (!
• =3*)'*#!9.!3.<;%))'9&!&.,Z+!'9+%0%(+!'9!b<*['9&!4;c!G.0!;*(+!6'(30'<'9*+'.9I!
• K:.<*(#!%_4',*)%93%!A%+/%%9!;*+%09*)'(+'3!0*3%EA*(%6!)%&'()*+'.9!*96!0*3'*)!6'(30'<'9*+'.9I!
• =+%,%9(#!@'GG%0%93%!A%+/%%9!A%9'&9!*96!<*)'&9%6P!3.9&04%93%!9.+!0%_4'0%6!DLS>!jL!0%&4)*+%(!=+*+%(P!jh!
%<;./%0!M.9&0%((F!
!
=+0'3+!=304+'9C!'(!9.+!fatal(in(factI!
H4+P!*+!+:'(!;.'9+P!9.!;0.&0*<!:*(P!'9!G*3+P!(40,',%6!D%,%9!Adarand!/*(!(+043[!6./ 9 !. 9 !0% <*96F!
!
A#=66,#&'(&N4::859,#&V566YZC*O9',I!^'3:'&*9!$*/!4(%!.G!0*3%!'9!*6<'(('.9(!=O87"71=!(+0'3+!(304+'9C!
• ?*00./)C!+*').0%6!+.!&.,%09< %9 +!'9+% 0% (+!'9 !educational(diversity!
o M.<;%))'9&#!!
o ?%3%((*0C!+.!;0%;*0%!;%.;)%!G.0!'930%*('9&)C!&).A*)'a%6!/.0[!G.03%!D)'<'+%6!+.!%643*+'.9*)!3.9+%2+F!
o ?*00./!A%3*4(%!.9)C!4('9&!0*3%!*(!*!;)4(!G*3+.0!
o =3:..)!3.9('6%0%6!0*3%E9%4+0*)!*)+%09*+',%(!A4+!9.9%!*,*')*A)%!D/.9Z+!)./%0!*3*6%<'3!(+*96*06(F!
o Sunset!;0.,'('.9(#!+: % !<.<%9+!'+!'( !9 . !). 9 & % 0!9%3%((*0CP!'+!(4 9 ( % +( !DQ h !C % * 0( F!
• M0'+'_4%!D8%:9_4'(+BK:.<*(!6'((%9+(F!
o 196(#!/:C!'(!0*3'*)!6',%0('+C!*9!%96Y!!D%(;!*(!3.<;*0%6!+.!.+:%0!G.0<(!.G!6',%0('+CF!
NZM.99.0#!0*3%!'(!6'GG%0%9+!AB3!.G!:'(+.0C!.G!0*3%!0%)*+'.9(P!A4+!+:%9P!'(9Z+!+:'(!0%<%6'*)!/.0[!
+:0.4&:!+:%!)..;:.)%!.G!b6',%0('+CcY !
o K*').0'9&#!X'&&%0'9&!'9!+%0<(!.G!*6<'++'9&!<.0%!<'9.0'+'%(P!+:'(!'(!*!:'66%9!_4.+*!(C(+%<!
o K:.<*(#!6.!<.0%!:*0<!+:*9!&..6!'9!;*+0.9'a'9&!>G0'3*9 !> <%0'3*9(!/'+: !> > !;0 . &0 * < ( P!30% *+ %!
(+%0%.+C;%(!*A.4+!>G0'3*9!><%0'3*9(!*(!;0.+%3+%6!*96 !496%0; %0G.0< '9&!
K:%!.9)C!3.<;%))'9&!'9+%0%(+!+.!;*((!==!'(!9*+'.9*)!(%340'+CP!Korematsu!
?.!6%G%0%93%!+.!*3*6%<'3!'9(+'+4+'.9(P!US(v.(Virginia!
• ^4)+';)%!*96!3.9G)'3+'9&!3.93%;+'.9(!.G!0*3%I!!^.0%!+:*9!G.0<* )!0*3%I!!NZM.9 9.0!4( '9&!34)+4 0*)B:'(+. 0'3*)FP!A4+!
&.%(!A*3[!*96!G.0+:dI!b30'+'3*)!<*((c!0%&*06(!G.0<*)I!
!
A#"6U&'(&N4::859,#&V566 YZ3&^'3:'&*9!496%0&0*6!;0.&0*<#!(+0'3[(!6./9!0*3'*)!;0%G%0%93%!+:%!(*<%!6*C!*(!'+!4;:.)6(!
)*/!(3:..)Z(!'9!Grutter!
• O96%0&0*6!;0.&0*<!'(!<.0%!)'[%!*!_4.+*P!A%3*4(%!;.'9+(!*(('&9%6!G.0!0*3%!*0%!.4+!.G!;0.;.0+'.9I!
• -.'9+!(C(+%<(!*0%!)'[%)C!+.!&%+!(+043[!6./9I!!!
o ?.+!9*00./)C!+*').0%6#!(3:..)!<4(+!A%!(4GG'3'%9+)C!(<*))!+:*+!'+!3*9!*GG.06!'96','64*)'a %6 !* ( (% ( ( <%9+!
;)4(!G*3+.0(!'9!.06%0!+.!<*'9+*'9!>>!
• ]'9(A40&P!6'((%9+#!+:'(!/'))!G.03%!;)4(!G*3+.0(!496%0&0.496P!)%((!G0*9[!*96!)%((!G*'0B)%((!+0*9(;*0%9+!
Amanda Bakale 4/30/09 2:54 PM
Comment: =%%!()'6%!
!
k%C!+.!A%'9&!4;:%)6#!4(%!6',%0('+C!0*+'.9*)%P!3.9('6%0!0*3%E9%4+0*)!*)+%09*+',%(P!9.!;.'9+!(C(+%<I!
?.!_4.+*(P!(%+E*('6%(!<4(+!;*((!(+0'3+!(304+'9C!*96!*0%!49)'[%)C!+.!G.0!A0.*6!;*++%09(!.G!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!
8*3%!3*9!A%!*!G*3+.0P!A4+!G*3+.0!<4(+!A%!9*00./)C!+*').0%6!
! =%%!6'GG%0%93%!A%+/%%9!Grutter,(Gratz:!.9)C!NZM.99.0!U!H0 % C% 0 !, . +% 6 !6 'G G%0%9 +)C!
&
I"#,56$&\5'4:',?&85&)4**=586>&H@%44:$&'(&H,"66:,&H@%44:&G8$6(&K4(&.&
*
&9;B@EBF<>;B *$A@ = ;<9K *>9 F *4B 9F B @*! ?>:: <I<A> ;<8 9: *
"<<4+*A)%P!:'(+.0C !.G!6'(30'< '9 *+'. 9P!0%X%3+!0. < *9 +'3!; *+%09 * )'(< !*96 !(%; *0* +%!(;: %0% (!
N#"?;,::&'(&\::8548$*VWX`YZC*!;*0*<.4 9 +!<'(('.9!.G!/.<*9!'(!*(!/'G%!*9 6!<.+:%0#!/.< % 9 !6% 9 '%6 !0'& : +!+. !
G.0<!3.9+0*3 +(!'(!+: % !A* ('( !G.0 !6% 9C '9 & !/ . < % 9 !%9 +0C !+.!)* / !( 3: .. )I!!=% ; *0 *+ %!(; : %0 %( !*0& 4 <%9+I!
!=66,#&'(&B#,9453*Q,$6&)4"$6&'(&I"##8$%C*4(%6!0.<*9+'3!;*+%09*)'(<P!;0.+%3+'.9!
! E?<85$&'(&)%8:?#,5S$&F4$D86":*VW75YZ C*.,%004)%6!MullerP!Ln>!%<*93';*+%(!G0.<!;0.+%3+'.9!D ( : . 0 +) ', % 6 F !
!
M,,?&'(&M,,?&VW7`WZC*0*+'.9*)!A*('(!/'+:!A'+%!*;;)'%6!+.!;0%G%0%93%!G.0!<*)%!%2%34+.0(P!(+043[!6. / 9 !
8*+'.9*)!A*('(#!G*')%(P!*0A'+0*0C!3:.'3%!G.0A'66%9!AC!1-#!(%)%3+'9&!*&*'9(+!/.<%9!/*(!/.0(%!+:*9!;'3['9&!*+!0*9 6. < !!
* +<;L*J<;BC*+:%0%!'(!*9'<4(P!493.9,'93%6!AC!*9C!(+*+%!0*+'.9*)!+:%!3.40+!(+0'[%(!'+!6./ 9!
&
R#4568,#4&'(&M8@%"#?$45&VW7`YZC*;)40*)'+C!&',%(!(+0'3+!(304+'9C!+.!6'(;*0*+%!<')'+*0C!A%9%G'+(!+.!6%;%96%9+(!
• =%0,'3%<%9!3*9!3)*'<!/',%(!*(!6%;%96%9+(P!A4+!(%0,'3%/.<%9!3*9!.9)C!3)*'<!:4(A*96(!'G!+:%C!*0%!+:%!
;0'<*0C!/*&%!%*09%0!
• ?.!6%G%0%93%!+.!<')'+*0CP!9.+!+:%!:%*0+!.G!<')'+*0C!G493+'.9!D.9)C!1-!3*(%!<')'+*0C!:*(!).(+F!
• =+0'3+!=304+'9C!'9!;)40*)'+C!.9)CP!9%,%0!*!<*X.0'+C!
o `*0<#!
-0.3%640*)#!:%'&:+%9%6!0%_4'0%<%9+!.G!;0..G!.G!6%;%96%93C!
=4A(+*9+',%#!(%0,'3%<%9!&%+!<.0%!*'6!+:*9!(%0,'3%/.<%9!/:%9!(;.4(%!'(!9.+!6%;%96%9+!
o ].,Z+!'9+%0%(+#!
>6<'9'(+0*+',%!%GG'3'%93C!'(!?1718!(4GG'3'%9+!496%0!(+0'3+!(304+'9C!
?.!%,'6%93%!+:*+!+:%!;0%(4<;+'.9!*3+4*))C!(*,%(!+:%!<')'+*0C!<.9%C!
• -./%))!6.%(!?NK!X.'9!;)40*)'+CP!6%(;'+%!493.9(+'+4+'.9*)'+CP!*(!M.9&0%((!:*(!*3+%6!D(.!6.9Z+!'93)46%!&%96%0!'9!
(4(;%3+!3)*((F!
o 1-!&4*0*9+%%!,'*!h>!@-!
M.40+!'9+%0,%9%(!/:%9!;%.;)%!3*9Z+!&%+!*++%9+'.9!.G!)*/<*[%0(!
M.40+!6.%(9Z+!'9+%0,%9%!/:%9!;%.;)%!:*,%!*++%9+'.9!.G!M.9&0%((P!A4+!6.%(9Z+!;0%,%9+!M.40+!
G0.<!*)(.!*3+'9 &!
• 18>#!;0.;.(%6!'9!LnpQ!
o 1_4*)'+C!.G!0'&:+(!496%0!)*/!(:*))!9.+!A%!6%9'%6!.0!*A0'6&%6!AC!+:%!O=!.0!*9C!(+*+%!.9!A*('(!.G!(%2!
o W*')(P!/.<%9Z(!<.,%<%9+!:.(+')%!+.!9%/!/*,%!G%<'9'(<!*0'(%(P!A*(%6!.9!G*<')C!,*)4%!G%*0(!.G#!
N9!6%<*96!*A.0+'.9!!
`.<.(%24*)!;0.+%3+'.9!
19)'(+'9&!/.<%9!'9!<')'+*0C!
o >+!+'<%!.G!3*(%P!'9!0*+'G'3*+'.9!<.6%!
@'6!.;'9'.9!+*[%!/'96!.4+!.G!(*')(!G.0!18>!;.)'+'3*)!<.<%9+4<Y!
M.40+Z(!0.)%!'(!?NK!+.!&%+!;.)'+'3*))C!'9,.),%6!'9!6%<.30*+'3!;0.3%((!
• K:.<*(#!'9+%0;0%+!M.9(+'+4+'.9!'96%;%96%9+)C!.G!(.3'*)!<.,%<%9+(P!9.!(.3'.).&'3*)!*9*)C('(Y!
• H0%99*9#!Reed(4(%6!:%'&:+%9%6!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!/'+:!A'+%P!*)0%*6C!6'6!+:'(!['96!.G!%9&*&'9&P!3*;*3'+C!+.!&%+!
*++%9+'.9!.G!)*/<*[%0(!'(!*!0%*(.9!G.0!M.40+!+.!*)(.!*3+I!
o V.<%9!*0%!9%'+:%0!6'(30%+%!9.0!'9(4)*0P!A4+!;.;4).4(!*96!6'GG4(%I!!K:%C!:*,%!+:%!%*0!.G!+:%!
)%&'()*+40%d:%'& :+ %9 %6 !(3 04+ '9C !X4(+'G'% 6!A B3 !+:% C!: *, %!'9 +%0 9* )'a%6 !< * )%!6 .<'9*93%Y!!-*+%09* )'(+'3I!
• ?./P!.9)C!A)*3[(!&%+!==P!A*('3*))C#!.+:%0/'(%P!6%G%0!496%0!CaroleneP!)%+!6%<.30* + '3 !; 0 . 3 % (( !0 % <%6C!
!
!
54(+'G'3*+'.9(!G.0!(+ 0'3 +!(30 4 +'9 C#!!
• M.<;*0%!0*3%!*96!(%2#!A.+:!'<<4+*A)%P!0%)*+%!+.!(+*+4(B3.9643+!6'(+'93+'.9P!6.9Z+!A406%9!;%.;)%!G.0!+:'9&(!
+:%C!3*9Z+!:%);!
• `'(+.0C!.G!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!D.9!*!;%6%(+*)!.0!'9!*!3*&%F!
• `'&:!,'('A')'+CP!'<;.(('A)%!+.!'&9.0%!+:%!3:*0*3+%0'(+'3!
Amanda Bakale 4/30/09 3:49 PM
Amanda Bakale 4/30/09 4:00 PM
Comment: YYY!
Comment: (%%!;;+!G.0!+'<%)'9%!.G!<.6%09!
3*(%(!.9!(%2!6'(30'<!
• -.)'+'3*)!;./%0)%((9%((P!6%(;'+%!<*X.0'+C!.G!;.;4)*+'.9!+:%C!*0%!9.+!0%;0%(%9+%6!
o M*;*3'+C!+.!&%+!*++%9+'.9!.G!)*/<*[%0(!+:.4&:!<'&:+!A%!0%*(.9!?NK!+.!*3+P!(%%!Cleburne!A%)./!
o Carolene(Products:(/.<%9!*0%!9%'+:%0!6'(30%+%!9.0!'9(4)*0!
?.+!&:%++.'a%6P!A4+!(%;*0*+%!(;:%0%(!(%_4%(+%0%6!
^*3k'99.9P!Feminism(Unmodified!DLnepF#!<4 (+ !. G!/:*+!'(!bG%<'9 ' (<c!'9!)*/!:* (!A%%9!*++%<; + !+. !& % +!G . 0!<%!/:*+!)'++)% !
:*(!A%%9!0%(%0,%6!G.0!/.<%9!
*
]%96%0!{!8*3%!'9!(304+'9C!;0.+%3+'.9!
LI N0'&'9*)!496%0(+*96'9&!.G!LS>!
QI M.93%09(!*A.4+!'9+%0,%9+'.9!'9!;%96'9&!18>!6%3'('.9(!D'9+%0G%0%!/'+:!)%&'()*+40%F|!
RI ?4<%0.('+C!.G!;0.+%3+%6!3)*((!D/.<%9!*0%!9.+!*!<'9.0'+CF!
SI W*3'*))C!A%9'&9!3:*0*3+%0!.G!<43:!(%2!6'(30'<'9*+'.9 !
*
*
.B>?*M<IIB@B9AB:*M8A;@<9B*
A,?=:?89&'(&E8,::4&VW7`^ZC*M>!6'(*A')'+C!'9(40*93%!+:*+!%23)46%(!;0%&9*93'%(I!!=%2!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!:%0%!?NK!&',%9!
:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9CP!.9)C!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!D;0%&9*93C!6.%(9Z+!&%+!:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9CF!
• ?.+!+0%*+%6!*(!6'(;*0*+%!'<;* 3+ #!Q !& 0. 4 ; ( !* 0% !; 0 % & 9 *9+!D/.<%9 F!* 9 6 !9 . + !; 0% & 9 * 9 +!D <%9!*96!/. <%9F!
o -0%6*+%(!Washington(v.(Davis!
o Cf.!FeeneyP!/:%0%!'+!/*(!*+!)%*(+!3. 9 3 % ', * A)%!+:*+!/. <*9!3.4)6 !A % !, % + % 0* 9P!(.!)%((!.G!*!6 '( ; * 0 * + % !
'<;*3+P!A4+!: % 0% P!.9 )C !/ . <%9!3*9!A%!;0% & 9* 9 + !
• H0%99*9!6'((%9+#!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!.9!A*('(!.G!&%96%0!AB3!<%9E.9)C!3.96'+'.9(!&%+!G4))!3.,%0*&%!
• N,%004)%6!AC!M.9&0%((!/'+:!-0%&9*93C!@'(30'<'9*+'.9!>3+P!A4+!M.40+!3*9!(+'))!*;;)C!+:'(!0%*(.9'9&!D+0*'+!
A*(%6!3)*(('G'3*+'.9P!9.+!&%96%0P!%,%9!+:.4&:!.9)C!/.<%9!*0%!*GG%3+%6F!
&
)#"89&'(&N4#,5&VW7`bZC*<*X.0'+C!(%++)%(!.9!'9+%0<%6'*+%!(304+'9C!G.0!RIQ!A%%0!3*(%!D/.<%9!60'9[!*+!LeP!<%9!QLF!
• "9+%0<%6'*+%!(304+'9C #!&%9 %0* )'a*+'.9 !'(!'9!+%9( '.9 !/'+: !1- !
&
R,,5,>3*0*+'.9*)!A*('(!0%,'%/!
• ()';;%0C!().;%!6%9'*)!.G!:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9C#!;*((%6!'9!(;'+%!.GP!9.+!A%3*4(%!.GP!6'(30'<!%GG%3+(!D0*+3:%+'9&!4;!
+:%!(+*96*06!+.!<*[%!'9+%9 +!*!<* )'3%!0%_4 '0%< %9 +F!
• 6'((%9+#!.,%0'93)4(',%P!6'(30'<!;40;.(%!AB3!:*(!%23%;+'.9(!G.0!(%30%+*0'*)!/.0[P!)%((!A406%9(.<%!*)+%09*+',%(!
*,*')*A)%I!
&
A,5,#":&X:,@6#8@&'(&A8:+,#6*VW7`bZC*'9+%0;0% +( !;0 %& 9 * 9 3C !6 '(3 0'<'9*+'.9!+.!G*))!.4 + ('6 %!K '+) %!7 ""Z( !;0 .: 'A '+'. 9 !. G!(%2 !
6'(30'<'9*+'.9!
• LnpeP!M.9&0%((!0%(;.96(!/'+:!-0%&9*93C!@'(30'<'9*+'.9!>3+!+.!6%G'9%!K'+)%!7""Z(!bA%3*4(%!.G!(%2c!+.!'93)46%!
;0%&9*93CP!3:')6A'0+:P!.0!0%)*+%6!<%6'3*)!3.96'+'.9(!
-@>!:*(!9.!'<;*3+!.9!GeduldigP!:./%,%0P!*(!Gilbert(!/*(!(+*+4 +. 0 C P!A 4 + !Geduldig!6%3'6% 6 !. 9 !1 - !& 0 . 4 9 6 ( I!
!
!8@%",:&!(&'(&H454*"&)4=56>*VW7XWZC*(+*+4+.0C!0*;%!)*/!<*[%(!< %9 !*).9%!)'*A)%!G.0!*3+!.G!'9+%03.40(%!/'+:!*!<'9.0!
• <*X.0'+C!.G!X4(+'3%(!D+:.4&:!9. !< * X. 0'+ C!. ; '9 '. 9F !4 (% (!b0% * )!6'GG% 0% 9 3% (c !'9!4 ; : . )6 '9& !(+ * +4 +% !
• >))!:*0<G4)!3.9(%_4%93%(!.G!;0%&9*93C!G*))!+.!&'0)(P!+:%9!'+Z(!X4(+'G'%6I!!-:C('.).&'3*)!6'GG0%93%(!6.!9.+!:*,%!+.!
A%!'&9.0%6!AB3!.G!1-!*96!'9+%0<%6'*+%!(304+'9CI!
o =40,',%(!'9+%0<%6'*+%!(304+'9C!AB3!.G!+*').0'9&P!(4A(+*9+'*))C!0%)*+%6!+.!'<;.0+*9+!&.,Z+!'9+%0%(+!
o @%G%0%93%!+.!&.,Z+P!6'69Z+!*0+'34)*+%!*!)%,%)!.G!(304+'9C!
• 8%*)!6'GG%0%93%(!*))./(!(+%0%.+C;%(!+.!;%0('(+}!!W0%%a'9&!9.0<(I!!H0%99*9P!6'((%9+#!+:'(!'(!*A.4+!G%<*)%!
3:*(+'+C!
&
JH&'(&[8#9858"&VW77bZC*<*X.0'+C!&',%(!<.0%!A'+%!+.!'9+%0<%6'*+%!(304+'9C!D]'9(A40&Z(!.;'9'.9!'(!3).(%0!+.!(+0'3+P!<.0%!
)'[%)C!+.!A%!'9,*)'6*+% 6 !+:* 9 !9. +P!0%*)!6 'GG%0% 9 3%( !3*0 ,% E.4+!&%+(!(<*))%0F!
• H'.).&'3*)!6'GG%0%93%(!0*+'.9*)%d([%;+'3*)P!)'9%!A%+/%%9!9*+40%!*96!34)+40%!'(!'+(%)G!0..+%6!'9!34)+40%!
• 7^"#!<'(('.9!+.!;0.<.+%!3'+'a%9!(.)6'%0(P!*))!<*)%!%9,'0.9<%9+P!<.(+!(;%96'9&!.G!*9C!7>!(3:..)!
o ='9&)%E(%2!(3:..)!*66(!+.!6',%0('+C!.G!%643*+'.9*)!%9,'0.9<%9+!'9!7>!
"<;.0+*9+!0*+'.9* )%P!A4 +!3.4 0+!:. )6(!+.!A% !;0%+%2+!
• >))!<*)%!AB3!.G!:'(+.0CP!9.+!6',%0('+C!
V'))'9&!+.!%9+%0+*'9!('9&)%E(%2!49',%0('+'%(P!A4+!.9)C!'G!6',%0('+C!.G!%643*+'.9!"=!*9!'<;.0+*9+!
&.,%09<%9+!&.*)P!*96!+:%C!:*,%!+.!A%!%_4*)!
N9!9.+'3%!*G+%0!Mississippi(v.(HoganP!*G+%0!G'0(+!0.49 6 !. G!) '+' & * + '. 9 P!3 0 % * + %6!7V"$!
o >6<'++'9&!/.<%9!/.4)6!G.03%!(3:..)!+.!<*[%!3:*9&%(!
>))!/.<%9!3*9Z+!:*96)%!+:%!(3:..)P!X4(+!*(!<%9I!!N9)C!*6<'+!+:.(%!/:.!3*9!
V.<%9!3*9!A%!%643*+%6!,'*!+:%!*6,%0(*+',%!<%+:.6!
$..[!*+!/.<%9!/'+:!+*)%9+!*96!3*;*3'+'%(dI3*9Z+!6%9C!_4*)'G'%6!/.<%9!.9!+:%!A*('(!.G!
.,%0&%9%0*)'a*+'.9(!*A.4+!/.<%9!
• "(!;0.GG%0%6!X4(+'G'3*+'.9!%23%%6 '9& )C!;% 0(4 *(',% I!!H406 %9 !.G!X4(+'G'3*+'. 9!0%( +(!.9 !(+*+%!
o "<;.0+*9+!&.,%09 < % 9+* )!.AX%3 +',%(!
o @'(30'<'9*+.0C!<%*9(!%<;).C%6!*0%!(4A(+*9+'*))C!0%)*+%6!+.!*3:'%,%<%9+!.G!+:.(%!.AX%3+',%(!
• ]'9(A40&#!(+*+%(!M>?!4(%!0%*)!6'GG%0%93%(!*(!*!&0.496!G.0!)%&'()*+'.9!
• 8%:9_4'(+P!6'((%9+#!+:'(!b%23%%6'9&)C!;%0(4*(',%c!(+*96*06!'(!0*+3:%+'9&!4;!'9+%0<%6'*+%!(304+'9C!
• =3*)'*P!6'((%9+#!%)%&'a%(!*!/*C!.G!)'G%P!<*X.0'+C!0%*))C!*;;)C'9&!==!D&.*)!.G!%643*+'.9*)!.AX%3+',%(!/.4)6!A%!<%+!
496%0!'9+%0<%6'*+%!(304+'9CF!
=.3'.).&'3*)!*9*)C('(!.G!M'+*6%)#!;0%(%0,*+'.9!.G!49'_4%)C!G%<'9'9%!<*)%!34)+40%#!A%++%0!+.![%%;!/.<%9!.4+!9.+!(.!<%9!
3*9!A%!<%9P!A4+!(.!<%9!3*9!(%0,%!/.<%9Z(!0.)%(!
&
K9=>,5&'(&\KH&V566WZC*W%6%0*)!'<<'&0*+'.9!(+*+4+%!&0*9+(!3'+'a%9(:';!+.!9.9<*0'+*)!3:')6!.G!3'+'a%9!<.+:%0P!A4+!9.+!.G!
3'+'a%9!0*+:%0P!/:%9!.+:%0!;*0%9+!'(!9.93'+'a%9!
• "9+%0<%6'*+%!(304+'9C #!4; :.)6 !)%&'()*+'. 9!.9 !0%* )!6'GG%0%9 3%(!& 0.4 96 !
o W*+:%0(!:*,%!+.!*GG'0<!;*0%9+:..6P!<.+:%0(!:*,%!3:')6A'0+:!
o >((40%!+:*+!A'.).&'3*)!0%)*+'.9(:';!%2'(+(!
o M:')6!:*(!.;;.0+49'+C!+.!:*,%!3.99%3+'.9!+.!+:%!O=!,'*!;*0%9+!
=+%0%.+C;%#!AC!&','9&!A'0+:!C.4!*0%!3.99%3+%6!+.!3:')6P!*96!9.+!'G!+:%!G*+:%0!
• NZM.99.0!6'((%9+#!+:'(!'(!0..+%6!'9!(+%0%.+C;%P!9.+!0%*)!6'GG%0%93%!
!
?.+%#!;0%&9*93C!'(!+:%!.9)C!b0%*)!6'GG%0%93%c!+:*+!+:%!M.40+!:*(!:%)6!+.!X4(+'GC!6'(30'<'9*+.0C!;.)'3'%(I!
!
1)C#!/.<%9!*0%!<*X.0'+CP!'G!+:%C!6.9Z+!;0.+%3+!+:%<(%),%(!'+!'(!A%3*4(%!+:%C!;)*3%!'+!.9!)./!;0'.0'+C!DHOK!(:.4)69Z+!
G.03%!/.<% 9 !+.!: *, % !+.!, . +% !* ( !*!A).3[!+.!&%+!% _ 4 *) !+0 % *+ <%9+F!
=*<%!*(!(:./'9&!0*3'*)!3)*(('G'3*+'.9#!G*3'*)P!.0!;40;.(%!*96!%GG%3+!
]%96%0!3)*(('G'3*+'.9(!A%9%G'++'9&!/.<%9#!
! ?.+!A*(%6!.9!0.)%!(+%0%.+C;%(!
! M*9!0%<%6C!;*(+!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!
! H'.).&'3*)!b0%*)!6'GG%0%93%(c!.[*C!DMichael(M.P!NguyenP!A4+!+:%(%!3*9!A%!;0 . 2 ' %( !G. 0 !( . 3 '* ) B ( +% 0 % . + C ; % ( F !
*
$=J:;>9;<OB*M=B*-@8AB::C*'9B9=EB@>;BF*.<]L;:*
1-!(4&&%(+(!+:*+!G0%%6.<!'(!)'<'+%6!AC!:*0<!;0'93';)%P!:*(!;0.+%3+%6!;%.;)%!'6%9+'G'%6!AC!3.<<.9!:'(+.0C!*96!
'<<4+*A )%!3 : *0 *3 +% 0'( +'3 (I!
AB3!.G!()';;%0C!().;%P!3.40+!:*(9 Z+!%2 +% 9 6 %6 !(4 (; % 3 +!3)* ( ('G'3 *+ '.9 ( I !
>4+.9.<C!0'&:+(!*0%!9.+!*)/*C(!'9!H.G8#!-0',*3C!D<*00'*&%P!3.9+0*3%;+'.9P!*A.0+'.9P!.A(3%9%!<*+%0'*)!'9!+:%!:.<%P!
%2+%96%6!G*<')'%(P!;*0%9+*)!3.9+0.)P!(%24*)!'9+'<*3CF!
N+:%0(#!,.+%P!+0*,%)P!0%G4(%!<%6'3*)!+0%*+<%9+!
W.0!*)<.(+!*))P!=MNKO=!&',%(!(+0'3+!(304+'9C#!9%3%((*0C!+.!*!3.<;%))'9&!&.,Z+!;40;.(%!
194<%0*+'9&!9%/!0'&:+(#!LF!6%%;)C!0..+%6!'9!+0*6'+'.9(!*96!:'(+.0CP!QF!'<;)'3'+!'9!3.93%;+!.G!.06%0%6!)'A%0+C!
!
@-#!'(!'9+%0G%0%93%!X4(+'G'%6!AC!(4GG'3'%9+!;40;.(%Y!
! "G!)*/!6%9'%(!0'&:+!+.!%,%0C.9 %P!+:% 9!*0& 4 %!@- !
1-#!'(!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!*(!+.!/:.!3*9!%2%03'(%!+:%!0'&:+!X4(+'G'%6!AC!(4GG'3'%9+!;40;.(%!
! "G!)*/!6%9'%6!0'&:+!+.!(.<% P!+:%9 !6'(30'< '9 *+'.9 !49 6% 0!1- !.0!,'. )*+'.9 !.0!0'&: +!49 6%0 !@- !
O96%0!%'+:%0!@-!.0!1-P!3.40+!<4(+!6%3'6%#!
LI "(!+:%0%!*!G496*<%9+* )!0'&:+Y !
*I CaroleneP!6%G%0!+.!)%&'(!49)%((!6'(30' <'9*+'.9!*& * ' 9 ( +!6 ' (3 0 % +% !*96!'9(4)*0 !<'9.0'+CP!.0!'9G0'9&%<%9+!
.G!*!G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+!
AI =+0'3+P!<.6%0*+%P!.0!9.9E.0'&'9*)'(<!
'I ^.6%0*+%#!X46'3'*0C!(:.4)6!'<;)%<%9+!general('9+%9+!.G!W0*<%0 Z(P!9 .+ !(; %3 'G'3 !
3I `'(+.0C!*96!+0*6'+'.9#!'(!'+!6%%;)C!0..+%6!D(;%3'G'3!.0!&%9%0*)!)%,%)!.G!*A(+0*3+'.9YF!
QI "(!+:%!0'&:+!'9G0'9&%6Y!
*I @'0%3+!*96!(4A(+*9+'*)!'9+%0G%0%93%!
AI O93.9(+'+4+'.9*)!3.96'+'.9(!6.3+0'9%#!G.0%&.!*!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)!0'&:+!'9!.06%0!+.!0%3%', % !* !& . ,Z+ !A % 9 % G'+ Y!
RI "(!+:%0%!X4(+'G'3*+'.9!+.!'9G0'9&%Y!
*I W496*<%9+*)!0'&:+#!3.<;%))'9&!'9+%0%(+!
AI ?.9G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+#!)%&'+'<*+%!;40;.(%!
SI "(!+:%!<%*9(!(4GG'3'%9+)C!0%)*+% 6!+.!+:% !;4 0;. (%Y !
*I M*9Z+!*3:'%,%!,'*!*!)%((!0%(+0'3+',%!<%*9(!D3.<;*0%!+.!0*+'.9*)!A*('(P!+:%9!.9)C!b0%*(.9*A)%cF!
*
W496*<%9+*)!0'&:+(!>6X46'3*+'.9!
• 546'3'*0C!9%%6 % 6!/:%0%!.)6!)*/(!. 9!+: % !A. . [ (!*0 %!% 9 +0% 9 3: %6 P!*9 6 !+: %9 !4 (% 6!* & *'9 ( +!'9 6', '6 4 *)( I!
• M.9,%9+'.9*)!<.0*)'+C#!'9+%0%(+!&0.4;(!'9+%0G%0%!/'+:!6%<.30*+'3!;0.3%((P!X46'3'*0CP!:./%,%0P!'(!(4AX%3+',%!
*96!49%)%3+%6!
• 8'&:+(EA*(%6#!*4+.9.<C!*96!%9+'+)%<%9+!.G!%_4*)!0%(;%3+!*96!3.93%09P!;0.+%3+!*&*'9(+!+C0*99C!.G!<*X.0'+C!
o H4+P!1)C#!9.!.AX%3+',%P!49',%0(*)!<.0*)'+C!D+:.4&:P!8*/)(Z!.0'&'9*)!;.('+'.9YF!
o -0*&<*+'3!3:*))%9&%#!X46&%(!<%0%)C!'9+%0;0%+!(+*+4+%(!*(!*0'(+0.30*3C!
!
LochnerE%0*#!;%94<A0*)!0'&:+(!
!,>,#&'(&K,+#"$<"*VW75YZC*,'.)*+%(!@-!+.!;0%,%9+!(+46%9+(!G0.<!'9(+043+'.9!'9!G.0%'&9!)*9&4*&%!49+')!e
+:
!&0*6%!
I8,#@,&'(&H4@8,6>&47&H8$6,#$&VW75_ZC*,'.)*+%(!@-!+.!;0%,%9+!(+46%9+(!G0.<!*++%96'9&!;*0.3:'*)!(3:..)(!
K:%9P!C4'859&'(&[8#9858"3*6%3'6%6!A.+:!.9!1-!D6'(30'<!*&*'9(+!A)*3[(F!*96!@-!D0'&:+!+.!<*00CF!&0.496(!
!
A#8$;4:?&'(&)455,@68@=6*VW7b_ZC*30'<'9*)!;%9*)+ '%( !.9 !4 (% !. G!3. 9 +0* 3 %; + ',% !60 4 & B6 % ,'3 % P!o(!* 0% !6 .3 !*9 6 !6 '0% 3+ .0 !.G!
-)*99%6!-*0%9+:..6!
• 8'&:+!.G!;0',*3C!'(!G496*<%9+*)I!!?.+!@-P!A4+!;*+3:%6!+.&%+:%0!G0.<!.+:%0!><%96(!!
o L>P!R>P!S>P!h>!
;)*3%#!+.!*((%<A)%!D0%)*+'.9*)P!6%3'('.9*)F!
:.<%#!G0%%!G0.<!&.,Z+P!a.9*)!
(%*03:!*96!(%'a40%#!a.9*)!
(%)GE'930'<'9*+ '. 9#!A . 6 C!; 0 ',* 3 CP!* 4 +. 9 . < C !; 0', * 3C !D6 % 3'('. 9 * )F !
o n>!*)(.!0%(%0,%(!0'&:+(!+.!;%.;)%P!%96.0(%(!0%3.&9'+'.9!.G!9%/!0'&:+(!'9!&%9%0*)!
o -%94<A0*(!.,%0)*;!+.!30%*+%!*!;0',*3C!0'&:+!.4+!.G!+%2+4*))C!%94<%0*+%6!0'&:+(!
o =4A(+*9+',%!@-!'9!;%0(.9*)!0'&:+(P!6'(+'93+!G0.<!%3.9.<'3!0'&:+(!
• K:0%%!*0%*(!.G!;0',*3C!
o v.9*)!
o 8%)*+'.9*)!
o @%3'('.9*)!D;%0(.9*)!*4+.9.<CF!
@%3'('.9*)!4)+'<*+%)C!(4A(4<%(!+:%!.+:%0!Q!
H.+:!a.9*)!*96!0%)*+'.9*)!*0%!)'<'+'9&!;0'93';)%(!.9!+:%!(+*+%P!3.930%+%!%2*<;)%(!.G!
G496*<%9 +* )!6% 3'('. 9 * )!;0 ',* 3C!
o `%0%P!a.9*)!DA%60..<F!*96!0%)*+'.9*)!D<*0'+*)F!*0%!'<;)'3*+%6!D?NK!6%3'('.9*)F!
• M.93400%93%(#!!
o n>!*4+:.0'+C!G.0!9.9+%2+4*)!0'&:+(!DV*00%9BH0%99*9F!
o )'A%0+C!496%0!@- !3)*4 (% !D` *0 )*9 F!b'< ; )'3'+!'9 !3.9 3% ;+ !.G!.0 6% 0%6 ! )'A %0+C c!
o G*')(!0*+'.9*)!A*( '(!DV:'+%F!%96!'(!+.!(+.; !'))'3 '+!0%)* +'. 9 (: '; (P!(. !; 0%, %9 + '9& !<*00'%6!3.4;)%( !G0.<!
4('9&!3.9+0*3%;+',%(!'(!490%)*+%6!
• @'((%9+#!+%2+4*))C!*A(%9+P!9.!;0',*3C!0'&:+!DH)*3[B=+%/*0+F!
=%%!`*0)*9Z(!6'((%9+!'9!Poe(v.(Ullman:!@-!9.+!*A . 4 +!; 0 . 3% 6 4 0 * )!; 0 . +% 3 +'. 9 ( !; . ( +!: . 3 P!A 4 +!* & * '9 ( +!* 0 A '+ 0* 0 C !)% &' ()* + '. 9 P!
*96!9.+!)'<'+%6!+.!%94<%0*+%6!0'&:+(!
!
X8$,5$6"?6&'(&N"8#?&VW7`5ZC!1-#!%2+%96(!0'&:+!+.!3.9+0*3%;+'.9!+.!49<*00'%6!3.4;)%(!
• @%3'('.9*)!;0',*3C#!0'&:+!.G!'96','64*)!+.!A%!G0%%!G0.<!49/*00*9+%6!&.,Z+!'9+04('.9!'9+.!;%0(.9*)!<*++%0(!
DH0%99*9Fd9.!)%&'+'<* +%!&., %09< % 9+!;4 0;.( %!:%0% !
• O9%94<%0*+%6P!9.+!3.9('6%0%6!AC!W0*<%0(P!A4+!(+'))!;0.+%3+%6!
• V%)G*0%!%9+'+)%<%9+!;*0*))%)#!9.+!%9+'+)%6!+.!/%)G*0%P!A4+!&.,Z+!<4(+!6'(+0'A4+%!'9!%,%9!:*96I!
o "G!<*00'%6!;%0(.9(!:*,%!0'&:+P!+:%9!49<*00'%6!;%0(.9(!<4(+!:*,%!(*<%!
o =*<%!0%*(.9'9&!G.0!<.(+!*4+.9.<C!0'&:+(!
!
!
!
M4,&'(&Q"?,&VW7`YZC*KJ!(+*+4+%!;0.:'A'+(!;0.340'9&!*A.0+'.9!%23%;+!G.0!(*,'9&!)'G%I!
• @.3+0'9*)!&0.496#!GriswoldI!!^*9%4,%0 '9 &!*0.496!LochnerI!!]% +( !0 '6 !. G !;%94<A0*!*0&4<%9+P!;4+(!'+!496%0!@-!
o ].,%09<%9+!3*9Z+!;0.:'A'+P!0%&4)*+'.9!<4(+!<%%+!(+0'3+!(304+'9C!
H*)*93%!(+*+%Z(!'9+%0%(+!'9!G%+4(!*96!/.<*9Z(!G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+!+.!*A.0+'.9!
• 8%X%3+%6!(+*+%!3)*'<(!+.!'9+%0%(+!'9!;0%9*+*)!)'G%P!G%+4(!9.+!*!;%0(.9!G.0!LS>!
o "9+0*+%2+4*)#!'9!M.9(+'+4+'.9#!b;%0(.9(!A. 09!.0!9*+4 0*)'a%6 cP!A'0+:!'(!6%G'9'9&!< .< % 9+!
o @.6&%(!_4%(+'.9!AC!G.34('9&!.9!,'*A')'+CP!9.+!)'G%!D)./%0!;.)'+'3*)!+%<;%0*+40%F!
• H)*3[<49#!Le;!:'(+.0'3*)!*9*)C('(!.G!*A.0+'.9!
o 1+:.(#!:'(+.0C!(:./(!*!A0.*6%0!%+:.(!+:*9!;0%(%9+!6*C!
o @.3+.0(!*(!6%3'('.9!<*[%0(!DA4+!+:'(!(+'))!+*[%(!/.<%9!.4+!.G!%_4*+'.9F!
• =+*+%!'9+%0%(+(#!:%*)+:!.G!<.+:%0P!;.+%9+'*)!)'G%!.G!G%+4(!
o K%<;%0%6!AC!/.<%9Z(!)'A%0+C!*96!_4%(+'.9!.G!/:%9!)'G%!A%&'9(!
• K8"^1=K18!W8>^1VN8k!
o L
(+
#!/.<*9!'9 !3 . 9 (4 )+ * +'. 9 !/'+:!;:C('3'*9!D.9)C!0%&4)*+%!+:%!(*<%!G.0!*9C!.+:%0!<%6'3*)!;0.3%640%F!
0'([!.4+/%'&:%6!AC!0'([!.G!;0%&9*93C!
0'([!6%30%*(%(!/B<%6'3*)!*6,*93% (P!A4+!,'*A')'+C!*)(.!&%+(!%*0)'%0!
o Q
96
#!(+*+%!3*9!0%& 4 )* + %P!A 4 + !.9 ) C!* A . 0+ '. 9 (!+ : *+ !* 0% !4 9 6 % 0+* [ % 9 !G. 0!: % * )+ : !.G !<.+:%0!
o R
06
#!&.,%09<% 9 + !<*C!;0.:'A'+!% 23 % ; +!G. 0 !+: % !)'G% B : % *) +: !. G!<.+:%0!
• @'((%9+#!+:'(!(:.4)6!:*,%!A%%9!)%G+!+.!)%&'()*+40%!
o 8%:9_4'(+#!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!0%,'%/!*!)*!Lee(OpticalP!*A.0+'.9!9. + !G4 96*<%9+* )!
o See!NZM.99.0 Z(!6 '( ( %9+!'9!City(of(Akron(v.(Akron(Center(for(Reproductive(Health!DLneRF#!+0'<%(+%0!
G0*<%/.0[ !'(!4 9 (. 4 9 6P!(3 '%9 3% !3: *9 & % (!*9 6 !< . , %( !+:% !)'9% (!
o 7'*A')'+C!'+(%)G!'(!*0A'+0*0CP!3.40+!X4(+!(['0+'9&!+:%!_4%(+'.9!.G!/:%9!)'G%!D*96!+:%0%G.0%!(+*+%Z(!'9+%0%(+F!
A%&'9(!
M.<;*9'.9!3*(%!DoeP!]>!)*/!/B!%2 3 % ; + '. 9(!G.0!)'G%B:%*)+:!.G!<.+:%0P!G%+*)!6%G%3+P!.0!0*;%!
o O93.9(+'+4+'.9*)!+.!0%&4)*+%!'9!L
(+
!+0'<%(+%0P!3 % 0+ 'G'3 * +'.9!(+*96*06 (!+ . . !: '& : P!4 9 6 4 )C !0 % (+ 0'3 +' ,% !' 9 !0% _ 4 '0 '9 & !
;%0<'(('.9!*96!Q!6.3+.0(P!493.9(+'+4+'.9*)!496%0!-U"!+.!0%(+0'3+!+.!(+*+%!0%('6%9+(!
o @.4&)*(P!3.93400'9&#!n>!6.%(!0%3.&9'a%!%2'(+%93%!.G!LS>!)'A%0+'%(d!
o >4+.9.<.4(!3.9+0.)!.,%0!6%,%).;<%9+!*96!%2;0%(('.9!.G!;%0(.9:..6!
o >4+.9.<C!.G!3:.'3%!'9!A*('3!6%3'('.9(!D(4AX%3+!+.!A*('3!0%&4)*+'.9!/:%0%!9*00./)C!+*').0%6dF!
o >4+.9.<C!.G!;:C('3*)!A.6C!D(4AX%3+!+.!(*<%F!
M.00%3+)C!6%3'6%6Y!
! ?.+!9*00./)C!+*').0%6P!0%*6(!)'[%!)%&'()*+'.9!
! =+0'3+!(304+'9C!*;;)'%6!0'&.0.4()CP!A%++%0!*9!1-!3*(%!+:.4&:P!*(!=4A(+*9+',%!@-!<.0%!(4AX%3+!+.!6%A*+%!
! K'%6!+.!<%6'3*)B(.3'.).&'3*)!6*+*P!0'([!.G!6%A49['9&!+:%!3.40+!D*,.'6%6!+:'(!+*3+'3P!49)'[%!BrownF!
! 1)C#!9.P!(4;%0;0.+%3+%6!0'&:+!3*9Z+!A%!'9G%00%6!G0.<!M.9(+'+4+'.9P!+:'(!'(9Z+!*!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)!_4%(+'.9!
! ! H4+P!.+:%0!*0%*(!.G!G*<')C!)*/!*0%Y!
! K0'A%#!)'A%0C!'(!;%0(.9*)!*4+.9.<C!*96!'96%;%96%93%!*96!*GG.06%6!@-!
M.40+P!'9!%,*)4*+'9&!(+*+%Z(!'9+%0%(+!'9!)'G%!.G!G%+4(P!*((4<%(!A'.).&C!{!)*/P!*0A'+0*0'9%((!.G!b,'*A')'+Cc!.0!
+0'<%(+%0!'9!+0'&&%0'9&!(+*+%(Z!'9+%0%(+!'9!)'G%!
^*3k'99.9#!+:'(!'(!*9!1-!;0.A)%<P!&%96%0!'9%_4*)'+C!.G!G.03%6!<.+:%0:..6!DA4+!1-!*9*)C('(!/.4)6!A%!+:%!
(*<%F!
-.)'+'3*)!<'(+*[%#!;0.,.[%6!0%(+0'3+',%!(+*+%!;.)'3'%(!*96!0'&:+!+.!)',%!<.,%<%9+P!G0.a%!)'A%0*)!0%G.0<!
!
RoeP!@-P!9.+!1- #!
-0%&9*93C!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!(%;*0*+%6!G0.<!&%96%0!6'(30'<!*G+%0!Feeney,(GeduldigI!
-0.;.9%9+(!*0%!<%6'3*)!;0.G%(('.9!*96!&0.4;(!)'[%!-)*99%6!-*0%9+:..6I!
!
1-!A%++%0Y!]%96%0EA*(%6P!G.03'9&!/.<%9!+.!A%*0!3:')60%9P!G.0%3).('9&!%3.9.<'3!.;;.0+49'+'%(I!
N0P!=4A@-P!)%,%)!.G!&%9%0*)'+C!(:.4)6!:*,%!A%%9!*+!A.6')CB6%3'('.9*)!*4+.9.<C!*96!;0',*3C!
!
-.(+[Roe#!
=+*+%!G496'9&!9%,%0!<*96*+%6P!;4A)'3!:.(;'+*)(!9.+!0%_4'0%6!+.!;0.,'6%I!
"9G.0<%6!3.9(%9 +P!A'.).& '3*)!G*+: %0!9. +'G'3*+'.9 P!;* 0%9 +*)!3.9 (%9 +!/ B. !X46 '3'*)!AC ;* ((#!(+043 [!6. / 9!
8%;4A)'3*9!;*0+C!*96!M:0'(+'*9!0'&:+!*)'&9<%9+P!M.40+!9.<'9*+'.9(!
!
!
*
(J8@;<89*>9F*H6"#,&G,@8$8$&
I:"55,?&I"#,56%44?&47&H4=6%,"$6,#5&I,55$>:'"58"&'(&)"$,>&VW775ZC*4;:.)6(!RoeP!.4+)'9%(!stare(decisis(
• 5.'9+!.;'9'.9!* A * 9 6 . 9 (!+ 0' <%(+%0!G0*<% /.0[B(+0'3+!(304+'9C!'9!G*,.0!.G!,'*A')'+C!*96!b4964%!A406%9c!+%(+!
o O964%!A406%9!.9)C!G.0!;0%E,'*A')'+CP!*G+%0!+:*+!(+*+%!3*9!0%&4)*+%!/BG0%%0!0%'9!
o M.93400%93%(P!/.4)6!:*,%!4;:%)6!+0'<%(+%0!G0*<%/.0[!
o ^*'9!+:04(+!.G!Roe(4;:%)6P!*A.0+'.9!'(!*!G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+!
• >;;)C'9&!+:*+!+%(+P!30%*+%(!<*X.0'+'%(!+.!4;:.)6!<.(+!.G!+:%!;0.,'('.9!'9!+:%!(+*+4+%!
• 5.'9+!.;'9'.9#!R !X4( +'3% (!/0'+%!+.&%+:%0!/B . !3)* 0'GC '9 & !/ : '3: !/ * (!+: %!* 4 +: .0 I!!
• ?%/!A'9*0C!04)%!
o -0%E,'*A')'+CP!(+*+%!3*9!0%&4)*+%!N?$\!"W!6.%(!9.+!;)*3%!4964%!A406%9!
o -.(+E,'*A')'+CP!(+*+%!3*9!0%&4)*+%!*96!;0.(30'A%!+.!;0.<.+%!'9+%0%(+!'9!)'G%!.G!G%+4(P!*(!).9&!*(!'+!:*(!
%23%;+'.9(!+.!;0%(%0,%!)'G%!*96!:%*)+:!.G!<.+:%0!
• Roe’s!+/.!'9+%0%(+(#!<.+:%0BG%+4(!
o `%*)+:!.G!<.+:%0!['3[(!'9!*G+%0!L
(+
!+0'<%(+%0!'9!Roed+:'(!&%+(!)*+%0!*96!)*+%0!
o $'G%!.G!G%+4(#!['3[(!'9!*+!Q
96
!+0'<%(+%0P!A4+!/'))!&%+!%* 0) '% 0!* 9 6 !% * 0 )'% 0!
• O964%!A406%9!'(!9%/!/*C!+.!0%3.93')%!(+*+%!'9+%0%(+!*96!/.<*9Z(!)'A%0+C!D6.%(!9.+!&%+!<*X.0'+C!49+')!
StenbergF!
o K%(+!3.9G)*+%(!_4%(+'.9(!.G!'9G0'9&%<%9+P!(4GG'3'%9+!;40;.(%P!*96!<%*9(B%96!+*').0'9&!
?.!)%,%)!.G!(304+'9C!D(+0'3+P!'9+%0<%6'*+%F!(+*+%6!
b(4A(+*9+'*)!.A(+*3)%c#!3*9!*3+!/B'9+%9+!+.!6'(3.40*&%P!A4+!4964%!A4 06%9 !.9)C!'G!'+!/'))!
prevent!/.<*9!G0.<!&%++'9&!
`%0%P!(;.4(*)!9.+'G'3*+'.9!"=!4964%!A406%9P!/.4)6!;0%,%9+!<*9C!/.<%9!G0.<!&%++'9&!+:%<!
AB3!.G!*A4(%!
QS!:.40!/*'+'9&!;%0'.6P!:./%,%0P!'(!?NK!4964%!A406%9!
• =3*)'*P!6'((%9+#!;.)'+'3*)!6%A*+%!(:.4)6!0%<*'9!'9!;.)'+C!
o K0*9()*+'9&!<.0*)!*0&4<%9+(!'9+.!+:%!0%*)<!.G!G*3+!:*(!3..)'9&!%GG%3+P!A4+!*)(.!;*;%0(!.,%0!+:%!:%*0+!
.G!+:%!6'(*&0%%<%9+I!
!
!
5.'9+!.;'9'.9!
DNZM.99.0P!
=.4+%0P!k%99%6CF!
=+%,%9(!
H)*3[<49!
8%:9_4'(+!D/'+:!
V:'+%P!=3*)'*P!
K:.<*(F!
8%(4)+!
"9G.0<%6!3.9(%9+!
7*)'6!
"9,*)'6!D+:.4&:!
'9G.!*A.4+!0'([(!
.G!*A.0+'.9!,*)'6F!
"9,*)'6!
7*)'6!
7*)'6!
^'9.0(!<4(+!A%+!
'9G.0<%6!3.9(%9+!.G!
;*0%9+!
7*)'6!
"9,*)'6!
"9,*)'6!
7*)'6!
7*)'6!
^*00'%6!/.<*9!
<4(+!9.+'GC!(;.4(%!
"9,*)'6!
"9,*)'6!
"9,*)'6!
7*)'6!
&9O>?<F*
8%_4'0%<%9+(!*A.,%!
/*',%6!G.0!<%6'3*)!
%<%0&%93C!
7*)'6!
7*)'6!
"9,*)'6!
7*)'6!
7*)'6!
8%;.0+'9&!
0%_4'0%<%9+(!
7*)'6!
7*)'6!
"9,*)'6!
7*)'6!
7*)'6!
!
• =+*0%!@%3'('(#!G.40!prudential(and(pragmatic(3.9('6%0*+'.9(!!
LI V.0[*A')'+C!
*I NG!3.9(+'+4+'.9*)!04)%!'9!3:*))%9&%6!;0%3%6%9+P!9.+!+:%!(+*+4+%!*+!:*96!
AI O9/.0[*A)%!04)%(!+%96!+.!A%!b+..!,*&4%c!
QI 8%)'*93%!
*I K0*6'+'.9*))C!'9!3.<<%03'*)!3.9+%2+!
AI -0%3%6%9+(!A%++%0!+.!A%!.,%004)%6!_4'3[)C!D'9!+%9('.9!/'+:!,*3'))*+'.9F!
3I =:'G+!G0.<!%3.9.<'3!+.!9.9G49&'A)%!;%0(.9*)!0%*)<!
'I -0.A)%<*+'3#!'(!'+!*!(+0%+3:!+:*+!/.<%9!(+043+40%!+:%'0!)',%(!*0.496!*,*')*A')'+C!
.G!*A.0+'.9( Y!
RI M:*9&%!'[email protected]+0'9%!
*I $'[%)C!+.!.,%004)%!/:%9!;0%3%6%9+!'(!wA*0%!0%<9*9+!.G!*A*96.9%6!6.30+'9%Z!
AI -0%3%6%9+(!496%0<'9%6!'930%<%9+*))C!AC!3:';;'9&!*/*C!
SI M:*9&%!'9!W*3+(P!.0!'9!-%03%;+'.9(!.G!W*3+(!D(%%<(!)'[%!+:'(!'(!*+!;)*C!'9!Casey…F!
*I >3+4*)!3:*9&%(P!)'[%!<%6'3 * )!+ % 3 : 9 . ) . & C P!. 0 !; % 0 3 % ; + '. 9 ( !
AI V:*+%,%0!+:%!(.3'.).&'3*)!496%0(+*96'9&!.G!+:%!6*CP!Plessy!/*(!/0.9&!/:%9!'+!/*(!
6%3'6%6!
3I M.49+%0<*X.0'+*0'*9!;0.A)%<Y!
• ?.+!*9!%)%<%9+(!.0!G*3+.0(!+%(+P!A4+!)'(+!.G!3.9('6%0*+'.9(!
• M.<;.0+(!/'+:!.+:%0!G*<.4(!0%,%0(*)(#!West(Coast(Hotel!*96!Lochnerm!Brown!*96!Plessy!
• V:%0%!M.40+!(:.4)6!A%!3*0%G4)!*A.4+!.,%0+409'9&!
o >9+'E,*3'))*+'.9!D+..!_4'3[)CF!
o -.)'+'3*)!G'0%!D;0.<.+'9&!)'+<4(!+%(+!A%:*,'.0P!X46'3'*)!'9+%&0'+C!;0%,%9+(!G0.<!04)'9&!.9!;.)'+'3*)!
;0%G%0%93%(P!0*+:%0P!4;:.)6!(+*0%!6%3'('(F!
• 8%:9_4'(+!6'((%9+#!.)6!(+*0%!6%3'('(#!.9)C!3.00%3+!;..0!0%*(.9'9&P!.9)C!><%96<%9+!3*9!3.00%3+!+:%!M.40+!
o ^*X.0'+C!'(!0%*))C!X4(+!3.93%6'9&!+:*+!Roe!/*(!/0.9 & !* 9 6 !( 4 A ( +'+ 4 +'9 & !* 9 !4 9 6 4 % !A 4 0 6 % 9 !+% ( + !
• =3*)'*!6'((%9+#!9.!0'&:+!+.!*A.0+'.9P!'00%)%,*9+!0:%+.0'3!/.4)6!%_4*))C!(4;;.0+!G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+!+.!;.)C&*<CP!
(4'3'6%P!'93%(+P!U3!
!
H6,5+,#9&'(&)"#%"#6*V5666ZC*(+*+4+%!;0.:'A'+(!;*0+'*)!A'0+:!*A.0+'.9!49)%((!G.0!)'G%!.G!<.+:%0P!6%G'9%(!*(!6%)',%0'9&!*!
)','9&!49A.09P!.0!(4A (+ *9 +'*)!; .0 +'.9 !+:% 0% .G!A %G.0%!['))'9&!+:%!3:')6I!!@.%(9Z+!6'(+'9&4'(:!A%+/%%9!@U1!*96!@UJI!!
=+043[!6./9I!
>A.0+'.9(#!nfz!'9!L
(+
!+0'<%(+%0P!, * 3 4 4 <!*(;'0*+'.9I!!L f z!'9!Q
96
!+0'<%(+%0P!@U1!.0!@U J!
@U1#!6')*+%P!0%<.,%!*96!(30*;%! @UJ#!G%+*)!([4))!+..!)*0&%P!;4))!.4+!A.6C!+:%9!304(:!([4))!*96!0%<.,%!
$%&'()*+'.9!60',%(!*!/%6&%!A%+/%%9!Q!;0.3%640%(I!!"9+*3+!@U1!;0%G%00%6P!*33I!@0I!M*0:*0+!
Casey(*9*)C('(#!
• ?.!6'(+'93+'.9!A%+/%%9!;0%B;.(+!,'*A')'+C!
• ?.!6'(+'93+'.9!A%+/%%9!@U1!*96!@UJ!
o -0.:'A'+%6!9.0<*)!;0.3%640%!+:*+!/*(!(*G%0!+:*9!+:%!*))./%6!.9%(P!(:.4)6!*))./!+ . !;0.+%3+!:%* )+ : !
o @.3!3*9Z+![9./!'G!@U1!/.4)6!:*,%!+.!A%!@UJ!
• ?.!%23%;+'.9!G.0!health!.G!<.+:%0!
NZM.99.0Z(!3.93400%93%#!(%96!('&9*)!+.!)%&'(!+:*+!A*9(!<4(+!A%!9*00./%0!
]'9(A40&Z(!3.93400%93%#!(+*+%!+0C'9&!+.!3:';!*/*C!*+!RoeP!*!)*!Casey!*9*)C('(!0%#!*A*96.9%6!6.3+0'9%!
K:.<*(Z(!6'((%9+#!(+*+%!(:.4)6!A%!*A)%!+.!0%&4)*+%!*!;0.3%640%!+:*9!<*9C!,'%/!*(!'9G*9+'3'6%!
! !
A45U":,$&'(&)"#%"#6*V566`ZC*4;:.)6(!(+*+4+%P!6'(+'9&4'(:!G0.<!Stenberg!.9!;0.3%640*)!6'(+' 9 3+ '. 9 !
8%(;%3+!G.0!:4<*9!)'G%!*96!A.96 !. G!) .,%P!(.<%!/.<%9!0%&0%+!3:.'3%!+.!*A.0+I!!N,%0A0.*6!=+%0%.+C;%(}!
W*3'*)!,%0(4(!*(E*;;)'%6!3:*))%9&%(#!3*9Z+!/*'+!G.0!*;;)'3*+'.9!AB3!.G!&%(+*+'.9!{!)'+'&*+'.9I!!!
M:';(!*/*C!*+!RoeP!<*['9&!Casey’s!A*0%!0%<9 * 9 + !+* 3 +'3 Y !
*
*
QU=>?*-@8;BA;<89C*$BS=>?*"@<B9;> ;<8 9 *> 9F*-@<O>AK*
N4;,#$&'(&F"#?;8@<&VW7XbZC*]>!(+*+4+%!A * 9 (!( . 6 . <C!0%&*06)% (( !. G!( %2I!!M.40+!4;:. ) 6 (!* & * '9 ( +!@-!3:*))%9&% !
• -0%,!0'&:+(!*0%!G*<')CB;0.30%*+'.9#!:.<.(%24*)!*3+','+C!6.%(9Z+!G'+!
o ?.!G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+#!9%'+:%0!b'<;)'3'+!'9!3.93%;+!.G!.06%0%6!)'A%0+Cc!9.0!b6%%;)C!0..+%6!'9!:'(+.0C!
*96!+0*6'+'.9c!
• `*)G!+:%!(+*+%(!*+!+:%!+'<%!:*,%!(.6.<C!(+*+4+%(P!A4+!0*0%)C!%9G.03%6I!!!
o `*0<!.G!49%9G.03%6!(+*+4+%#!6%9'*)!.G!%9+'+)%<%9+(!'G!30'<'9*)!0%3.06!
o 12IP!H./%0(!:'<(%)G!G'0%6!*!(+*GG!*++C!AB3!:%!/*(!3.<<'++%6!&*CP!*96!;0%(4<;+',%)C!%9&*&'9&!'9!
(.6.<C!
• 8*+'.9*)!A*('(!0%,'%/d(+*+4(!30%*+%6!AC!(+*+4+%!
• M:.(%!?NK!+.!3.<A'9%!/'+:!(%2EA*(%6!(+*+4+%!3*(%!
o "G!C.4!&.!1-!G.0!&*C(P!:*,%!+. !*0&4 %!G.0!* !0'&:+!
o "G!C.4!&.!.9!;0',*3C!&0. 49 6(P!+:% 9!*))!;% .; )%!:* ,%!+:% !0'&:+!D] > !(+*+4 +%!/ *(!<.0%!'93)4(',%F!
• 8'&:+!+.!;0',*3C!&0.496(!.4+P!6%(;'+%!a.9*)!D:.<%F!*96!6%3'('.9*)!;0',*3C!D'9+'<*+%F!
o L>!3*(%P!Stanley(v.(GAP!;0',*3C!'9!:.<%P!6'(+'9 & 4 ' (:%6!AB3!.G!3. 9(+'+4+'.9* )!<..0'9&(!
• -./%))P!3.93400'9&P!e>!3)*'<!AB3!;49'(:<%9+!+..!<43:!
• H)*3[<49!%+!*)IP!6'((%9+'9&#!<'('6 % 9 +' G'% 6 !)% , % )!. G!& % 9 % 0* )'+ C P!(: . 4 ) 6 !A % !0' &: + !+. !A%!)%G+!*).9%!
o @%3'('.9*)!*4+.9.<CP!'I%IP!(%24*)!'9+'<*3C!
o =;*+'*)!*4+.9.<CP!S>!;0.,'6%(!
o "G!==!:*6!A%%9!*;;)'%6P!&. ,Z+!'9+%0% (+(!*0% !9.+!3. < ; %))'9& #!9.!:* a*0 6(!+.!6 %3%9 +!(.3 '%+C !
!
Amanda Bakale 4/30/09 5:52 PM
Comment: (%%!;;+!
@'(+'9&4'(:!*64)+%0C!*96!'93%(+#!(%24*)!*4+.9.<CP!%(;!/'+:'9!:.<%P!+:.(%!;0.:'A'+'.9(!*0%!*)(.!0..+%6!'9!+0*6'+'.9(!
*96!:'(+.0CI!!M*9Z+!A%!4;:%)6!*(!*!<*++%0!.G!;0'93';)%I!
M.))%3+',%!*3+'.9!;0.A)%<#!'+Z(!9.+!'<<4+*A)%P!;%0:*;(P!A4+!3*9!A%!:'66%9P!3.<'9&!.4+!+.!X.'9!(.3'*)!<.,%<%9+!'9340(!
3.(+(!D<*CA%!9.+!(.!<43:!*9C<.0%P!&%++'9&!A%++%0YF!
&
M4*,#&'(&X'"5$*VW77bZC*MN!;*((%(!*<%96<%9+!+.!(+*+%!3.9(+'+4+'.9!+:*+!+:%0%!/'))!A%!9.!;0.+%3+%6!(+*+4(!G.0!(%24*)!
.0'%9+*+'.9!
• ?.!:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9CP!A4+!;0%,%9+(!(+*+%!G0.<!%2%03'('9&!6%('0%!+.!:*0<!*!;.)'+'3*))C!49;.;4)*0!&0.4;!
• 8*+'.9*)!A*('(!0%,'%/#!MN!'<;.(%(!(;%3'*)!6'(*A')'+CP!%2;)*'9%6!.9)C!AC!*9'<4(!
• M.40+!6.%(!9.+!+*[%!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!0%*(.9(!*+!G*3%!,*)4%P!%2:*4(+%6!%,%0C!0*+'.9*)%!%23%;+!*9'<4(!
• 8*+'.9*)!A*('(!/'+:!A'+%#!9.!)%&'+!;40;.(%!.+:%0!+:*9!%23)46'9&!*!&0.4;!G0.<!;.)'+'3*)!;0.3%((!D;'%03%!+:%!,%')F!
o =:'G+!'9!;4A)'3Z(!'6%.).&C#!/:*+!/*(!.93%!0*+'.9*)P!'(!9./!*9'<4(!
o >9'<4(!;0%(%9+%6!*(!b<.0*)c!A*('(!G.0!)*/!'(9Z+!0*+'.9*)!
• @'((%9+P!=3*)'*P!8%:9_4'(+P!K:.<*(#!;4A)'3!<.0*)(!3*9!A%!)%&'+!'9+%0%(+P!M.40+!(:.4)69Z+!(+0'[%!6./9!
<*X.0'+*0'*9!A%)'%G!D*9'<4(!9.+!493.9(+'+4+'.9*)F!
!
C";#,5@,&'(&W,Y"$*V566YZC*%_4*)'+C!3*(%#!(+0*'&:+!3*9!%9&*&%!'9!(.6.<C!A4+!9.+!&*C(!
• -0',*3C#!a.9*)P!0%)*+'.9*)P!6%3'('.9*)#!G496*<%9+*)!+.!;%0(.9:..6!
o K0*3%!=4A@-!)*/!G 0. <!GriswoldP!G'96!+:*+!6%3'('. 9*)!*96!(;* +' * )!* 4+.9.<C!( 4 &&%(+!+:*+!Bowers(/*(!
3.49+%0E6.3+0'9*)!
Bowers!6.%(!0%*)!*96 !( C<A.)'3!:*0<P!A0.*6!)'A% 0 +C !; 0. + % 3+ '. 9 !4 9 6 % 0 !=4A@-!
o >9'<4(!:*(!*93'%9+!0..+(P!*9+'E(.6.<C!(+*+4+%(!*0%!G*'0)C!<.6%09!
o ^*X.0'+C!<*C!9.+!%9G.03 % !* 9 '<4(!,'*!(+*+% !
o M.9+0.,%0('*)!*;;%*)!+.!'9+%09*+'.9*)!)*/!
• W.34(%6!.9!;0',*3C!*96!@-P!9.+!1-P!6'69Z+!*0+'34)*+%!*!)%,%)!.G!(304+'9C!
• NZM.99.0!'(!+:%!.9)C!X4(+'3%!+.!*0&4%!.9!%_4*)'+C!&0.496(P!'9!3.93400%93%!
• 1((%9+'*)!;*0+!.G!&*C!'6%9+'+CP!<'(*;;0%:%96!*!)*0&%!; *0 +!. G!(. 3'% +C !A C!)% ++ '9 &!G% 6 !3. 4 0+( !+% ))!&* C (!/:*+!6%G'9%(!
+:%<!*(!*!(.3'*)!&0.4;!D;0.&0%((',% !30'+'_4%!.G!)'A%0*)!*0&4 < %9 +(F !
• =3*)'*P!6'((%9+#!6'3+*!.G!'9+%09*+'.9*)!(:.4)6!A%!'&9.0%6P!)%+!4(!<*[%!.40!./9!<'(+*[%(!
o N+:%0!(%24*)!*3+','+'%(!G496*<%9+*) !+. !;% 0( .9 : . . 6Y !!=% )% 3+ ',% !%9 6 !. G!< . 0* )( !)%& '()* + '.9 I!
o 8%,%0(*)!496%0!G'0%P!9.+!*!&..6!/*C!+.!.,%0+409!;0%3%6%9+!496%0(CaseyI!
• @'6!?NK!'6%9+'GC!*(!*!G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+!.0!*0+'34)*+%!*!)%,%)!.0!(304+'9C!
o ^.0*)!X46&<%9+!'(!4(4*))C!%9.4&:!+.!;*((!0*+'.9*)!A*('(P!(.!*((4<%!3.40+!:%0%!'9+%96%6!G.0!(.<%!
['96!.G!:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9C!
*
Q-*>9F*:BS=>?*8@<B9;>;<89*>I;B@*C";#,5@,*
1-!*96!=4A@-!*0%!*9*)C+'3*))C!6'(+'93+!D3.9643+B(+*+4(!6'(+'93+'.9F!
• M.9643+!'(!;%0<'(('A)%!*96!%'+:%0!*F!(+*+4(!&%+(!0*+'.9*)!A*('(P!+04(+!;.)'+'3*)!;0. 3% ( ( !. 0!A F !; . /%0)%((9%((!
0*+'.9*)%!6.%(9Z+!3.9+0.)!
• 1,%9+4*))CP!<*CA%!Lawrence!/'))!)%*6!+.!0% 3 . & 9 '+'. 9 !.G!(%24*)!.0'% 9 +* +' . 9 !*( !* !( 4 (; % 3 +!3 )* (( !
o "G!0%)*+'.9(:';(!;0.+%3+%6P!+:%9 !(+*+4 (!3*9 Z+!A%!A 406 %9 %6 !
"G!(+*+4(!'(!A406%9%6!49X4 (+)CP!3* 9!3.40+!'9+%0,%9%!
o @%)*C!0%3.&9'+'.9Y!!M.40+Z(!;.)'+'3*)!*3+'.9*(!*0%!%9.4&:!+.!;0.+%3+!*3+','+C!'9!;0',*+%P!3*9Z+!.4+)*/!
<.0*)!6'(*;;0.,*)!
M.9(+'+4+'.9*)!G.0<!.G!3).(%+'9&!
`.<.(%24*)(!(:.4)6!*,.'6!;*0*6'&<!.G!0*3%P!(%%[!49'_4%!3',')!0'&:+(!<.,%<%9+!
*
@'(30'<'9*+'.9!:*(!40&%6!<4+'9&!.G!:.<.( % 2 4 * )'+C !'9 !* !, * 0 '% +C !. G!G. 0 <(P!/%*[%9 '9 & !/'+:!0'(%!.G!&*C !3',')!0'&:+(!
<.,%<%9+(I!
! M.9,%0('.9#!>->!3)*(('G'%6!;*+:.).&C!49+')!LnpR!
! -*(('9&!6%<*96(#!&*C(!0%<*'9!3).(%+%6P!@>@K!
! M.,%0'9&!6%<*96(#!+.9%!6./9!(+'&<*+'a%6!'6%9+'+C!3:*0*3+%0'(+'3(!D*;;%*0*93%P!A%:*,'.0P!*GG')'*+'.9P!*3+','(<P!
*((.3'*+'.9#!A4+!*)(.P!;0%((40%!+.!(4A(4<%!'96','64*)!+0*'+(!+.!b+0*'+(c!.G!&0.4;!;.)'+'3(YF!
!
*
*
*
*
M89[;*(:d3*M89[;*%B??*
O9+')!LnnSP!<')'+*0C!&.,%09%6!AC!*!LneL!@.@!0%&!+:*+!3*+%&.0'3*))C!A*99%6!&*C(I!!=4AX%3+!+.!6'(3:*0&%!
@>@K#!;0.:'A'+(!3.9643+!+:*+!'(!%9&*&'9&!.0!'6%9+'GC'9&P!(;%%3:!+:*+!30%*+%(!*!0%A4++*A)%!;0%(4<;+'.9!+:*+!C.4!*0%!
)'[%)C!+.!%9&*&%!'9!: .<.(%24*)!3.964 3+ !
! @'(3';)'9%P!<.0*)%P!+04(+P!'9+%&0'+C!.G!0*9[P!;0',*3C!3.93%09(P!0%304'+<%9+B0%+%9+'.9P!49'+!3.:%('.9!
! ^')'+*0C!6%G%0%93%#!A4+!<')'+*0C!G.34(%(!.9!3.9643+P!9.+!(+*+4(!D@>@KP!0%A4++*A)%!;0%(4<;+'.9!.G!A%:*,'.0F!
! =+*+4+%!60*G+%6!G.0!(*G%!:*0A.0!'9!Bowers!
*
-@<O<?B]B:*8@*&EE=9<;<B:C*$>EBa$BS*H>@@<>]B*
K'<%)'9%!
! LnnR#!`*/*''!=M+!/B(+0'3+!(304+'9C!.,%004)%(!0%(+0'3+'.9!.G!<*00'*&%I!!$%&'()*+40%!.,%00'6%(!/'+:!3.9(+!*<%96I!
! Lnng#!M)'9+.9!('&9(!@N^>#!!
(+*+%(!6.9Z+!:*,%!+.!0%3.&9'a%!(*<%E(%2!<*00'*&%(!.G!.+:%0!(+*+%(!
G.0!G%6!;40;.( %( P!< *0 0'* & %!'(!. 9 %!<*9!.9%!/.<*9!
! Lnnn#!7%0<.9+!0%_4'0%(!(*<%E(%2!3.4;)%!A%9%G'+(!496%0!3.<<49*)!A%9%G'+(!3)*4(%!.G!3.9(+!
! ^*C!QffR#!W%6%0*)!^*00'*&%!><%96!'9+0.643%6!'9!`.4(%!
! 549%!QffR#!Lawrence(v.(Texas(
( ?.,!QffR#!^*((!=M+P!(+*+%!3.9(+!&4*0*9+%%(!(*<%E(%2!<*00'*&%!0'&:+(!!
! ! ><%96<%9+!;0.3%640%!(+*0+(!'<<%6'*+%)C!
! ! ^4(+!&%+!,.+%!.,%0!Q!(433%((',%!)%&'()*+40%P!+:%9!;%.;)%!&%+!+.!,.+%!0%G%0%964<!D49)'[%!M>F!
54)C!Qffg#!?\!M+!>;;P!(+*+%!3.9(+!6.% ( !9 . +!& 4 * 0 * 9 +% % !(*< %E(%2!<*00'*&%!0'&:+(!!
! ! (+%0%.+C;%(!*A.4+!0%3[)%((!(%2!.G!(+0*'&:+!3.4;)%(P!9%%6!'9(+'+4+'.9!.G!<*00'*&%!G.0!3:')60%9Z(!(*[%!
!! ! b0%*)!6'GG%0%93%(c!*0&#!;0.&0%((',%!0*+'.9*)%!G.0!6%9'*)!.G!0'&:+(!
! ! ('<')*0!+.!*0&(!*& * '9 (+!/.<%9Z(!%_4 *) !+0% *+ <%9+!Lff!C%*0( !*& . F !
54)C!Qffg#!`.4 ( %!0% X%3 +(!W ^>!
^*C!Qffe#!M>!=M+!:.)6(!+:*+!(+*+%!3.9(+!&4*0*9+%%(!<*00'*&%!G.0!((!3.4;)%(!
N3+!Qffe#!MK!=3+!04)%(!+:*+!(+*+%!3.9(+!&4*0*9+%%(!<*00'*&%!0'&:+(!G.0!((!3.4;)%(!
?.,!Qffe#!M>!,.+%0(!*;;0.,%!-0.;e!.,%0+409'9&!=M+Z(!04)'9&!G.0!<*00'*&% !0 '& : +( P!* <%96'9&!(+* +% !3 . 9 (+ !
^*0!Qffn#!^*((!@'(+!M+#!]*C!0'&:+(!.0&!G')%(!3.<;)*'9+!*&*'9(+!G%6!(+*+4+.0C!6%G!. G!!
^*0!Qffn#!M>!=M+!:%*0(!.0*)!*0&(!'9!3*(%!3:*))%9&'9&!,*)'6'+C!.G!-0.;e!
>;0!Qffn#!"./*!=M+!04)%(!+:*!+:%!(+*+%!3.9(+!&4*0*9+%%(!((!3.4;)%(!+:%!0'&:+!+.!<*00C!
>;0!Qffn#!7K!)%&'(!.,%00'6%(!&.,Z(!,%+.P!%9*3+'9&!)*/!+:*+!)%&*)'a%(!((!<*00'*&%!
>;0!Qffn#!?`P!^1P!?\!6%A*+'9&B(..9!+.!6%A*+%!((!<*00'*&%!'9!)%&'()*+40%(!
!
W*<')C!)*/!'(!+0*6'+'.9*))C!*!(+*+%!6.<*'9I!!-0*&<*+'3!3.93%09(P!<.0%!<.<%9+4<!*+!(+*+%!)%,%)I!
N;;.9%9+(!.G!(*<%!(%2!<*00'*&%!3*9Z+!+*[%!'+!+.!=MNKO=#!/:%9!=+*+%!=M+!6%3'6%(!*!<*++%0!.G!(+*+%!)*/!/'+:!*6%_4*+%!
&0.496(P!=MNKO=!3*99.+!&0*9+!3%0+I!!?.!G%6%0*)!_4%(+'.9P!*6%_4*+%!*96!'96%;%96%9+!(+*+%!&0.496(I!
!
N"<,#&'(&H6"6,*Vf;0*W777ZC**))!<*+%0'*)!A%9%G'+(P!A4+!9.+!(C<A.)'(<!.G!<*00'*&%I!!M.93400%93%#!0%G)%3+'.9!.G!(%;*0*+%!
A4+!%_4*)I!
?*93C!W0*(%0#!;.)'+'3(!.G!0%6'(+0'A4+'.9!*96!;.)'+'3(!.G!0%3.&9'+'.9!D(C<A.)'3!6'&9'+*0C!0%3.&9'+'.9F!
7K!)%&'()*+40%P!>;0!QffnP!(4;%0(%6%(!&.,%09.0Z(!,%+.!AC!.9%!,.+%!+.!;*((!3',')!49'.9!)*/!D)'[%)C!9.+!;.0+*A)%!G0.<!(+*+%!
+.!(+*+%F!
!
^*00'*&%P!:'(+.0'3*))C#!
V.<%9Z(!'6%9+'+C!(4A(4<%6P!49*A)%!+.!3.9+0*3+B./9!;0.;%0+CP!0'&:+(!<%0&%6!'9+.!:%0!:4(A*96(!
>G0'3*9!><%0'3*9#!()*,%(!3.4)69Z+!<*00CP!:*6!0'3:!34)+40%!.G!0%)*+'.9(:';(!+:*+!6'(*;;%*0%6!.93%!<*00'*&%!/*(!+:%!
.9)C!*33%;+*A)%!G.0<!
!
*
A44?#8?9,&'(&G,D"#6*,56&47&I=+:8@&F,":6%*VH>::0*566YZC*(*<%!(%2!< *00'*&%!A* 9!:%)6!+.!,'.)*+%!@-!*96 !1-!3)*4(%(!.G!
(+*+%!3.9(+'+4+'.9P!6.%(9Z+!<%%+!0*+'.9*)!A*('(I!!$%&'()*+'.9!*([(!G.0!3)*0'G'3*+'.9!'G!3',')!49'.9!/.4)6!A%!.[*CP!3.40+!(*C(!
9.I!!W'0(+!(+*+%!+.!)%&*)'a%!&*C!<*00'*&%I!!=+0'[%(!6./9!*))!(+*+% Z(!*0 &4 <%9+(!496%0!0* +'. 9 * )!A * ('(# !
• ?.!;0',')%&%!G.0!;0.30%*+',%!'9+%03.40(%P!G%0+')'+C!9.+!*!3.96'+'.9!.G!<*00'*&%P!0*+:%0!3.<<'+<%9+I!
• N;+'<*)!G.0!3:')6!0%*0'9&#!A%(+!'9+%0%(+!.G!3:')6!6.%(9Z+!+409!.9!(%24*)B<*0'+*)!(+*+4(P!&*C(!3*9!A%!&..6!
;*0%9+(P!+..P!'00*+'.9*)!+.!;49'(:!3:')6!G.0!(%24*)!.0'%9+*+'.9!.G!;*0%9+(!
• -0%(%0,'9&!(+*+%!0%(.403%(#!&*C(!)'[%)C!*GG)4%9+P!6.9Z+!9%%6!A%9%G'+(!.G!<*00'*&%!D.,%0)..[(!.+:%0!6%;%96%9+(P!
)'[%!3:')60%9B;*0% 9 +(P!)*/(!6.9Z+!;0',')%&%!0%3%'; +!.G!A%9%G'+(!G.0!3.4;)%(!.9!(:./'9&!<4+4*)!6%;%96%93%F!
• W496*<%9+*)!,*)4%!.G!<*00'*&%!
]0%*9%CP!3.93400'9&#!<*00'*&%!'(!G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+P!(%2!A*(%6!3)*(('G'3*+'.9!D('<')*0!+.!LovingFP!==!0%_4'0%6P!6%9'*)!.G!
<*00'*&%!30%*+%(!3*(+%E)'[%!(C(+%<!
=;'9*P!6'((%9+'9&#!.9)C!;40;.(%G4)!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!3.4)6!/*00*9+!+:%!*3+'.9!+*[%9!AC!+:%!3.40+P!((!<*00'*&%!9.+!*!
G496*<%9 +* )!0'& :+!
M.06CP!6'((%9+'9&#!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!.9)CP!%I&IP!+:*+!0%*(.9'9&!/.4)6!(+0'[%!6./9!;0.:'A'+'.9!*&*'9(+!;.)C&*<C!
^*X.0'+C!*,.'6(!(+*+(!+:*+!'96'3*+%!==!3.4;)%(!3:')6!0%*0'9&!'(!9%&*+',%I!
!
!
H%++%0!496%0(+..6!*(!(%2!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!.0!(%24*)!.0'%9+*+'.9!6'(30'<'9*+'.9Y!
='<')*0!+.!Loving:!%_4*)!*;;)'3*+'.9I!!$% ( A '* 9 ( !3* 9 !<*00CP!+:%C!X4 ( +!3 * 9 Z+!<*00C!/.<%9I!
(
Loving!*9*).&C!
~!*0&4%(!(+*+4+%!A*00'9&!/:'+%(!G0.<!<*00C'9&!9.9/:'+%(!
G*3'*))C!6'(30'<!. 9 !A* ('( !.G!0* 3% I!
~!*0&4%(!(+*+4+%!A*00'9&!/.<%9!G0.<!<*00C'9&!
/.<%9!G*3'*))C!6'(30'<!.9!A*('(!.G!(%2I!
=+*+%!6%G%96(!+:*+!A.+:!/:'+%(!*96!9.9/:'+%(!*0%!
;0.:'A'+%6!G0.<!'9+%00*3'*)!<*00'*&%I!
=+*+%!6%G%96(!+:*+!A.+:!/.<%9!*96!<%9!*0%!;0.:'A'+%6!
G0.<!((!<*00 '*& % I!
M.40+!0%X%3+(!(+*+%Z(!%_4*)!*;;)'3*+'.9!6%G%9(%!.9!&0.496(!
.G!bV:'+%!=4;0%<*3Cc!
D`C;.+:%+'3*))CF!M.40+!0%X%3+(!(+*+%Z(!%_4 *)!*;; )'3*+'.9!
6%G%9(%I!
!
F,#5"5?,U&'(&M4+:,$*V#1*566bZC*?\!M.9(+!1-!*96!@-!3:*))%9&%!+.!;0.:'A'+'.9!*&*'9(+!==!<*00'*&%!
`%)6#!)%&'()*+'.9!9.+!6%('&9%6!+.!(4A.06'9*+%!%'+:%0!(%2!!
$%&'+!(+*+%!;40;.(%(P!(+*A')'a'9&!'9G)4%93%!.G!<*00'*&%!9%%6%6P!&*C(!3*9Z+!:*,%!['6(!;0.<'(34.4()C!(.!6.9Z+!9%%6!'+}!
Loving(*9*).&C#(:'(+.0C!9.+!6'(30'<'9*+.0C#!;0.;.(*)!.G!==!<*00'*&%!'(!<.6%09!'9,%9+'.9!
@-#!]*C!<*00'*&%!9.+!0..+%6!'9!+0*6'+'.9(B:'(+.0C!(.!9.!@-(D'(!+:'(!;4++'9&!3*0+!A%G.0%!:.(%!+.!3'034<,%9+!(+0'3+!
(304+'9CF!
1-#!9.!G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+P!9.+!*!&%96%0!3)*(('G'3*+'.9P!0%X%3+!:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9C!AB3!+:%0%!*0%!)%&'+'<*+%!0%*(.9(!G.0!
)%&'()*+',%!6'(+'93+'.9!'9 !3.9 +% 2+ !.G!< * 00'*& %P!(. !0*+'. 9* )!A* ('(!0% , '%/ !'(!* ;; 0. ;0'* +%!
W0*<'9&!+:%!;0.A)%<#!%_4*)!*;;)'3*+'.9!+.!<%9!*96!/.<%9P!9.+!&*C(!*96!(+0*'&:+(!
!
\5&#,&!"##8"9,&)"$, $*V! (*566XZC*(+*+%!3.9(+!1-!3)*4(%!&4*0*9+%%(!0'&:+!+.!(*<%E(%2!<*00'*&%!.9!A.+:!@-!*96!1- !
&0.496(!
-0.;e#!;.)'+C!*0+'34)*+%(!6'(*&0%%<%9+!/'+:!3.40+!/'+:!3.9(+!*<%96I!
$'+'&*+'.9!*&*'9dM:*))%9&%!'G!*<%96!'(!;0.3%640*))C!,*)'6P!*96!0%+0.*3+',%!
!
["#5=*&'(&N#8,5*V&8N>*5667ZC*(+*+%!3.9(+!&4*0*9+%%(!0'&:+!+.!(*<%!(%2!<*00'*&%P!'9+%0<%6'*+%!(304+'9C!496%0!1-!
!
W1@18>$!"==O1#!
@%G%9(%!.G!^*00'*&%!>3+!DLnngF#!!
WWUM!M:*))%9&%#!/.4)6!).(%I!!$'[%!.+:%0!M.9(+'+4+'.9*)!;0.,'('.9(P!+:%0%!'(!*!M.9&0%(('.9*)!%23%;+'.9(!3)*4(%#!
M.9&0%((!<*C!AC!&%9%0*)!)*/(!;0%(30'A%!+:%!<*99%0!'9!/:'(:!(43:!*3+(P!0%3.06(P!*96!;0.3%%6'9&(!(:*))!A%!;0.,%6P!*96!
+:%!%GG%3+!+:%0%.G!
1,%9!*A(%9+!@N^>P!).9&!'9+%0;0%+*+'.9!.G!WWUM!+.!*))./!;4A)'3!;.)'3C!%23%;+'.9(!D(43:!*(!G'0(+!3.4('9!<*00'*&%(F!
A8::&'(&B778@,&47&I,#$455,:&!"5"9,*,56&V5667ZC!&*C!0'&:+(!. 0 & !G')% ( !3. <;)*'9+!3:*)) % 9 &' 9 &!@N^>!*(!'+!% 2 3 )4 6 % ( !(* <%!
(%2!3.4;)%(!G0.<!<*00'*&%!496%0!G%6%0*)!1-!3)*4(%I!
!
*
*
*
*
)B]<:?>;<OB*>9F*(F\=F<A>;<OB*Q9I8@ABEB9;*8I*W^(*
1-#!:'(+.0C!.G!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!'(!.9%!;0.9&!.G!+:%!:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9C!0%_4'0%<%9+!
@-#!:'(+.0C!.G!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!(+*96(!'9!(4;;.0+!.G!+:%!denial!.G!+:%!0'&:+I!
*
!8@%",:&F(&'(&A,#":?&G(&VW7X7ZC*9.!0'&:+(!G.0!49<*00'%6!G*+:%0!/:%0%!<.+:%0!'(!<*00'%6!+.!*9.+:%0!<*9!!
• V:*+!3.9(+'+4+%(!*!)'A%0+C!'9+%0%(+Y!
o -0.3%640*)!@-#!(:.4)6!:*,%!.;;.0+49'+C!+.!A%!:%*06!
M>!04)%#!(+*+4(!*(!A'.).&'3*)!G*+:%0!'(!'00%)%,*9+!+.!'9_4'0CP!3.93)4(',%!;0%(4<;+'.9P!9.+!
0%A4++*A)%I!!=.!9.!9%%6!G.0!%,'6%9+'*0C!:%*0'9&!
@-!9%%6%6!.9)C!'G!+:%0%!/%0%!*!0%A4++*A)%!;0%(4<;+'.9!
• =3*)'*P!3.93400%93%#!(+*+%!(:.4)6!0%3.&9 'a % !)'A % 0+ C!'9 + % 0% (+ !. 9 )C !'G!+: % 0% !'( !* !+0* 6 '+ '.9 !. G!; 0 . +% 3+ '. 9 P!(+* + %6 !* + !
+:%!most(specific(level(of(abstraction!D+:'(!'(!9.+!*!G4 9 6 * <%9+*)!0'&:+!* + !'(( 4 % F!
o $%,%)(!.G!&%9%0*)'+C#!;*0%9+*)!0'&:+(!.G!*64)+%0.4(!9*+40*)!G*+:%0(!BB!;*0%9+:..6!BB!G*<')C!
0%)*+'.9(:';(!BB!;%0(.9*)!0%)*+'.9(:';(!BB!%<.+'.9* )!*++*3:< %9 +(!'9!&%9%0*) !
o 12IP!Bowers(v.(HardwickP!0'&:+!+.!;0',*3C!< . 0 % !& % 9 % 0 * )!+ : * 9!0'&:+!+.!(.6 . <C!
o WNNK?NK1!g#!3.40+!<4(+!3:..(%!<.(+!(;%3'G'3!0'&:+!G.0!/:'3:!C.4!3*9!G'96!*!tradition!+:*+!(;%*[(!
.9%!/*C!.0!*9.+:%0!+.!+:%!_4%(+'.9!.G!/:%+:%0!'+!'(!6%%;)C!0..+%6!'9!+:%!9*+'.9Z(!:'(+.0C!D:%0%P!
/0'+'9&!.9)C!G.0!:'<(%)G!*96!8%:9_4'(+F!
N9)C!/*C!+.!;0%,%9+!X46'3'*)!%9*3+<%9+!.G!;%0(.9*)!;0%G%0%93%(!
N+:%0/'(%P!9./:%0%!+.!60*/!+:%!)'9%P!*96!<.(+!&%9%0*)!/.4)6!G04(+0*+%!*9C!&.,Z+!;40;.(%!
`%0%P!(+0.9&!+0*6'+'.9!.G!;0.+%3+'9&!+:%!49'+*0C!G*<')C!
• H0%99*9Z(!6'((%9+#!M.9(+'+4+'.9!(:.4)6!;0.+%3+!6',%0(%!;*0%9+*)!0'&:+(P!<*9C!6'GG%0%9+!+C;%(!.G!G*<')C!
*00*9&%<%9+(P!/%!*0%!9.+!*!:.<.&%9.4(!(.3'%+C!
• NZM.99.0Bk%99%6C!.;+!.4+!.G!G9g#!*(!'93.9('(+%9+!/'+:!;*(+!3*(%(!D6'GG%0%9+!/*C(!.G!G'96'9&!G496*<%9+*)!
0'&:+(FP!+:'(!/.4)6!3:';!*/*C!*+!RoeI!
!
K0*6'+'.9*)!(+*+%!6.<*'9#!30'<%P!G*<')CI!!W).4+%6!AC!%9*3+<%9+!.G!@N^>P!%I&IP!'93.9('(+%9+I!
!
!
Q"$%859645&'(&A:=@<$+,#9&VW77`ZC*4;:.)6!(+*+%!A*9!.9!;:C('3'*9!*(('(+%6!(4'3'6%!*(!=4A@-!,'.)*+'.9P!9.!
3.9(+'+4+'.9*)!0'&:+!+.!*(('(+%6!(4'3'6%!
! @%(;'+%!3:*9&%!'9!G*3+(B+%3:9.).&CP!3.<<.9!)*/!*96!:'(+.0C!;0%,*')%6!
K/.!;0.9&!*9*)C('(!D)'<'+'9&!;0'93';)%(F!D3.9X493+',%!+%(+F!
• "(!+:'(!6%%;)C!0..+%6!'9!9*+'.9Z(!:'(+.0CB'<;)'3'+!'9!3.93%;+!.G!.06%0%6!)'A%0+C!
• M*0%G4)!6%(30';+'.9!.G!*((%0+%6!G496*<%9+*)!)'A%0+C!'9+%0%(+!
o =+*+%!'9+%0%(+!'9!;0.+%3+'9&!,4)9%0*A)%!&0.4;(!*96!6'(;*0*+%!'<;*3+!D;..0P!6'(*A)%6P!%)6%0)C#!9.+!
:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9C!3)*(('G'3*+'.9(F!
• ?.!G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+P!.9)C!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!+%(+#!! !
o -*((%(P!AB3!'+!;0.+%3+(!,4)9%0*A)%!&0.4;(!D6'(*A)%6!;%0(.9(P!%)6%0)CF!
• M.40+!3).('9&!.9%!+0*6'+'.9*)!1-!6..0!*G+%0!*9.+:%0!
o ?.!<.0%!:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9C!&0.4;(!
o N;%9'9&!)'A%0+C!6..0#!6.'9&!%_4*)'+C!/.0[!496%0!+:%!04A0'3!.G!)'A%0+C!DLawrenceP!Tennessee(v.(
LaneFd).9&!+0*6'+'.9!.G!6.'9&!+:'(!DMeyerP!PierceF!
• Cruzan!DLnnfF!:*6 !& ', % 9 !0 '& : +!+.!0%G4(%!<%6 '3 * )!3 * 0% !A C !3 . <;%+%9+!*64 )+ (!4 9 6 % 0 !@ - !
o =+*+%!3*9!0%_4'0%!3)%*0!*96!3.9,'93'9&!%,'6%93%!+:*+!;%0(.9!/*9+%6!+%0<'9*+'.9!.G!+0%*+<%9+!
o ^*C!;0%,%9+!G*<')C!<%<A%0(!G0.<!6%3'6'9&!D3.9G)'3+!.G!'9+%0%(+F!
o @'6!9.+!*0+'34)*+%!)%,%)!.G!(304+'9CP!)%G+!/:*+!%,'6%93%!(+*+%!3.4)6!0%_4'0%!493)*0'G'%6!
!
X*D:4>*,56&G8'8$845&'(&H*86%C*;%C.+%!3*(%!
• =:4+!6./9!1-!,%9+40%!AB3!.G!;)40*)'(<!*92'%+C#!3*9 Z+ !* 33 . <<.6*+%!* ))!0 % )'& '. 9 ( !/:%9!+:%0%!* 0% !( . !<*9C!
(<*))!&0.4;(!D3:%%(%B0%)'&'.9F!
• jh#!V:'+%Z(!*9*)C('(!.G!+..!<*9C!&0.4;(!'9!Cleburne!'(!;0%(3'%9+!.9!+:'(!; . '9 +!
o (.),'9&!+:%!+..!<*9C!&0.4;(!;0.A)%<!<%*9(!(/'+3:'9&!G0.<!&0.4;(!+.!0'&:+(EA*(%6!0%*(.9'9&!
o -)40*)'(+'3!(.3'%+C!:*(!+.!%9&*&%!'9!6'GG%0%9+P!A4+!0.A4(+!3',')!0'&:+(!6%A*+%!
o 1_4*)'+C!3.93%09(!*0%!*!A0*[%!*96!*!&.*6!'9!+:%!3.9('6%0*+'.9!.G!A.496*0'%(!.G!)'A%0+C!
*
Lawrence,(*(!3:*9&%(!+.!Michael(H.(*96!Glucksberg…c'<;)'3'+!'9!3.93%;+!.G!.06%0%6!)'A%0+Cc!9%%6!9.!).9&!:'(+.0CP!9.+!
+%<;.0*)I!!"9!LawrenceP!+:'(!34+ (!*&*'9(+!+:%!' 6 % * !. G!: '( + . 0 C !* ( !* !& 4 '6%I!!!@0*G+%0(!. G!h >!*96!LS>![9%/!+:*+ !+'<%(!3*9!
A)'96!4(!+.!3%0+*'9!+04+:(I!!!
=49(+%'9Z(!6'(+'93+'.9(#!
• `'(+.0C!34+(!'9!.;;.('+%!6'0%3+'.9(!G.0!@-B1-!;40;.(%(d<.0%!)' [ %) C!+ . !/'9!'9!@-!'G!0.. + % 6 !'9 !: '( +. 0 C !+: * 9 !1 - !
• `'(+.0C!.G!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!)%96(!/%'&:+!+.!:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9C!*96!'9,*)'6*+'.9!.G!(+*+%!*3+'.9!
• Lawrence!496%0<'9 % ( !+: '( !6 '( +'9 3 +' . 9 d W 0 * <%0(!3.4)6!: *, % !3 : . (% 9 !) *4 9 60C!)'(+!.G!)'A%0+ '% ( !A 4 +!6 '6!9.+!
• -0.+%3+'9&!)'A%0+C!/B:'&:%0!)%,%)(!.G!&%9%0*)'+CP!)%G+!'+!+.!(433%((',%!&%9%0*+'.9(!+.!6%+%0<'9%!
• ?.!6'0%3+!0%;46'*+'.9!.G!GlucksbergP!(+*0+!/'+:!Glucksberg!+%(+P!*96!+: % 9 !* 6 X4 (+ !G. 0 !Lawrence!
Amanda Bakale 4/30/09 10:33 PM
Comment: (%%!;;+!
• @-#!=+0'3+!(304+'9C!G.0!G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+(P!A4+!9.!+'%0%6!(C(+%<!G.0!1-I!
o 1I&IP!Lawrence!6'6!9.+!'9+%96!+.!&', %!G 4 9 6 * <%9+*)!0'&:+!(+ * +4 ( !+. !+ : %!0 '& : + !+. !% 9 & * &% !'9!(.6.<C!
!
H",5U&'(&M4,*VW777ZC*D(%%!*A., %P!*)(.P!-U"F!
• =+043[!6./9!640*+'.9*)!0%('6%93C!0%_4'0%<%9+(!496%0!0'&:+!+.!+0*,%)!%<A%66%6!'9!-U"!
• ?N!1-!(304+'9C!AB3!9.+!*!:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9C!3)*((!
• 8'&:+(!(+0*96!.G!1-!3)*4(%#!3)*((!A*(%6P!*96!;0.+%3+(!0'&:+(!.G!*33%((!+.!3.40+P!0'&:+!+.!A%!G0%%!G0.<!;.))!+*2P!
0'&:+!+.!+0*,%)!
• K:.<*(!/.4)6!:*,%!4(%!0%,'('+!=4A@-!3*(%(!*96!A0'9&!+:%<!'9+.!-U"!DA)';#!Lawrence(3.<%(!*).9&P!;*+:!
6%;%96%93C!.G!)*/F!
!
?.+%#!'9+%09*+'.9*)!)*/!*(!,'*A)%!*)+%09*+',%!+.!:'(+.0C!*(!*!<%*9(!.G!6'(3';)'9'9&!@-!0'&:+(Y!!D'I%IP!LawrenceF!
! -8N#!'930%*('9&)C!&).A*)'a%6!/.0)6P!9%+/.0[!.G!X46&%(P!3.<'+C!3.93%09(!
! MN?#!;'3[!*96!3:..(%!*<.9&!3.49+0'%(P!6'GG'34)+!+.![9./!*))P!+0*9( 9* +'.9 *)'( < B 3.4 9 +% 0< * X.0'+* 0'*9 !/ * C!.G!
(<4&&)'9&!'9!'9+%09*+'.9*)!9.0<(!/B. !+:%!'<;0'< *+40!.G!6%< .30*+'3!;0.3%((P!)'A%0*)!%)'+%!'<;.('9&!6%3'('.9(!.G!
G.0%'&9!X46&%( !D; 0. A )%<(!.G!k.:P!)*+%)CF!
! !
["@@4&'(&Z=8::&VW77`ZC*3.<;*9'.9!+.!GlucksbergP!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!0%,'%/!* ;;)'%6!+.!1- !3 : * ) )% 9 &%6!+.!;0.: 'A '+ '. 9(!.9!
;:C('3'*9E*(('(+%6!(4'3'6%!D9.+!*!G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+P!(.!9.!(+0'3+!(304+'9CF!
• ?.!1-!,'.)*+'.9#!
o ?.!(4(;%3+!3)*((P!+0%*+(!*))!%_4*))CP!9.!G496*<%9+*)!0'&:+!D(%%!GlucksbergF!
@.%(9Z+!6'(30'<'9*+%!A%+/%%9!+: . (% !/ : . !3* 9 !0% G4( %6 !+0 %* +<%9+!G0.<!+:. (% !/ : . !/ . 4 )6 !:* , % !
+.!&%+!*(('(+%6!(4'3'6%!
o 8*+'.9*)!A*('(!!
• $%G+!+.!;.)'+'3*)!;0.3%((!G.0!(+*+%(!+.!;*((!)*/(!&40*9+%%6'9&!!
• ^'&:+!A%!*9!b*(!*;;)'%6c!+%(+P!:'9+(!'9!+:%!3.93400%93%(!
&
T"6U,5+"@%&'(&!4#9"5&VW7bbZC*?\!)'+%0*3C!0%_4'0%<%9+!G.0!,.+'9&P!W%6%0*)!7.+'9&!8'&:+(!>3+!<*96*+%(!+:*+!'G!
><%0'3*9!G'9'(:%6!g
+:
!&0*6%!'9!=; * 9 '( : !)* 9 & 4 *& % !'9 !- 4 % 0 +. !8'3.P!+:%9!+:% C !3* 9 Z+!A%!6%9'%6!,. +% !A*(%6!.9!19 & )'( : !
)'+%0*3CI!!K:%!G%6%0*)!* 3+!'(!; *( (%6 !; 40( 4* 9 +!+.!L S> !j hI!!!
• M:*))%9&%6!78>!*(!'9!%23%((!.G!M.9&0%((Z(!;./%0!+.!*3+!
• LS>!A0%*[6./9!
o jL!:*(!(+*+%!*3+'.9!0%_4'0%<%9+!D;4A)'3P!9.+!;0',*+%!*3+.0(F!
o jhP!M.9&0%((!:*(!;./%0!+.!%9G.03%!;0.,'('.9(!.G!+:'(!*0+'3)%!
N+:%0!8%3.9(+043+'.9!><%96(!:*,%!M.9&0%(('.9*)!0'6%0!;0.,'('.9(!DLR>!jQP!Lh>!jQF!
N9)C!LR>!:*(!9.!(+*+%!*3+'.9!0%_4'0%<%9+!
M.9&0%((!3*9!9.+!*3+!(.!A0.*6)C!496%0!LS>!jh!*(!+.!.A,'*+%!+:%!(+*+%!*3+'.9!0%_4'0%<%9+!
• M*9Z+!0%*3:!;0',*+%!*3+.0(P!AB3!+:*+!'(!9.+!%9G.03'9&!jL!
o `%0%P!+:%!(+*+%!'(!'9,.),%6I!!M.9&0%((!'9+%0%(+%6!'9!+%(+'9&!+:%!/*+%0(!.9!jh!;./%0(d !
• M.9&0%((Z(!'9+%0;0%+*+'.9!.G!jL!%9G.03%6!496%0!jh!;./%0#!*&&0%((',%!'9+%0;0%+*+'.9!.G!jL!;./%0(I!!M.9&0%((!
6.%(!9.+%!6%G%0!+.!=MNKO=Z(!'9+%0;0%+*+'.9!.G!jLI!
• M.40+Z(!'9+%0;0%+*+'.9!.G!jL!'(!9*00./%0!D/:*+!'(!9%3%((*0C!*96!;0.;%0F#!M.49+!+:%!,'.)*+'.9(!496%0!jL!as(
articulated(by(the(COURTP!%I&IP!'9!LassiterP!*96!+:% 9!(%%!'G!M.9&0 % ( (!'( !0 % (;.96'9&!+. !(+ * + % !* 3 + . 0Z( !, '.)*+'.9(I!!!
`%0%P!M.9&0%((!6%+%0<'9%6!+:*+!+:%!?\!)*/!,'.)*+%6!1-!D6'(;*0*+%!'<;*3+!*0&4<%9+FI!!M.9&0%((!6%G%0(!+.!3.40+!/0+!
G*3+!+:*+!9*+'.9 *)!. 0'& '9 !6'( 30'<'9*+'.9!'(!;%09 '3'. 4 (P!(+0 '3+!(3 04 +'9 C I!!HO K !M .4 0+ !(*'6 !'9 !Lassiter(+:*+!+:%!0%_4'0%<%9+(!
6'6!9.+!,'.)*+%!1-P!M.9&0%((!'&9.0%(I!!!
!
C"$$86,#&'(&K4#6%"*D645&X:,@6845&N4"#?*VW7_7ZC*?MZ(!)'+%0*3C!0%_4'0%<%9+(!:%)6!9.+!+.!,'.)*+%!LS>!jLI!!!
K:'(!;0%3%6%9+!<*[%(!'+!:*06!G.0!M.9&0%((!+.!(*C!'+!'(!*3+'9&!+.!%9G.03%!LS>!jLP!/:%9!=MNKO=!:*(!(;.[%9I!
=+*+%(!3*9!6%+%0<'9%!%)%3+'.9!(+*96*06(d!
!
N4,#5,&'(&)86>&47&R:4#,$C*3:*9&%(!+:%!*9*)C('(d!
• @%+%0<'9%!/:*+!+:%!jL!0'&:+(!*0%P!*(!6%+%0<'9%6!AC!+:%!M.40+!
• V*(!M.9&0%((Z(!jh!0%(;.9(%!congruent(and(proportional(+.!0%<%6C!+:%!,'.)*+'.9(I!
o MU-!'(!*!much!(:.0+%0!)%*(:!G.0!M.9 & 0% ( (!+ : * 9 !? U-!
• 8*+3:%+!G..+9.+%#!jh!;./%0!)'<'+%6!+.!<%*(40%(!+.!%9G.03%!LS>!&4*0*9+%%(P!A4+!&',%(!M.9&0%((!?N!;./%0!+.!
0%(+0'3+P!*A0.&*+%P!.0!6')4+%!+:.(%!&4*0*9+%%(!DM.9&0%((!3*9!;0.:'A'+!/: *+!+:%!M.40+!:* (!;%0< '++%6P!A4+!3*9Z+!
;%0<'+!/:*+!+:%!M.40+!:*(!;0.:'A'+%6FI!
`'(+.0Cd!
Sherbert(v.(Verner(DLngRF#!49%<;).C%6!A4+!/.9Z+!/.0[!AB3!.G!0%)'&'.9 I!!M.40+!3*0,%( !.4+!*9!%2 3%;+'.9!G.0!0%)'&'.9!!
Wisconsin(v.(Yoder!DLnpQF#!>< '( : !6 . 9 Z+!/*9+!['6(!'9!( 3 : . . )!; * (+ !e
+:
!&0*6%I!!M.4 0 +!* 33 . <<.6*+%(,(MeyerP!Pierce(
!
W0%%!%2%03'(%!04)%!<4(+!:*,%!3.<;%))'9&!'9+%0%(+!A%G.0%!*!04)%!.G!&%9%0*)!*;;)'3*A')'+C!3*9!A%!*((%0+%6!*&*'9(+!
*!3.<<49'+CB'96','64*)!*&*'9(+!/:'3:!'+!:*(!*!6'(;*0*+%!'<;*3+!
Employment(Division(v.(Smith(DLnnfF#!6%9'%6!A%9%G'+(!AB3!.G!;%C.+% !4(%P!(*30*<%9+*)!
! =3*)'*#!3*9Z+!&0*9+!(;%3'G'3!*33.<<.6*+'.9(!
! @.9Z+!&%+!3.40+(!'9+.!*!6%A*+%!*A.4+!('93%0'+C!.G!A%)'%G(!
"<;.0+(!Washington(v.(Davis!'9+.!W0%% !1 2 % 03 '( % d & % 9 % 0* )) C!* ; ; ) '3* A)%P!9.!*9'<4 ( !+ . / * 0 6 !; * 0+ '3 4 )* 0!& 0 . 4 ; P!
+:%9!N?$\!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!0%,'%/!
NZM.99.0#!+:%(%!*0%!9.+!'6%9+'+C!A*(%6!6'(+'93+'.9(P!A4+!A%:*,'.0(!+:*+!3.9(+'+4+%!0%)'&'.4(!'6%9+'+C!
8%)'&'.4(!W0%%6.<!8%(+.0*+'.9!>3+!DLnnRF#!496%0!jh!;./%0(P!:'&:!;0.+%3+'.9(!.G!Sherbert!*96!YoderP!A4+!)./!'9 !
Smith(
( 8W8>!'(!M.9&0%((Z(!*++%<;+!+.!0%(+.0%!Sherbert!*96!Yoder!(+*96*06(!*(!M. 4 0 +Z( !3 . %_4*)!'9+%0;0% +% 0 !
! MNO8K!&',%(!MN?]81==!+:%!(<*3[6./9dM.40+!'(!.9)C!'9+%0;0%+%0P!+:'9!;0.+%3+'.9(!.G!Smith!(+*96!
• M.40+!&%+(!+.!6%G'9%!jL!0'&:+(P!M.9&0%((!3*9!%9G.03%!+:%<!496%0!jh!
o M.9&0%((!'(!+0C'9&!+.!%9G.03%!0'&:+(!+:*+!*0%!A0.*6%0!+:*9!+:%!M.40+!&4*0*9+%%6!496%0!jL!'9!Smith!
(
K:'(!'(!)'[%!+:%!(_4%%a%6!A*))..9#!M.<<%03%!-./%0!/*9%(P!(.!M.9&0%((!+0'%(!+.!X4(+'GC!496%0!jh!
!
JH&'(&!4##8$45*V5666ZC*A'96(!jh!*9*)C('(!*96!Lopez#!7'.)%93%!>&*'9(+!V .<%9!>3+P!;0',* +% !3 * 4 (% !. G!* 3+ '. 9 !G. 0!, '3+ '<(!
.G!&%96%0!<.+',*+%6!,'.)%93%P!'(!,'.)*+'9&!M.9&0%((Z(!;./%0!496%0!HNK`!jh!*96!M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!
• Lopez!+%(+#!M:*99% )( P!'9 (+ 04 <%9+*)'+'%(P!(4A( +* 9 +'* ))C !* GG%3 +(!
o =4A(+*9+'*))C!>GG%3+(#!% 3. 9 . <'3!'9!9*+40% P!X4 0 '( 6 '3+ '. 9 * )!% )% <%9+P!3.9&0% ( (' . 9 *) !G'9 6 '9 & ( P!)'9 [ !+ . !
'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!D9.+!* !A *)* 9 3 '9 &!+ %( +P!.9 % !3* 9 !A %!(4 GG'3 '% 9+ F !
o @'(+'9&4'(:%6!Wickard(v.(FillburnP!*&&0%&*+'.9!.9)C!*,*')*A)%!/:%9!*3+','+C!'(!%3.9.<'3!'9!9*+40%!
`%0%P!9.+!%3.9.<'3P!9.!X40'(6'3+'.9*)!%)%<%9+P!G'96'9&(!'9(4GG'3'%9+P!9.!)'9[!+.!3.<<%03%!AB3!
3:*'9!.G!3*4(*+'.9!'(!+..!+%94.4(!
• jhP!M.9&04%93%!*96!-0.;.0+'.9*)'+C!+.!jL!,'.)*+'.9(!
o *;;)'%(!Boerne!+.!jL!0'&:+!
1-!G0.<!(+*+%!
M*9Z+!0%*3:!;0',*+%!*3+.0(!
!
>G+%0<*+:!.G!Boerne!
='&9'G'3*9+!'9!sovereign(immunity(3*(%(P!A%3*4(%!M.9&0%((!3*9Z+!*,*')!'+(%)G!.G!M.<<%03%!M)*4(%!+:%0%!
Chisholm(v.(GA!DLpnRFP!3'+'a%9(!. G!. 9 % !(+ * +% !3 *9 !( 4 % !* 9 . +: % 0 !(+ * +% !
$%6!+.!LL>!
Hans(v.(Louisiana(DLenfF#!LL>!;0.:'A'+(!(4'+!*&*'9(+!*!(+*+%!AC!'+(!./9!3'+'a%9(P!.+:%0/'(%!6'(30'<'9* +'9&!*&* '9(+!.4+E
.GE(+*+%0(!
Ex(parte(Young!DLnfeF#!3'+'a%9(!3*9!(4 % !( +* +% ( !G. 0 !; 0. ( ; % 3 +', % !'9 X4 9 3 +' ,% !0 % )'% G!
Edelman(v.(Jordan!DLnpSF#!3'+'a% 9 (!3 * 9 Z+!( 4 % !(+ * +% (!G . 0!6 * <*&%(!G0.<!(+*+%!+0%*(40C!
Alden(v.(Maine!DLnnnF#!3'+'a% 9 !A * 00 % 6 !G0 . <!A0'9&'9&!G%6%0*)!6*<*& % ( !(4 ' +!'9 !G% 6 !3 . 4 0 +!3 * 9 Z+!A 0 '9 & !+: * + !(4 ' +!'9 !( +* + %!3 . 4 0 +!
Seminole(Tribe(v.(Florida!DLnngF#!M.9 & 0% ( (!3 * 9 Z+!* A 0 . & * +% !( . ,!' <<!,'*!>0+I!"I!!!
!
K.!*A0.&*+%!(+*+%!;./%0(P!+:%0%!<4(+!A%!%'+:%0!!
! V*',%0!.G!'<<49'+C!AC!+:%!(+*+%P!.0!
! M)%*0!'9+%9+!AC!M.9&0%((!+.!*A0.&*+%!*9!*3+'.9!;40(4*9+!+.!;0.;%0!D'I%IP!;.(+ELL>F!;./%0!
DLL>#!9.!;0%%2'(+'9&!;./%0!/ *(!(4 GG'3'%9+!+.!;'%03%!(., !'<< P!+:.4 &: !(4A(% _4 %9+!*< % 96 (!3.4)6 F!
*
)86>&47&):,+=#5,&'(&):,+=#5,&VW7X_ZC*:.<%!G.0!<%9+*))C!0%+*06%6!6%9'%6!;%0<'+P!M.40+!*;;)'%(!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!/'+:!A'+%!
*96!(+0'[%(!6./9!+:%!;%0<'+!0%_4'0%<%9+!
$%&'+'<*+%!;40;.(%!3*9Z+!A%!A*(%6!.9!;0%X46'3%B;0',*+%!A'*(!D3.<;*0%!+.!.+:%0(!'9!('<')*0!('+4*+'.9F!
O93.9+%(+%6!+:*+!M.9&0%((!:*(!+:%!;./ %0!+.!>3+!49 6% 0!M.< < % 03%!M)*4 (%P!A4+!+: %!_4% (+'.9!'(!/ :%+: %0!+:'(!'(!*!,*)'6!
*++%<;+!+.!*A0.&*+%!+:%!(.,%0%'&9!'<<49'+C!.G!+:%!(+*+%!
Cf.!MorrisonP!/:%0%!_4%( +' . 9 !/*(!/:%+: % 0 !M . 9 & 0 % ( (!:*6!;./%0 !+ . !* 3 + !
$'[%/'(%P(/0+!>@>!'9!GarrettP!+:%!>@>!K'+)%!"!6%*)(!/'+:!%<;).C<%9+P!*96!+:%0%G.0%P!'9+%0(+*+%!3.<<%03%!3*9!*;;)CP!
*96!+:%!_4%(+'.9!'(!/:%+:%0!+:%!>@>!3*9!A%!4(%6!+.!*A0.&*+%!(.,!'<<!
• M.40+!0%X%3+(!:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9C!G.0!+:%!6'(*A)%6#!DA4+P!:'(+.0C!.G!6'(30'<P!;./%0)%((9%((P!'<<4+*A)%YF!
o ?.+!;./%0)%((P!AB3!+:%C!:*,%!*++%9+'.9!.G!)*/<*[%0(!D0%,%0(%!.G!Frontiero!;)40*)'+CF!
o =)';;%0C!().;%!3.9(%_4%93%(P!.+:%0(!/'))!*)(.!%2;%3+!:%'&:+%9%6!(304+'9C!
M.9&0%((P!49)'[%!3.40+P!3*9!*3+!/B.!(+*+'9&!;0'93';)%6!0%*(.9(!D3*9!X4(+!<*[%!;.)'+'3*)!
;0%G%0%93%(F!
• M.40+!0%X%3+(!G.40!0*+'.9*)%(!.G!+:%!M'+C!M.493')!
o ?%&*+',%!*++'+46%(!.G!;0.;%0+C!./9%0(!
o W%*0!.G!:*0*((<%9+!AC!9%*0AC!(3:..)Z(!(+46%9+(!
M*9Z+!0%&4)*+%!;0',*+%!;0%X46'3%P!A4+!3*9!4(%!'+!*(!0*+'.9*)%!G.0!0%&!DPalmerF!
o W%*0!+:*+!:.4(%!/*(!.9!G)..6!;)*'9!
O96%0'93)4(','+CP!(:.4)6!*;;)C!+.!*9C+:'9&!.9!G)..6!;)*'9!
o W%*0!*A.4+!94<A%0!.G!.334;*9+(!
• @'(+'9&4'(:!Lee(OpticalP!.;+'3'*9(!*0%!6'GG%0 % 9 + !G0 . <!<%9+*))C !6 ' (*A)%6dA* (% 6 !.9!(.3'*)!*9 '<4(!.,%0!+'<%!D9.+!
G.0<*)!6'GG%0%9 3% P!.0!C .4 !!& %+!+. !()'; ; % 0C!( ).; % !*0 &4 <%9+F!
• K*[%!*/*C#!*0&4%!G.0!*0A'+0*0'9%((!*96!490%*(.9*A)%9%((!.G!+:%!(+*+4+%P!9.+!+:*+!,'3+'<(!*0%!*!;0.+%3+%6!3)*((P!
+.!&%+!0*+'.9*)!A*('(!/'+:!A'+%!'9(+%*6!.G!G*')'9&!+.!&%+!:%'&:+%9 %6 !(304+'9C !!
!
E:"+"*"&'(&A"##,66*V566WZC*>@>!(4'+!G.0!6*<*&%(!*&*'9(+!(+*+%!%<;).C%0P!M.40+!4;:.)6(!LL>!6 %G% 9( %I!
>@>!K'+)%!"#!9.!6'(30'<'9*+'.9!'9!%<;).C<%9+!D3.<<%03%!3.99%3+'.9F!
>@>!K'+)%!""#!*33%((!+.!;4A)'3!*33.<<.6*+'.9!D('<')*0!+.!Heart(of(AtlantaF!
-%0<'(('A)%!+.!%9*3+dI(.,!'<<!_4%(+'.9!
• 49%_4',.3*))C!'9+%96(!+.!*A0.&*+%!(.,%0%'&9!'<<49'+C!
• *3+%6!;40(4*9+!+.!,*)'6!&0*9+!.G!*4+:.0'+C!D;.(+!LL>F!
o Boerne(<.6%)!.G!jh!;./%0!
@%G'9%!jL!0'&:+!D0*+'.9*)!A*('(!/ '+ : !A '+ %!G . 0!+ : % !6 '(* A)%6P!*G+%0!Cleburne!*96!>@>F!!
• ?.+!*))!G.0<(!.G!6'(;*0*+%!+0%*+<%9+!*0%!jL!,'.)*+'.9(P!A4+!Cleburne(0%3.&9'a%(!+:*+!
'+!might(be!0*+'.9*)!!+.!6'( 3 0'<'9*+%!*&*'9 ( +!6 '( * A )% 6 !'96','64*)(!
`./!<*9C!,'.)*+'.9(Y!D9.+!<*9CP!%2+%96%6!'9_4'0C!.9)C!+.!(+*+%P!9.+!<49'3';*)'+'%(F!
"(!3.9&0%(('.9*)!0%< %6 C!3.9 & 04% 9+!*9 6!; 0.; .0 +'.9 *)!
!
!
!
W,55,$$,,&'(&C"5,C*/:%%)3:*'0!*33%(('A)%!3.40+:.4(%#!o!:*6!+.!3)'<A!4;!(+%;(!+.!*9(/%0!30'<'9*)!3:*0&%(P!0%G4(%(!*96!
'(!:%)6!'9!3.9+%<;+!
• =+*+%!0*'(%(!(.,!'<<!3)*'<!
• M.40+!4;:.)6(!K'+)%!""!*(!,*)'6!jh!%9*3+<%9+I!!8'&:+!+.!*33%((!3.40+(!496%0!=4A@-!
• Griffin(v.(IllinoisP!+0*9(30';+ !9 % % 6 % 6 !+ . !: * , % !<%*9'9&G4 )!* 33% (( !+.!3. 40 +!
&
K,'"?"&G,D6&47&F=*"5&M,$4=#@,$&'(&F8++$&V566YZC*W*<')C!*96!^%6'3*)!$%*,%!>3+P!(.,!'<<!6%G%9(%!
• `*0<!*((%0+%6!+0'&&%0(!jLP!M.9&0%((!<*C!*3+!496%0!jh!
• M.9&04%9+!*96!;0.;.0+'.9*)!0%<%6C#!!
o @'(;*0*+%!+0%*+<%9+!.9!A*('(!.G!(%2!AC!(+*+%!*3+.0(!D%2+%96%6!<*+%09'+C!)%*,%!6'(30'<'9*+%(!*&*'9(+!
<%9P!6'(;*0*+%!+0%*+<%9+!*96!'9+%0<%6'*+%!(304+'9CF!
o @'(;*0*+%!+0%*+<%9+!.9!A*('(!.G!(%2!AC!(+*+%!%<;).C%0(!0%(4)+(P!)%((!)'[%)C!+.!:'0%!/.<%9!AB3!+:%C!3*9!
+*[%!)%*,%!
o @'(;*0*+%!+0%*+<%9+!.9!A*('(!.G!(%2!AC!private!%<;).C%0 ( !D/:%0%!3:')6!3 *0 % !; . )'3 '% ( !%2'(+P!<%9!*96 !
/.<%9!&%+!+0%*+%6!6'GG%0%9+)C!/:%9!*(['9&!G.0!)%*,%F!
Washington(v.(DavisP!*A(%9+!'9+% 9 + P!9 .!,'.)*+'.9!+ . !: * , % !6 '( ; *0*+%!'<;* 3 +!
`%0%P!*3+!;0.+%3+(!HNK`!<%9!*96!/.<%9P!(.!9.+!.,%0A0.*6P!A*(%6!.9!(+%0%.+C;%!
o @'(;*0*+%!'<;*3+!.9!/.<%9!.G!/.0[;)*3%!;.)'3'%(!6%('&9%6!G.0!/.0[%0(!/B.!3*0%+*['9&!;0.,'('.9(!
• W^$>!&*,%!49;*'6!)%*,%!/B.!0%&*06!+.!(%2db3.9&04%9+!*96!;0.;.0+'.9*)c!+.!6'(30'<'9*+'.9Y!
&
-@8ABF=@>?*M-C*M46%&'(&N4"#?&47&M,9,56$*VW7`6ZC*6%;0',*+'.9!'93)46%6!+%0<'9*+'.9!G0.<!(+*+%!X.A!D/ % )G *0 % !A % 9 % G'+ (P!
U3FI!!I,##>&'(&H85?,#*"5*VW7`5Z C*;0.;%0+C!'(!0%*(.9*A)%!%2;%3+*+'.9!+.!3.9+'94%6!0%3%';+!.G!*!A%9%G'+!D+%940%!3*(%F!
&
]!89]@B::[:*G8NB@*=9FB@*;LB*@BA89:;@=A;<89*B@>*>EB9FEB9;:C*!2QH*G5XXaY67*